Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 3: Keshavdev of Mathura
1666-1670: The Temple Pulled Down
“Remove the Railing”
“In the Muslim faith it is a sin even to look at a temple,” said the Emperor Aurangzeb. He had just learned that the temple of Keshav Rai at Mathura had a stone railing, given to it by a Muslim, Dara Shukoh. “And this Dara had restored a railing in a temple! This fact is not creditable to the Muhammadans. Remove the railing.” The court news-letter records it on 14 October 1666. By the Emperor’s order, the governor of Mathura took the railing away. Mathura was the birthplace of Krishna, a god for whom millions of Hindus felt a personal love. The city stood on the king’s highway between Agra and Delhi, and its lofty spires were almost visible from the palace at Agra. One account says the great temple’s gilded pinnacle could be seen from Agra itself. The temple of Keshav Rai had been built in the reign of the Emperor Jahangir by Bir Singh Deo, a Bundela raja, at a cost of thirty-three lakhs of rupees. It has been called “that wonder of the age.”
1666-1670: The Temple Pulled Down
A Religious Man as Governor
Aurangzeb had turned his eye on Mathura early. To repress its Hindus he made Abd-un-Nabi its governor, a man the court history calls “a religious man.” Soon after taking up his post, in 1661-62, Abd-un-Nabi built a great mosque in the heart of the city, on the ruins of a Hindu temple. It was he who took away the railing. In April 1669 the Emperor went further. His court chronicle tells why: he had heard that Brahmans taught their books in schools, at Benares above all. Muslims as well as Hindus came from far away to learn from them. He ordered the governors of all his provinces “to destroy with a willing hand the schools and temples of the infidels.” Their teaching and worship were to end. His hand now fell on the great shrines that Hindus all over India revered: among them the temple of Vishwanath at Benares, and the Keshav Rai temple of Mathura. The governors had no peace till they could tell the Emperor that the order had been carried out. Later his officers reported that the temple of Vishwanath had been destroyed.
1666-1670: The Temple Pulled Down
The Governor Shot
That same year the Jat peasants round Mathura rose, led by Gokla, a landholder of Tilpat. Abd-un-Nabi marched out against them. The chronicle tells the end: “He was at first victorious, and succeeded in killing the ringleaders. But in the middle of the fight he was struck by a bullet, and died the death of a martyr.” Gokla looted the country round, and the disorder spread to the Agra district. By the end of November the Emperor himself had to march out from Delhi. A new governor, Hasan Ali Khan, fought the rebel villages in December, and the next month he defeated Gokla. The rebels, 20,000 strong, mostly Jat peasants, charged “most gallantly,” but after a long and bloody fight they gave way before the discipline and the guns of the Mughal army. They fled to Tilpat, which held out for three days and was stormed. Gokla and his family were taken. On the platform of the police office at Agra his limbs were hacked off one by one, and his family was forcibly converted to Islam. To the historian F. S. Growse, the rising gave Aurangzeb “a fit pretext for a crusade against Hinduism.”
1666-1670: The Temple Pulled Down
In the Month of Ramazan
Before Aurangzeb struck at the temple, its ancient image of Keshavdev was carried away to Mewar. On the road the wheels of its chariot sank in deep sand and would not move. There, at a little village 22 miles from Udaipur, the image was set up. The town that has grown up round its temple is Nath-dwara, and its image is the most highly venerated of all the statues of Krishna. Then came the month of Ramazan, in the thirteenth year of the reign. The Emperor ordered the temple known as the Dehra of Keshav Rai to be pulled down. “His officers accomplished it in a short time.” On its site a grand mosque was built, at vast expense. That is the chronicle’s account, and the one told here. In Growse’s, Aurangzeb came down on Mathura in person, in February 1669, during the Ramazan fast.
1666-1670: The Temple Pulled Down
Trodden Underfoot
The chronicler gave thanks: “Praised be the God of the great faith of Islam.” In the reign of “this destroyer of infidelity and turbulence,” so marvellous and seemingly impossible a feat had been done. To Growse, the chronicler’s words showed that the fall of the temple was taken for a death-blow to Hinduism. The chronicle goes on: the Rajas saw the strength of the Emperor’s faith, and “felt suffocated and they stood in amazement like statues facing the walls.” In Growse’s English of the same words, the proud Rajas “felt their breath burning in their throats.” The idols of the temple, large and small, set with costly jewels, were carried to Agra. There they were buried under the steps of the mosque of Jahanara, “to be trodden upon continually.” Mathura itself was given a new name: Islamabad. In the chronicle, it was so called in all official papers, and by the people. Told from the Maasir-i Alamgiri in two translations: in Elliot and Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. VII (1877), pp. 183-185, and in Jadunath Sarkar, History of Aurangzib, vol. III (1916), pp. 320-321, which also gives the court news-letter (Akhbarat) of 14 October 1666; Sarkar’s own account, pp. 302-304 (with the Storia) and 332-335; and F. S. Growse, Mathura: A District Memoir (1883), pp. 36-37 and 130, with his list of the governors of Mathura. The Maasir dates the general order 17 Zi-l Ka’da 1079 (18 April 1669); Sarkar, 9 April 1669. Elliot’s translation puts Ramazan 1080 in December 1669, Sarkar’s in January 1670. Elliot’s has the temple “levelled with the ground,” Growse’s “with the help of numerous workmen … utterly broken down.” The mosque at Agra is the Nawab Begam Sahib’s in Elliot’s translation and Nawab Kudsia Begam’s in Growse’s; Elliot’s calls the builder Nar Singh Deo. Growse names the man who took the image away Ram Raj Sinh of Mewar, and the village Siarh, on the Banas; his list puts the temple’s fall in the time of Hasan Ali Khan. Growse dates the Jat rising to 1668 and Abd-un-Nabi’s mosque to 1661; he names the Jat leader Kokila and the place of the governor’s last fight Sahora, a reading he himself calls very uncertain (Sarkar: Bashara); and in his account Kokila was taken by the new governor’s deputy, Shaikh Razi-ud-din, and executed at Agra. Between Abd-un-Nabi and Hasan Ali Khan, Saf Shikan Khan was governor for a time. The 1669 order and the fall of the Vishwanath temple are told in full in the Kashi book of Stories of India's Ancient Cities, Part 5.