Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 1: Somnath
The Ruin by the Sea
The City of the God
On 29 November 1822 James Tod, travelling in western India, at last came in sight of “perhaps the most renowned of all the shrines of India.” Its town was called Deva-Pattan, “the city of the god.” This was Somnath, on the sea shore of Gujarat, the temple that Mahmud of Ghazni had marched to destroy in 1025. Near the town he crossed the Triveni, where three streams meet: the Vrijini, the Sarasvati and the Hiranya, “the golden.” Beyond the last of them, the temple of Somnath with its pinnacle gone and the dark battlemented towers of the town rose out of green trees. They carried his mind back eight centuries, “to conquest and Mahmoud.” He had long hoped for this pilgrimage, and pressed on without stopping for breath. He entered the town by the gate of the sun. Its walls were built of great square blocks of freestone, darkened by the salt air, with a deep ditch all round. An inscription from a temple in the town showed that Kumarapala, king of Anhilwara and overlord of Saurashtra, had rebuilt them all, two centuries after Mahmud. The main gate was on the north: a triple gate, full sixty feet high, each portal set at right angles to the last. He took it for the place where the main attack of the Muslim warriors had fallen. Through the third gate, the great temple came into full view.
The Ruin by the Sea
The Shell of What It Was
“Behold me in the vestibule of Somnat’h.” The shrine was now “but the shell of what it was.” Its spire had fallen, and the fragments lay strewn on the ground. He believed it had survived at all only because the conquerors had turned it into a mosque, and that from the minarets of Muslim work at its entrance Mahmud’s muezzin had called the soldiers to give glory to God for the victory. He admitted that “we should think little of a cathedral in Europe no larger.” But its massive solidity, “as if constructed in defiance of time and human malevolence,” gave a truer sense of grandeur. “What then must it have been when its spire was the beacon of the mariner?” Round its base ran bands of carving: griffins, then elephants, then horses, then revellers. Above them, a few fragments still showed heavenly nymphs in a sacred dance. “The hammer of the Mooslem has deprived them of heads, arms, and legs,” yet some of the broken bodies were finely made. Even the dome over the hall was not the first. It was of brick. Its arch was built on a different principle from the Hindu design of the columns beneath it, and he judged that it was no part of the first building.
The Ruin by the Sea
Where the Linga Stood
The way to the sanctum was choked with rubble. People blamed the shock of cannon set on the temple roof, during the war, to keep off French privateers. He made his way through. The sanctum was a plain dark chamber. The spot where the linga, the stone emblem of Shiva, had stood was empty. In the western wall, facing Mecca, a pulpit had been cut for the mullah. The temple had once stood in the middle of a vast walled court, ringed with lesser shrines. These were now levelled, and mosques, walls and houses had been built from their rubble. The great mosque of the town had swallowed at least five of them, and its court a dozen more. And the temple itself stood on the wreck of older buildings. Where some of the facing had been removed from its base, he found a carved stone built into the foundation with its figures upside down.
The Ruin by the Sea
Other Eyes
Lieutenant Hoskins, an officer sent to visit Somnath, wrote of it in 1838. The whole population, he found, was Muslim, and no service had been held in the temple for ages. Later still, the historian of architecture James Fergusson studied the ruin from a plan and from photographs. To him it had never been large, but the dome of its porch was as big as any of its age, and its carving had been of great beauty. Its courtyard may have been splendid enough to justify all that was said of it. But was this the temple Mahmud had attacked, or a later rebuilding? In Fergusson’s day no one could yet say. As the story goes, it had been restored more than once after Mahmud left, last of all by Kumarapala in 1168, and most thought the ruin was his work. Yet to Fergusson a good part of the original temple seemed to remain, “though very much altered and knocked about by subsequent restorers.”
The Ruin by the Sea
Not Even a Name
To Tod, “nothing can surpass the beauty of the site.” The temple stands on a rock whose base is washed by the ocean. Before it the bay curves away to Veraval, its golden sands kept moving by the surf. He later saw many noble bays, “from that of Penzance to Salernum,” and none struck him more. Far off rise the peaks of Girnar. Round the town lay innumerable Muslim graves, and on the beach stood an Idgah, an open place of prayer for the festivals. He called Mahmud “the earliest and direst scourge which ever inflicted misery on a nation.” One might suppose that the story of that war would be written on every stone of the temple. With the help of his friend Mr. Williams, and every means they had, he searched the town for a single legend of Mahmud, spoken or carved. He found none. The sultan was “unknown alike by Brahmin, Banya, or Byrajee, as well as by Mooslem, even in name, within the city of the god.” To anyone who had read the chronicle of Firishta, the fallen stones of the pinnacle could be read like a book. To those whom they most concerned, they could not be read at all. Told from James Tod, Travels in Western India (1839), pp. 329, 335-344 and 351-353; Lieutenant Hoskins’s account in the Asiatic Journal (October 1838) as quoted by Hume in Hansard, the debates of 9 March 1843 on Lord Ellenborough’s proclamation, col. 653; James Fergusson, History of Indian and Eastern Architecture (1876), pp. 232-233; and the Gazetteer of the Bombay Presidency, vol. VIII, Kathiawar (1884), p. 607. The year of Mahmud’s attack is Fergusson’s; Tod gives 416 H. as 1008, and the Kathiawar gazetteer has him take the town in 1026. The gazetteer names the three rivers of the Triveni as the Sarasvati, Hiranya and Kapila. The measurements differ: Tod made the temple 117 feet long and seventy-four broad, Hoskins ninety-six by sixty-eight, and Fergusson, from Burgess’s plan, about 130 feet over all at most. Before Kumarapala, Fergusson writes, the temple was restored by Bhimadeva (1021-1073) and adorned by Siddharaja (1093-1143).