Stories of Ancient India
As a King
Watching the River
East of the river Hydaspes, the Jhelum of today, an Indian king “had been watching the immense peril come near”. He learnt that his old enemy, the king of Taxila, had made an alliance with the Yavana conqueror, Alexander of Macedon; Yavanas was the Indian name for the Greeks. He learnt that other princes were submitting, even a kinsman of his own further east. “In that moment of fear” the king “rose unshaken in the resolve” to settle the matter by arms. This was in 326 BC, in the Punjab, and the story is told by the Greek and Roman writers of Alexander’s wars. India has long forgotten the king’s name. “We know of him only through the Greek books which call him Porus.” The historian Bevan thinks Porus did not fight for India: “it was his own honour and his own kingdom.” “And yet,” he adds, “India may well reckon the proud and brave prince among her national heroes.”
As a King
The Proud Answer
Taxila was a great and flourishing city, the greatest between the Indus and the Hydaspes. Its king, Ambhi, had received Alexander as a friend. He was at war both with Porus and with a hill raja, his neighbour, and he wanted Alexander’s help against them. Plutarch gives the words Ambhi is said to have greeted him with. “Why should we two, Alexander, fight with one another,” he asked, “if you have come to take away from us neither our water nor our necessary food?” Gifts passed both ways, and Alexander added a thousand talents. His own officers were displeased. In Curtius’s account one of them, drunk at supper, congratulated the king on having found in India, if nowhere else, someone worthy of a thousand talents. The hill raja played a double game. He sent his brother to Taxila with presents and his submission, and meanwhile prepared to send troops to Porus. In Curtius’s telling, Alexander sent an envoy to Porus with orders to pay tribute and to come and meet his sovereign at the frontier of his kingdom. Porus answered that he would do the second. He would meet Alexander when he entered his realm, “but come armed for battle.”
As a King
The River in Flood
From Taxila the army marched to the Hydaspes. The hot season was at its height. When the army arrived, early in May by the historian V. A. Smith’s reckoning, the river was already in flood with the melting snows of the hills. The boats used on the Indus had been cut into sections, carried on wagons and pieced together again on its bank. On the far side stood Porus, with all his army and his elephants. From that bank the Indians could make out the royal tent, and “even the figure of the marvellous man himself moving to and fro among his captains”. They could see, too, five thousand of their own countrymen, sent by Ambhi to fight on the Macedonian side. “Nothing divided the Indian army from the conquerors of the world but the breadth of the Hydaspes.” Alexander saw that he could not cross where Porus stood. His horses would refuse to climb the far bank with the elephants there. At the very sight and roaring of them they would go frantic and leap into the water.
As a King
Nights of Alarm
Alexander set out to deceive. He gave out that he would wait for the cold season, when the river would fall. He had provisions brought into camp from all the country round, as if for a long halt. His boats kept moving up and down the stream, and his troops from place to place. Porus could not settle his defence “at any one point”. Then came the noise by night. Alexander led his cavalry out along the bank in the dark. They raised the war-shout and filled the shore with every kind of noise, as if they were about to cross. Porus marched his elephants along the other bank towards the sound. Across the water the Indians heard shouted commands and the songs the Yavanas sang in battle to their own gods. At the sound the great elephants would “swing through the darkness to their stations”, and the lines of Indians stand ready with sword and bow. “And still nothing happened.” In time Porus stopped moving when the cavalry came out, and kept to his lines. “The night alarm became almost a piece of routine.” In Smith’s reckoning the feints went on for six or seven weeks. The rains broke, and the flood grew worse.
As a King
With So Much History
Some sixteen or seventeen miles from the camp there was a bend in the river where a wooded bluff faced an island overgrown with jungle. Both could screen a crossing, and there Alexander chose to cross. He left Craterus, one of his generals, in the main camp with a large force and Ambhi’s five thousand. His orders turned on one thing. If Porus took all his elephants away against Alexander, Craterus must cross at once, “for it is the elephants only which make it impossible for the horses to land on the other bank.” Alexander marched by night with a picked force, keeping well back from the bank. A violent storm of rain and thunder broke and drowned the rattle of arms and the shouted orders. Plutarch, from Alexander’s own letters, says some of his men were struck dead by the lightning. Towards daybreak the wind dropped and the rain stopped, and the boats, hidden until then in the woods, pushed off. One galley carried Alexander with his officers Ptolemy, Perdiccas, Lysimachus and Seleucus. Each would one day rule great lands of his own: Ptolemy as king of Egypt, Seleucus as heir to Alexander’s empire in Asia. “With so much history was one boat big.”
