Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 3: Keshavdev of Mathura
1018: Mahmud at Mathura
Two Hundred Years to Build
“If anyone should wish to build a building equal to this, he would not be able to do it without spending a hundred thousand thousand red dinars. And it would take two hundred years, even with the most able and experienced workmen.” So wrote Mahmud, the Sultan of Ghazni, of a temple he found in a holy city of India in 1018. The words were kept by Utbi, his secretary, in his history of the Sultan’s campaigns, though Utbi himself did not go on them. Utbi does not call the city Mathura; the historians who came after him do. To the historian F. S. Growse, this is the first record of Mathura written in its own time. By Utbi’s account, all of India but Kashmir had been conquered. Twenty thousand men from the lands beyond the Oxus, who were with the Sultan, longed for a holy war in which they might die as martyrs. So he set out with them for Kanauj, a journey of three months even for camels and horses.
1018: Mahmud at Mathura
Like a Comb Through Hair
He crossed six great rivers, from the Indus to the Sutlej, so deep that they hid even an elephant’s body. A chief who held the passes into Kashmir came to offer himself as guide, and led the way through forest after forest. The drum sounded for the march at midnight. In December 1018 they crossed the Yamuna. Then the Sultan marched on the fort of Kulchand, a raja whom no one had ever fought without being beaten. Kulchand drew up his army and elephants in a deep forest. The Sultan’s advance guard went through it “like a comb through a head of hair,” and swords and spears met at close quarters. When every effort failed, the defenders left the fort and tried to cross the foaming river behind it. Nearly fifty thousand men, by the secretary’s count, were killed or drowned and “became the prey of beasts and crocodiles.” Kulchand took his dagger, killed his wife, and then drove it into his own body. The Sultan took 185 elephants. Firishta tells it differently: Kulchand, the raja of Mahaban, came out to submit, a quarrel between the soldiers started the fight, and he killed his wife and children.
1018: Mahmud at Mathura
A City Built by Jinn
Near by stood the holy city. Its people said that one of its buildings had been made not by men but by jinn, spirits. Growse wondered whether their word was really Jina, the name of both the Buddhist and the Jain deity. The city wall was of hard stone, and two gates opened on the river, raised on high foundations against the floods. On both sides of the city stood a thousand houses with temples attached, all of masonry, bound from top to bottom with iron. In the middle rose a temple larger and stronger than all the rest, too fine to be described or painted. It was this temple that the Sultan said two hundred years would not build again. Firishta, a later historian of the Muslim kings of India, gives another line from the letter. “There are here a thousand edifices as firm as the faith of the faithful; most of them of marble.”
1018: Mahmud at Mathura
Five Idols of Red Gold
Among the idols were five of red gold, each five yards high, fixed in the air without support. One had two rubies for eyes, worth fifty thousand dinars. Another bore a sapphire purer than water and brighter than crystal. There were two hundred idols of silver, which could not be weighed until they had been broken in pieces. Nizamuddin, a later historian, names the city plainly: Mathura, the birthplace of Krishna, “whom the Hindus venerate as an incarnation of God.” No one came out to fight the Sultan there. His army plundered the whole city and set fire to the temples, and by his order a golden image was broken up. In later accounts the city was given up to plunder for twenty days. The spoil has been reckoned at three million rupees, and more than five thousand Hindus were carried away as captives.
1018: Mahmud at Mathura
Burnt with Naphtha
What became of the temples? Utbi’s answer is short. The Sultan gave orders that all of them should be “burnt with naphtha and fire, and levelled with the ground.” Firishta tells it another way. The Sultan broke or burned all the idols, and the city suffered greatly from fire as well as plunder. But he would have pulled down the temples too, had the labour not been too great; some say their beauty turned him from it. In Growse’s account, many temples were gutted of everything of value and left standing, probably because they were too massive to pull down easily. Some writers say the conqueror spared them for their beauty, and went home to build at Ghazni a splendid mosque named “the Celestial Bride.” Growse did not believe it was admiration that saved them. The gold and silver images, which Mahmud did not hesitate to break, must have been finer work still. Told from Utbi’s Tarikh-i Yamini, pp. 41-45, and Nizamuddin’s Tabakat-i Akbari, pp. 460-461, in Elliot and Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. II (1869); Firishta, History of the Rise of the Mahomedan Power in India, translated by John Briggs, vol. I (1829), pp. 34-35; and F. S. Growse, Mathura: A District Memoir (1883), pp. 32-33. Utbi dates the crossing of the Yamuna to the 20th of Rajab, 409 H. (2 December 1018, as Elliot gives it); Firishta and Growse make the year 1017. Utbi names the rivers as the Indus, Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej, and the guide as Sabli, son of Shahi; he calls the city Maharatu-l Hind. Firishta has 80 elephants taken. Utbi’s sapphire weighed 450 miskals, Firishta’s 400; Nizamuddin’s golden image weighed 98,300 miskals, and in Firishta the idol with the sapphire, melted down, gave as much pure gold; Firishta has more than a hundred silver idols that loaded as many camels. Firishta says the city belonged to the Raja of Delhi, for which, Elliot writes, there is no authority. Growse notes that the first accounts speak only of idolaters, a word that would fit Buddhists too.