Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 1: Somnath
The Gates of Somnath, 1842
The Insult of Eight Hundred Years
“My brothers and my friends,” the proclamation began. “Our victorious army bears the gates of the temple of Somnauth in triumph from Afghanistan.” It came from Lord Ellenborough, the Governor-General of India, at the end of the British war in Afghanistan, in November 1842. It was addressed “to all the princes and chiefs, and people of India.” The gates, it was believed, were the famous sandal-wood gates of Somnath, the temple on the coast of Gujarat. Mahmud of Ghazni, the sultan who had plundered Somnath eight hundred years before, had carried them off, and they had stood ever since at his tomb at Ghazni. “The insult of eight hundred years is at last avenged,” the proclamation said. The gates, so long the memorial of India’s humiliation, had become “the proudest record of your national glory.” The princes were to carry them, with honour, through their lands “to the restored temple of Somnauth.” But there was no restored temple. The temple of Somnath lay in ruins, and its holy ground was trodden by Muslims. The Duke of Wellington called the proclamation a “song of triumph.” Among Europeans, worldly men scorned it as a folly, and religious men denounced it as a crime.
The Gates of Somnath, 1842
A Line in a Letter
It had begun with a few words in a letter. On 4 July 1842 Ellenborough wrote to General Nott, whose army was in Afghanistan, giving him leave to bring it home to India by way of Ghazni and Kabul. He added: “You will bring away from the tomb of Mahmoud of Ghuznee, his club which hangs over it; and you will bring away the gates of his tomb, which are the gates of the Temple of Somnauth.” Where Ellenborough had heard of the gates, or who had put them in his mind, no one knows; history “cannot determine.” In Afghanistan the priests held the shrine in high esteem, and no priest and no one among the people doubted that the gates were truly Somnath’s. They had been wanted before. Ranjit Singh, the ruler of the Punjab, had once bargained with the exiled king of Kabul. One of his conditions was the gates, “being the same which were brought from Somnauth, in India, when that destroyer smote the Idol.” As a passage read to the House of Commons put it, eight hundred years had passed, “but the Hindoo still remembers it.”
The Gates of Somnath, 1842
Were They Somnath’s at All?
Rawlinson, who marched with Nott’s army and later won fame as a scholar of the ancient East, did not believe it. He copied an inscription on the tomb and talked long with its mullahs, the Muslim priests who kept it. The tomb, they told him, was built just after Mahmud’s death. When Genghis Khan threatened Ghazni, it was buried under earth to save it. Long after, a sultan of Timur’s line, shown the spot in a vision, dug it out again. The gates, they held, were Somnath’s. But one inscription, giving the exact date of Mahmud’s death, was “obviously of a much later age.” Rawlinson was sure that the tomb was no older than that later sultan: “The gates, therefore, are certainly not those of Somnauth.” It suited the mullahs to keep the belief alive, and give the place “the odour both of sandal and sanctity.” Still, he called them trophies: what mattered politically was that people believed in them. Years later the historian of architecture James Fergusson went further. To him the gates were not sandal-wood at all but deodar, the local pine. Their carving was like that of buildings in Cairo of the same age, with nothing Hindu about it. He concluded that the old tradition “is entirely disproved.”
The Gates of Somnath, 1842
“Aye, the Restored Temple!”
On 9 March 1843 the proclamation came before both Houses of Parliament, and Ellenborough’s critics moved to censure him. In the Commons, Macaulay, the member for Edinburgh, seized on its words. Ellenborough had sent troops, he said, to carry the gates “from a Mahometan mosque to a Hindoo temple, and place them on the restored temple of Somnauth.” The House cheered. “Aye, the restored temple!” he went on, to more cheers. “We all know that the temple is in ruins.” Either Ellenborough had not asked, or he had been told and meant to rebuild it. A governor, Macaulay said, must pay no homage to any religion of India and offer insult to none; Ellenborough had done both. Another member, Hume, quoted the account of an officer sent to visit Somnath, printed in 1838. The people were all Muslims, it said, and no service had been held in the temple for ages. Ellenborough, said Hume, had shown “an ignorance for which schoolboys would be whipped.” In the Lords, the Duke of Wellington defended him. As for the temple, “Nobody knows exactly what it is.” Ellenborough had “looked upon these gates merely as a symbol of triumph.” Both Houses voted the censure down.
The Gates of Somnath, 1842
The Breath of Our Nostrils
To J. W. Kaye, the historian of the war, “the folly of the thing was past all denial.” No state paper was ever met with so much ridicule; at first many took it for a newspaper’s joke. In India the “brothers and friends” it addressed were not stirred at all, and in Afghanistan the taking of the gates made little or no stir. The stir scarcely went beyond the priests. The gates had been taken on 8 September 1842, two months before the proclamation. That day a party of English soldiers took them down from Mahmud’s tomb, as gently as they could. Rawlinson was there. When the guardians saw what the soldiers had come for, they went to a corner of the courtyard and wept bitterly. When the gates were gone, they threw themselves down before the shrine again and lamented aloud. They said only this: “You are lords of the country, and can of course work your will on us; but why this sacrilege? Of what value can these old timbers be to you, while to us they are as the breath of our nostrils?” The reply was: “The gates are the property of India—taken from it by one conqueror, they are restored to it by another. We leave the shrine undesecrated, and merely take our own.” Rawlinson thought the mullahs, whose family had kept the tomb for generations, would suffer most. Told from J. W. Kaye, History of the War in Afghanistan, vol. III (1890 ed.), pp. 336-338 and 359-362, with Rawlinson’s notes; Hansard, the debates of 9 March 1843 on Lord Ellenborough’s proclamation (Commons, cols. 599-600, 618-620, 653 and 702; Lords, cols. 533-536 and 578-579); and James Fergusson, History of Indian and Eastern Architecture (1876), p. 496 and note. Fergusson names the mosque of Ibn Tulun at Cairo. The Commons rejected the censure by 242 votes to 157, the Lords by 83 to 25. Ellenborough’s own account, as the Marquess of Lansdowne gave it, was that the ancient temple had been destroyed and a similar but smaller Hindu temple built in its place. In the copy of Ranjit Singh’s letter printed for the Commons, the gates come from “Juggernaut,” which Emerson Tennent called an obvious mistake. Lieutenant Hoskins’s account appeared in the Asiatic Journal of October 1838.