As a King
An Island, Not the Shore
They were not seen until they had passed the island and were near the bank. Then Porus’s sentries galloped off at full speed to carry the news. Alexander was the first ashore, and formed his horsemen into line as they landed. But he did not know the ground. He had landed not on the mainland but on another island, so large that no one took it for one. The rain of the night had swollen the channel behind it, and for a time no ford could be found. If none was found, they were caught in a trap. At last a ford was found. Where it was deepest, the water came above the breasts of the foot soldiers, and of the horses only the heads showed above the river. It was here, the Greek writer Onesikritos says, that Alexander cried out: “O Athenians! can you believe what dangers I undergo to earn your applause?” Plutarch, who quotes him, adds that Alexander’s own letters say only that they left their rafts and waded through under arms, with the water up to their breasts.
As a King
The Son of Porus
Porus could not yet tell where the main attack would come, for the enemy camp was still in sight across the river, as before. Curtius says that at first he hoped the troops on his bank were his ally the hill raja, come as agreed. He sent his son with horsemen and chariots to stop them. They met first the horse archers, men from the steppes of Central Asia who could shoot at full gallop. Then Alexander charged with his cavalry, squadron after squadron, and the Indians gave way. Four hundred of their horsemen fell, and the son of Porus among them. Curtius says it was his brother, Hages, who led them. The rain had made the ground slippery, and the heavy chariots stuck in the mud; they were all taken, horses and all. The fugitives brought Porus the news: Alexander himself had crossed, and his son was dead. Still Porus hesitated, for the troops opposite seemed to be crossing too. At last he left a few elephants and a small force to hold the bank, and marched with the rest of his army against Alexander.
As a King
Towers in a Wall
He found a place where the ground was sandy, flat and firm, and drew up his army. In front stood the elephants, at least a hundred feet apart. The foot stood behind them and between them, the horse on the wings, with the chariots before them. Porus counted on it that no horseman would dare to ride in between the elephants. To Diodorus the army had “very much the appearance of a city—the elephants as they stood resembling its towers”. How big it was the writers do not agree: their counts of the foot run from about 30,000 to more than 50,000, and of the elephants from 85 to 200. Nor do they agree on when it was fought. Smith puts the battle at the beginning of July 326 BC, Bevan, keeping the Greek writer Arrian’s own date, about the middle of May. In Curtius’s account an image of Hercules was carried before the foot, and death was the penalty for failing to bring it back from the field. Porus himself sat in the midst of his army on an elephant of exceptional size. His armour left nothing bare but his right shoulder, and he was “visible to all and surveying all”. The drums beat. In the same account the elephants were so used to them that the sound did not alarm them.
As a King
A Danger That Matches My Courage
The sight made the Macedonians pause. In Curtius’s telling, from a distance the elephants looked like towers, and Porus stood taller than other men, as his elephant towered over the rest. Alexander studied the king and his army, and said to those near him: “I see at last a danger that matches my courage. It is at once with wild beasts and men of uncommon mettle that the contest now lies.” The Indian foot had a fearsome weapon. In Arrian’s description of the Indians, their bow was as long as the man who carried it. He rested it on the ground, pressed against it with his left foot and drew the string far back. “There is nothing which can resist an Indian archer’s shot—neither shield nor breastplate.” But that day the ground was slippery with rain. The archers could not set their bows firmly on it, and the horsemen were on them before they could shoot.
