Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 3: Keshavdev of Mathura
Sikandar Lodi’s Mathura
Gods on the Butchers’ Scales
At Mathura, in the reign of Sultan Sikandar Lodi, the stone images of the temples were handed to the butchers. They used them as weights for their meat. So says a history of the Afghan kings of India, written in the reign of the Emperor Jahangir by a man who calls himself Abdullah. Sikandar ruled at Delhi from 1488 to 1516; the historian F. S. Growse counts him among the ablest kings ever to sit on the Delhi throne. Growse also found that between the invasion of Mahmud in 1017 and the reign of Akbar, not one building at Mathura, not even a fragment, can be given a date. Whenever the city drew an emperor’s notice, it was at once marked for plunder and desecration: “the more religious the sovereign, the more thorough the persecution.”
Sikandar Lodi’s Mathura
No Barber for a Hindu
In Abdullah’s account, Sikandar was so zealous a Muslim that he “utterly destroyed many places of worship of the infidels, and left not a single vestige remaining of them.” He “entirely ruined the shrines of Mathura, that mine of heathenism.” He turned their chief temples into caravanserais, the travellers’ inns, and colleges. Their stone images went to the butchers for meat-weights. All the Hindus of Mathura were strictly forbidden to shave their heads and beards, or to perform their ritual bathing. So he put an end to their rites there. No Hindu who wished to have his head or beard shaved could get a barber to do it. The historian Firishta adds the river. Sikandar had mosques and bazaars built facing the bathing stairs that led down to it, and ordered that no Hindu was to bathe there.
Sikandar Lodi’s Mathura
The Machine at the Ghat
A legend in a book of the lives of the devotees is set at a bathing place of Mathura, the Visrant Ghat. It names no sultan and no year. Kesav Bhatt was one of the most celebrated teachers of the Vaishnavas, the worshippers of Vishnu. He had beaten the most learned pandits of India in argument, until a child of seven asked him questions he could not answer. Then he went home to Kashmir, and lived there alone in devout meditation. News of the tyranny at Mathura roused him. In the legend, the Muslims had set up a machine at the Visrant Ghat that forcibly circumcised every Hindu who came there to bathe. Kesav Bhatt gathered a thousand of his disciples and went straight to the spot. The governor’s men fell on him, thinking to bring him too under the yoke of Islam. But he broke the machine to pieces and threw it into the river. Then an army was sent against him. Not a man of it escaped: most fell to his sword, and the rest were driven into the Yamuna and drowned.
Sikandar Lodi’s Mathura
Bought from the Butchers
In Growse’s judgment, the history of Mathura under Muslim rule is almost a blank: the rulers had no wish to be closely tied to such a “centre of superstition,” and the town lost all political importance. Hindu pilgrims still came to its impoverished shrines. But they were not invited to make, and the priests were not anxious to receive, any rich gift that would only stir the jealousy of the rival faith. Was Abdullah’s story of the butchers true? Growse thought there was proof of it on the ground. In 1661 the Muslim governor of Mathura, Abd-un-Nabi, built a great mosque, his first step towards the new city he virtually founded. The ground he chose was beyond question an old temple site. And it had to be bought from the butchers. Told from Abdullah’s Tarikh-i Daudi, in Elliot and Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. IV (1872), pp. 434-435 and 447; Firishta, History of the Rise of the Mahomedan Power in India, translated by John Briggs, vol. I (1829), the reign of Sikandar Lodi; and F. S. Growse, Mathura: A District Memoir (1883), pp. 33-34 and 142. Abdullah’s history runs from Bahlol Lodi, the first Afghan king, to Daud Shah, the last. Firishta also has Sikandar destroying Hindu temples and forbidding the barbers to shave the Hindus, so that they could not keep their customs of pilgrimage. In the Bhakt Mala, the child who silenced Kesav Bhatt was Chaitanya.