Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 1: Somnath
The Idol of Somnath Broken
Laughter on the Walls
Somnath, on the sea shore of Gujarat, was Shiva’s temple of the “master of the moon.” The Hindus believed that every other idol in India was only its attendant. Mahmud, the Sultan of Ghazni, who turned many temples into mosques, led his armies there. The chronicler Ibn al-Athir tells what happened. Mahmud reached Somnath on a Thursday in the middle of the month Zi-l Ka’da, and saw a strong fortress built so close to the shore that the waves washed it. The people of the fort stood on the walls and made fun of the Muslim army below. Their god, they told them, would cut off the last man of them and destroy them all. On the Friday the army advanced to the assault. When the Hindus saw how the Muslims fought, they left their posts. The attackers set their ladders against the walls, reached the top and shouted their war cry. A fearful slaughter followed. A band of Hindus hurried to Somnath, threw themselves on the ground before him, and begged him to give them victory. Then night came, and the fighting stopped.
The Idol of Somnath Broken
Band After Band
Early next morning the battle began again. The Muslims drove the Hindus out of the town to the house of their god, and at the temple gate there was a dreadful slaughter. Band after band of the defenders went into the temple to Somnath. With their hands clasped round their necks they wept and begged him passionately. Then they went out again to fight until they were killed. Few were left alive. These took to the sea in boats, but the Muslims caught up with them; some were killed and some were drowned. In Ibn al-Athir’s count the slain were more than fifty thousand. The later historian Firishta tells a longer siege, of three days. In his account an army came to relieve the town, and Mahmud’s men began to give way. Mahmud leapt from his horse and lay face down before God, begging his help. Then he mounted, took one of his generals by the hand and rode at the enemy, and his troops, ashamed to leave their king, charged after him. Five thousand Hindus fell.
The Idol of Somnath Broken
The Dark Shrine and Its Riches
Mahmud went into the temple. It stood on fifty-six pillars of teak covered with lead. The shrine of the god was dark, but lit by chandeliers set with jewels. Near the idol hung a chain of gold with bells on it. At set hours of the night it was shaken, and the bells woke a fresh party of Brahmans to carry on the worship. The idol stood five cubits high, with two more hidden below the floor. It “had no appearance of having been sculptured.” Another history tells that every night the god was washed with fresh water carried from the Ganges, a river far away in the east of India. Five hundred dancing women served it, and kings sent their own daughters to its service. At an eclipse more than two hundred thousand pilgrims came, bringing offerings. When it was over, the plunder was beyond counting. Ibn al-Athir has more than two million dinars taken from the temple, and a treasury full of idols of gold and silver, hung with veils set with jewels. In Firishta’s telling, Mahmud found more jewels and gold there than any royal treasury had ever held.
The Idol of Somnath Broken
The Blow
In that other history, as soon as Mahmud’s eye fell on the idol, he lifted his battle-axe in great anger and struck it so hard that it broke into pieces. Firishta has him strike off its nose with his mace. A crowd of Brahmans came to his nobles and offered him several crores of gold coins if he would stop. Many of the nobles agreed: he could not get so much treasure by breaking the image. Mahmud answered that he knew this. But on the day of resurrection he wished to be called with the words “Where is that Mahmud who broke the greatest of the heathen idols?” He would not be called “that Mahmud who sold the greatest of the idols to the infidels for gold.” In Firishta he would not be remembered as “Mahmud the idol-seller”; he wished to be known as “Mahmud the destroyer.”
The Idol of Somnath Broken
Jewels in the Belly
Then, both histories say, the idol gave up a treasure. In Firishta, the next blow broke open its belly, which was hollow, and inside lay diamonds, rubies and pearls, worth far more than the Brahmans had offered. Later writers did not believe it. James Bird calls the story “the invention of some narrator, who loved fable more than truth.” The scholar H. H. Wilson wrote that the earlier Muslim writers say nothing of its face being broken, “for, in fact, it had none,” nor of treasure inside it, for it was solid. “Firishta invents the hidden treasure of rubies and pearls with quite as little warrant.” For Wilson, Somnath was a linga, the stone emblem of Shiva. H. M. Elliot, who quotes Wilson, adds that there were jewels on it all the same: Al-Biruni tells that its top was set with precious stones and gold.
The Idol of Somnath Broken
The Fall of Puttun
Another tale is told in a fragment of a Hindi poem which James Tod found in his travels in western India. In the poem, a pilgrim back from Mecca, the Hadji Mahmoud, comes to the town. He learns that a Muslim is offered to the idol every day. He offers himself in place of a widow’s only son. Before the temple’s brass bull he holds up the offering, and the bull eats. At his cry of “Allah Akber!” the emblem of Somnath vanishes. He sends word to Ghazni, and the Sultan’s failing sight comes back as he lifts the letter to his forehead. Then comes a siege of six months. A camel is sent ahead against the spiked gate, the gate bursts, and “rivulets of blood ran through the streets.” Seven hundred heroes make their last stand with their prince at the temple door, and the image is broken. Tod himself had no faith in the poem’s dates. He put Mahmud’s invasion in 1008 (or 1025), but the poem makes the prince of the town Kumarapala, a king who died in 1166.
The Idol of Somnath Broken
A Step at the Mosque Door
What became of the broken idol? Ibn al-Athir says Mahmud burnt part of it, and carried part to Ghazni, where he made it a step at the entrance of the great mosque. Another chronicler, Minhaj, says it was broken in four: one piece for the great mosque of Ghazni, one for the palace gate, one sent to Mecca and one to Medina. The poet Unsuri wrote a long ode on the victory. Al-Biruni, who gives the year as 416 H. (1025-26), tells it another way. Mahmud had the upper part broken, and the remainder carried to Ghazni with all its coverings of gold, jewels and embroidered cloth. Part of it was thrown into the town’s hippodrome. Another part lies before the door of the mosque of Ghazni, where people rub their feet on it to clean off the dirt and the wet. Told from Ibn al-Athir, the Tarikh-i Alfi, Minhaj’s Tabakat-i-Nasiri and H. M. Elliot’s note quoting H. H. Wilson, in Elliot and Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. II (1869), pp. 270 and 470-476; Firishta, History of the Rise of the Mahomedan Power in India, translated by John Briggs, vol. I (1829), pp. 42-44; James Bird, The Political and Statistical History of Gujarat (Mirat-i-Ahmadi) (1835), pp. 41-42; Al-Biruni’s India, translated by E. C. Sachau, vol. II (1888), pp. 102-103; and James Tod, Travels in Western India (1839), pp. 344-350. The chroniclers differ on smaller points too. Bird, like Ibn al-Athir, has the town taken on the second day, but with five thousand slain; Firishta’s fifty-six pillars are carved and set with precious stones, and Bird has six, set with jewels; Firishta and the Tarikh-i Alfi make the idol five yards high; Firishta has it washed twice a day, from a river more than a thousand miles off, and two or three hundred thousand pilgrims at an eclipse; the Tarikh-i Alfi puts the jewels inside it at more than a hundred times the Brahmans’ offer; the temple’s villages and Brahmans are ten thousand and a thousand in the Tarikh-i Alfi, two thousand each in Firishta; and the Tarikh-i Alfi and Bird have the pieces cast down before the mosque of Ghazni, while Firishta has the same four pieces as Minhaj.