Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 5: Martand
Cunningham Measures Martand, 1848
The Sun Bursts Through
The ruined temple of the sun at Martand stands on a plateau in the valley of Kashmir. Alexander Cunningham, who wrote on the temples of Kashmir, thought it overlooked the finest view in Kashmir, and perhaps in the known world. Below it lay “the Paradise of the East,” with its sacred streams and cedar glens, its brown orchards and green fields, ringed by vast snowy mountains. That was the everyday view. But there were scenes now and then that could hardly be equalled. Once, when heavy clouds spanned the valley from side to side and hid the blue sky completely, he saw the evening sun burst suddenly out through the Baramula Pass. In an instant, as the verses in his essay tell it, gloom turned to brilliant light. From peak to peak, the whole length of the valley, the setting sunbeams poured down “such a blaze of golden light, / As filled the heart with joy unspeakable.” Then, as the sun went down, hill and dale, temple and tower and tree sank one by one into the night. Cunningham could almost fancy that this sunny prospect had first suggested building a temple to the sun here. From the temple the whole valley, sixty miles broad and more than a hundred long, lies within sight.
Cunningham Measures Martand, 1848
Measured by His Own Hand
Cunningham measured all the principal buildings of Kashmir himself in November 1847, and by his own account accurately. All were of a blue limestone that takes the highest polish, and he thought they mainly owed their fine state to that. Only one had a name of its own: Martand, which Kashmiris pronounce matan. “Of all the existing remains of Kashmirian grandeur, the most striking in size and situation is the noble ruin of Marttand.” It stands at the northern end of the plateau, three or four miles east of Islamabad. It was no more than forty feet high now, but its solid walls and bold outlines towered over the fluted pillars of the colonnade around it. “There are no petty confused details.” In the middle of a great courtyard rises one lofty building, with a small wing on either side of its entrance. Its walls are nine feet thick. Inside are three chambers, one behind the other. The first two are richly decorated. The innermost, the sanctuary, is perfectly plain and closed on three sides.
Cunningham Measures Martand, 1848
The Architectural Lion
Not everyone was carried away. James Fergusson, the historian of Indian architecture, called Martand “the architectural lion of Kashmir.” In his view all tourists thought they must go into raptures over it, and compare it to Palmyra or Thebes. But much of the admiration came from where it stood, alone on its plateau, with no tree or house in the way. Its ruins, shaken down “apparently by an earthquake,” lay where they fell, and a mystery hung over its origin. “When, however, we come to reduce its dimensions to scale,” he wrote, “the rhapsodies of which it has been the theme seem a little out of place.” The temple itself was “a very small building.” The pillars of the court were only nine feet high, “not dimensions to go wild about,” though their strongly Greek look was curious and interesting. He doubted Cunningham’s roof, too. Cunningham held that the heaps of large stones lying on every side could only have come from a stone roof. Fergusson pointed out that no roof fragments lay on the temple floor, and doubted that its thin walls could ever have carried a stone roof. He thought the roof had been of wood.
Cunningham Measures Martand, 1848
Eighty-Four Pillars
Cunningham read meaning into the courtyard itself. Its colonnade held eighty-four fluted columns, and he was sure that number had been chosen on purpose. To him eighty-four was above all the sun’s number: his seven rays, or the seven steeds of his chariot, times the twelve signs of the zodiac. So the pillars most probably stood for as many rays of the sun. “Thus even the colonnade is made typical of the Deity.” He had a second idea. Picture the whole courtyard, as he did, filled with water, up to a foot below the bases of the columns, with the temple rising out of it. From the gateway steps a raised path of stone slabs, set on blocks, would have run across the water to the temple steps. A drain by the gate kept the water at one level, and a canal brought along the mountainside from the river Lidar kept it fresh. He pointed out that other temples of Kashmir still stood in water in his day. Why build them so? He thought it was to place them under the protection of the Nagas, gods with human bodies and snakes’ tails, worshipped for ages all over Kashmir. Fergusson quoted Cunningham’s words on the water at length, and called it a feature common to all true Kashmiri temples.
Cunningham Measures Martand, 1848
A Sun or a Snake?
Was it the sun’s temple at all? Fergusson was not sure. To him its god was harder to settle than its date. Shown only its plan, he would unhesitatingly call it Jaina; once its water was explained, it would look as clearly Naga. He admitted he knew nothing of sun temples. Cunningham had taken the figures in the temple’s niches for the Sun and, probably, his wives. Fergusson read them otherwise. The stone was so crumbly that by his day the carvings were barely recognisable. But from such photographs as there were, he made out snake-hoods on all the chief figures in the niches. They were Nagas, with three- or five-headed snakes at the backs of their heads. In his view anyone on the spot could settle it in a few minutes. But no one had yet come prepared to do it. A full study of the temple would be worth any pains an Indian archaeologist might give it. Many of its details were of great beauty, and had never been drawn with the care they deserved.
Cunningham Measures Martand, 1848
Lit by the Setting Sun
Cunningham, who had measured those chambers himself, read the sun into them. Over each side door of the first chamber was a niche with a bust of the Hindu triad. He took it for one more sign of the Sun, who is Brahma the Creator at morning, Vishnu the Preserver at noon, and Shiva the Destroyer at evening. In the larger niche by the doors he took the figure to be the Sun himself, and those beside it perhaps some of his wives, the Moon, Intellect or Brightness. Beyond lay the sanctuary, quite plain. He thought this was perhaps so that nothing should draw the worshipper’s mind from the god. He found that not a trace of the image had escaped the destructive zeal of the Muslims. But he had little doubt that it had held the Sun-god, Martanda, in his chariot, drawn by seven horses or by four, green or yellow. By day the sanctuary took its light from half-round openings over the closed doors on its three sides. But the entrance faced west. And in the evening, as Cunningham pictured it, the image of the glorious Sun was lit by his own setting beams. Told from Alexander Cunningham, An Essay on the Arian Order of Architecture (1848), pp. 3, 18, 23-24 and 26-34; and James Fergusson, History of Indian and Eastern Architecture (1876), pp. 285-291. Cunningham gives the central building as 63 feet long and the courtyard as 220 feet by 142; Fergusson gives the building as 60 feet by 38. Cunningham dated some temples of Kashmir to the end of the fifth century, and one to 220 BC.