Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 2: Jagannath of Puri
1803-1840: The Company and the Pilgrim Tax
White-Robed Brahmans
In September 1803 a British army marched to occupy Orissa, then a Maratha province. The Marathas were Hindus, but the priests of Jagannath, the Lord of the World, at Puri, had learned to detest them for their endless extortion and plunder. Lord Wellesley, at the head of the Company’s government, had ordered the troops to respect the temple and the religious feelings of the Brahmans and pilgrims. The general sent these orders on to the priests. Where the Chilka lake pours through a narrow strip of sand into the sea, a couple of cannon and 300 men might have held the dangerous channel for days. Instead of an army, the general found a deputation of venerable Brahmans in white robes. They begged that their temple, the religious key to the province, be placed “under the protection of the British.” In the judgment of W. W. Hunter, the historian of Orissa, possession of the god had always given the rule of Orissa. Not a blow was struck. On 18 September the army camped in the shadow of the temple walls.
1803-1840: The Company and the Pilgrim Tax
Paying the God’s Bills
The Marathas had taxed the pilgrims harshly, with a toll at every ford and pass, and the British at first stopped the tax. For the temple, they simply took the Marathas’ place. The Marathas had paid no fixed sum, but had made up the gap each year between the temple’s receipts and its spending. For four years the British did the same, struggling, in Hunter’s words, through “the endless maze of chicanery” in the temple accounts. The Christian writer Claudius Buchanan printed the god’s yearly expenses from the official accounts. More than half went on the god’s table. The rest went on his dress, his elephants and horses, his car, his festivals and his servants; among them were the courtesans kept for the temple’s service. In June 1806, he was told, the three great cars of the yearly festival were decked with more than £200 worth of English broadcloth. Wellesley let the pilgrims in free, and would not sanction a tax. After he left, the government passed one, on 3 April 1806. Only one member of the council, George Udny, recorded his dissent. The others held the temple a lawful source of revenue; Buchanan believed it was on the principle that money from other temples had long gone into the treasury.
1803-1840: The Company and the Pilgrim Tax
At the Two Gates
Now guards stood at the only two ways into Puri and sorted the pilgrims into four classes. The richest, the Red Pilgrims, paid the most, and could go into the temple for thirty days, always with a panda, a temple guide, at their side. The fourth class could worship only outside the temple. With them were sixteen low castes who were not allowed into the temple at all: among them fishermen, boatmen, washermen, shoemakers and liquor sellers. Many went free: holy men of the ascetic orders, and the carriers of holy water from the Ganges. So did the people of Orissa, and every poor pilgrim who declared he could not pay. Only two-thirds of those counted paid, and those counted were seldom half of all who crept into the town unseen. Even so the tax was an important item in the Company’s revenue: in the twenty-one years to 1831, after the temple’s charges, it left £6,619 a year. In 1808 the government handed the running of the temple to the Raja of Khurda, heir of the ancient royal line of Orissa, whom the Marathas had grievously oppressed. Some Hindus in Orissa put a question to James Peggs, who campaigned against the tax. Did not the Sahibs go to Puri to worship Jagannath? Why should the Company destroy him? “He is their chakar,” their servant.
1803-1840: The Company and the Pilgrim Tax
Jagannath Comes Home Early
How far British power reached among the priests shows in a letter that Archdeacon Corrie, a churchman, wrote from Puri in 1823. About two years before, during a partial rising, the priests had given out that Jagannath would no longer suffer the English to stay in India. Once a year the god leaves his temple in a procession. This time, the priests said, he would not go back until the English were driven out, and they named a day for their overthrow. The general commanding the district took it as an attempt to help the rebels against the government. He sent a private order to the officer in charge at Puri. If the god was not carried back to his temple on the usual day, the officer was to put him back by force and take military possession of the temple. Corrie had no doubt that the Indians around the general warned the priests. “Juggernaut returned before his time.”
1803-1840: The Company and the Pilgrim Tax
The Pledges Kept
The tax made money, but it was felt to be in some measure “the price of a State sanction to idolatry,” and Christian missionaries never ceased to protest. In 1840 the Company abolished the pilgrim tax and gave up all connection with the temple, leaving the Raja of Khurda in full charge. The temple itself was forbidden to make pilgrims pay to enter or to perform their rites. Free entry and free worship became the right of every pilgrim. Yet the government kept the pledges Wellesley had given in 1803. It did not touch the temple’s ancient grants, and went on paying toward its expenses, later in land instead of money. On the strength of those pledges the priests had placed their temple under British protection. They were kept “so scrupulously as to give offence to many Christian men both in India and at home.” Told from W. W. Hunter, Orissa, vol. I (1872), pp. 122-126, and vol. II (1872), ch. VI, pp. 55-56; L. S. S. O’Malley, Puri (Bengal District Gazetteers, 1908), pp. 120-121; Claudius Buchanan, Christian Researches in Asia (1811), pp. 30-32; James Peggs, India’s Cries to British Humanity (1830), pp. 216-219 and 289-290, with Archdeacon Corrie’s letter of 1823; and A. Stirling, An Account of Orissa Proper or Cuttack (1822), in Asiatic Researches XV, p. 163. The temple’s yearly expenses in Buchanan are Rs 69,616 (£8,702); the shortfall the British met was some £3,000 a year (Hunter). Peggs dates the first regulations to January 1806, replaced in 1809 and 1810; Hunter has the Raja given the temple in 1808 with £6,000, O’Malley by Regulation IV of 1809, after a council of three pandits named in 1806. Peggs names the gates Attara Nala and Lokenath and gives rates from ten rupees down to two; Hunter gives 12s to £1 for the Red Pilgrims and 4s for the rest. If the Muslim historians’ figures are right, Hunter reckons, the Company’s tax was barely a fifteenth of what the people had paid before. Stirling counts from 33,446 to 131,874 pilgrims a year at the three great festivals in 1817-22. The law of 1840 was Act X (O’Malley); in 1845 the yearly payment was cut to Rs 23,321, the part found to stand for grants of the former Rajas of Berar and old temple dues.