Great Temples Through the Ages · Part 5: Martand
Sikandar and Suhabhatta
The Stones That Would Not Fall
In the valley of Kashmir stood the temples of Martand, which W. R. Lawrence, writing on Kashmir, called grand. Sultan Sikandar, who came to the throne of Kashmir in 1394, set out to pull them down. In Lawrence’s account, for one whole year a large body of men was kept at work on the demolition of Martand. The massive masonry resisted every effort. At last fire was put to it, and the noble buildings were “cruelly defaced.” Martand was only one of many. Lawrence saw an “intense zeal” in Sikandar’s destruction of the grand old temples that the Hindu kings had left to Kashmir. He thought him brave and cultured, but all his good qualities “warped by his gloomy fanaticism.” Two older histories tell how the breaking of the temples began, and each puts a minister at the king’s side.
Sikandar and Suhabhatta
The Councillor Suhabhatta
The first is the chronicle of Kashmir’s kings written by Jonaraja. Among Sikandar’s close councillors was Suhabhatta. He cared nothing for the duties the Vedas lay down, and he had been taught by the mlechchhas, the foreigners. To Jonaraja, Kashmir had been polluted by the evil ways of the mlechchhas, and the Brahmans, the mantras and the gods had lost their power. In his telling the gods, for the country’s sin, withdrew from their images, and the images became mere stones. And as a crystal turns red or white or black with whatever lies near it, so the king changed. Suhabhatta urged him to break the images of the gods, and the king forgot his duties as a king and took delight, day and night, in breaking them. Among the images he broke, Jonaraja names first that of Martanda. As others fell, the world trembled as if in fear; but not the mind of the wicked king. There was no city, no town, no village, no wood, where “Suha the Turushka” left the temples of the gods unbroken. Turushka is the chronicle’s word for a Turk. Of the images that had once been there, only the names were left. And Suhabhatta felt the satisfaction of a man who has recovered from an illness.
Sikandar and Suhabhatta
Firishta’s Minister
The historian Firishta tells the same years another way. In his account the king’s minister is a Brahman named Seeva Dew Bhut, whom Sikandar made prime minister. This man became a Muslim, and then so fierce a persecutor of Hindus that he had the king forbid anyone but Muslims to live in Kashmir. Last, he had every image of gold and silver broken, melted down and struck into coin. Many Brahmans poisoned themselves rather than give up their religion or their country. Some left their homes; a few escaped exile by becoming Muslims. When the Brahmans had gone, Sikandar ordered every temple in Kashmir thrown down. One temple of Shiva could not be destroyed, because its foundation lay below the water beside it. At another, when the men dug into the foundation, the earth poured out fire and smoke, and the Hindus called it a sign of God’s anger. Sikandar watched, and did not stop until the building was razed to the ground and its foundations dug out.
Sikandar and Suhabhatta
The Copper Plate
Elsewhere, in Firishta’s account, stood a temple built by a raja. When it had been levelled and the diggers reached its foundation, they found a copper plate. The raja, it said, had asked his astrologers how long his temple would last. After eleven hundred years, they told him, a king named Sikandar would destroy it, and the other temples of Kashmir too. The king was surprised, and vexed that the Hindu prophet had foretold the truth. Had they set the plate up against the wall, he said, he would have spared the temple, to prove the prophet wrong. Lawrence heard of such stones too, and of the king’s grim answer: he had no wish to fulfil the predictions of an idolatrous people. For breaking all the images in Kashmir Sikandar was called the Iconoclast, “Destroyer of Idols,” as Firishta has it; Lawrence gives the name as Butshikan. The stones were put to use. Sikandar laid the plinths and friezes of the old temples into the city’s embankments and the foundation of the Jama Masjid. Alexander Cunningham, who wrote on the temples of Kashmir, found that the tomb of Sikandar’s own queen in Srinagar stood on the foundation of a Hindu temple and was built of its stones.
Sikandar and Suhabhatta
Death, Conversion or Exile
Then Sikandar turned on the people who had worshipped in the temples, and gave them three choices: death, conversion or exile. Many fled, many were converted, and many were killed. It is said that he burnt “seven maunds of sacred threads” of the murdered Brahmans. Every book of Hindu learning he could lay hands on was sunk in the Dal lake. Jonaraja tells of an attack on caste. Suhabhatta and the leaders of the army tried to destroy the caste of the people. The Brahmans said they would die if they lost it, and Suhabhatta fined them heavily for holding to it. Some of Suhabhatta’s dependents, Brahmans and others, gave up their caste to win the king’s favour. Jonaraja praises the few who did not, above all Nirmalacharya, who gave up all his property as if it were grass rather than take the king’s favour at that price. Jonaraja held that a master answers for his servant’s faults, and so, for Suhabhatta’s fault, Death grew angry with the king. Sikandar crowned his eldest son, and died; Firishta gives the year as 819 H., Cunningham as 1416.
Sikandar and Suhabhatta
Open to the Sky
What brought Martand down? Cunningham, who had blown up a fort himself, thought only gunpowder could overturn such temples so completely. He had seen it tear every part of a building from every other and turn the stones over, which no earthquake does. And he supposed that Sikandar might have had it. Dr. Stein thought otherwise: others had doubted so early a use of gunpowder in Kashmir, and rightly. Earthquakes and the poor fitting of the stones, seen in every Kashmiri temple, were in his view enough to explain the ruin, massive as the stones were. When the traveller G. T. Vigne saw the temple of Martand, its inner chamber, five yards long, stood between blank walls, open to the sky. To him, every trace of a roof had long since gone “beneath the shocks of earthquakes and the unsparing hand of Sikundur But Shekun.” Told from the Rajataranginis of Jonaraja and Shrivara, translated by J. C. Dutt (1898), pp. 58-61; Firishta, History of the Rise of the Mahomedan Power in India, translated by John Briggs, vol. IV (1829), pp. 464-466; Alexander Cunningham, An Essay on the Arian Order of Architecture (1848), pp. 4-5; W. R. Lawrence, The Valley of Kashmir (1895), pp. 190-191, with Stein quoted in his note; and G. T. Vigne, Travels in Kashmir, vol. I (1842), p. 389. Lawrence also names Muhamad Khan Hamadani, successor of the famous Shah Hamadan, among the learned Muslims at Sikandar’s court, who “added fuel to the fire” of his zeal; the travellers Trebeck and Moorcroft, as Cunningham quotes them, tell of a traditional attempt by Shah Hamadan himself to destroy Martand: “It is fortunate he was not acquainted with the use of gun-powder.” Jonaraja names the other images broken (Vishaya, Ishana, Chakrabhrit, Tripureshvara, the Shesha, Sureshvari, Varaha), and those who kept their caste (the merchants Shri Simha and Bhattakasthula besides Nirmalacharya); Firishta names the surviving temple as Maha Dew’s in Punjhuzara, the burning one as Jug Dew’s, and the builder of the prophesied temple as Raja Bulnat, and adds bans on the forehead mark and on widows burning with their husbands. Jonaraja dates Sikandar’s death to the eighth day of Jyaishtha “in the year 89”; Firishta gives 819 H., after a reign of nearly twenty years; Cunningham, 1416; Lawrence speaks of twenty-five years of power. Cunningham, who also cites Abul Fazl and Firishta for temples still standing in their day, held that Sikandar most likely ordered all the temples overturned, and that many of the chief ones fell in his reign, but that some still stand.