As a King
Like Ships Backing Water
Alexander would not strike at the centre, where the elephants stood. He led his cavalry against the Indian left: first his thousand horse archers, with storms of arrows, and then his own charge. The Indian horse rode to meet him. Then Coenus, one of his cavalry generals, sent off for the purpose with two regiments, appeared behind them. Caught between the two, the Indian horse broke and “fled for shelter to the elephants as to a friendly wall”. The drivers urged the elephants on, but the phalanx, the close-packed Macedonian foot, met them with darts. The beasts charged into it, and wherever they turned they crushed through its ranks. In Curtius’s account the most dismal sight of all was the elephants seizing men in their trunks, arms and all. They lifted them over their heads and handed them to their drivers. The Macedonians hacked at the animals’ feet with axes. Penned in at last, the elephants trampled their own side as much as the enemy. Exhausted, in Arrian’s words, they “fell back like ships backing water, and merely kept trumpeting as they retreated with their faces to the enemy.”
As a King
Not After the Manner of Darius
Then Alexander ringed the whole Indian line with his cavalry, and his foot came on with their shields locked. In Bevan’s words, “what followed was not fighting, but butchery.” Those who broke through the ring of horse met the men of Craterus, who had crossed the river fresh and cut them down. Two sons of Porus were among the dead, and the Greek counts of the Indian dead run from twelve thousand to more than twenty thousand. Arrian counts Alexander’s own dead at about three hundred and ten; Diodorus, 280 horse and more than 700 foot. In Arrian’s judgment, Porus had played the part not only of a general but of a gallant soldier. Darius, the great king of Persia, had fled from Alexander. Porus did not, “after the manner of Darius”, abandon the field and show his men the first example of flight. He fought on as long as he saw any Indians still holding together. Diodorus says he gathered round him forty elephants still under control and fell on the enemy, killing many with his own hand. The javelins he threw flew almost like shots from a catapult, and Alexander ordered every archer to aim at him. In Arrian’s account, at last he was wounded in the right shoulder, the one place his armour left bare, and he turned his elephant and began to withdraw.
As a King
The Hated Face
In Arrian’s telling, Alexander wanted to save his life, and the first man he sent after Porus was Ambhi. Ambhi rode as near the elephant as seemed safe and called on Porus to stop and hear Alexander’s message. Porus saw the “hated face” of his old enemy, turned in his seat, and threw a javelin with what strength his wounded arm had left. Ambhi galloped out of reach. Curtius tells it more fiercely. In his account it was Ambhi’s brother who came. “I recognise the brother of Taxiles, who gave up his throne and kingdom,” Porus said; Taxiles was the Greeks’ name for the king of Taxila. He flung his one remaining dart so hard that it went through the man’s back to his chest. Arrian’s account goes on. Alexander sent messenger after messenger. Last came an Indian who was an old friend of Porus. By then Porus was overcome with thirst. He halted his elephant and got down, and when he had drunk and felt revived, he asked to be taken to Alexander. Others end it otherwise. Diodorus says Porus, drained of blood by his wounds, fainted and was borne to the ground. Curtius gives him nine wounds and has him lifted onto a wagon after he was thought dead, and Smith too has him taken prisoner fainting.
As a King
As a King
Alexander rode out in front of his line with a few companions to meet him. In Arrian’s account he looked with admiration at the handsome, majestic figure. Porus did not seem broken in spirit; he came on as one brave man meets another, after fighting for his kingdom. Alexander spoke first, and asked how he wished to be treated. “Treat me, O Alexander! as befits a king,” Porus said. Pleased, Alexander answered that for his own sake it would be so, and asked him to name what he wished for himself. Porus replied that everything was included in what he had asked: “When I said ‘As a king’, everything was contained in that.” Plutarch gives the answer the same way. Curtius makes a speech of it. His Porus used to think no one braver than himself, but “the result of the war has taught me that you are the braver man.” He asks to be treated by the lesson of a day that shows “how readily prosperity can be blasted”. McCrindle, the translator of these writers, thinks Curtius has spoiled “the simple and dignified answer” with rhetoric.
As a King
Perhaps Porus
Alexander gave Porus back his kingdom and added to it other lands still larger. In return he found him faithful in everything. Porus had to live at peace with Ambhi now, and in Bevan’s view that was probably what he found most bitter. On the battlefield Alexander founded a city, Nicaea, for his victory. Where he had set out to cross the river he founded another, Bucephala, named for his old horse Bucephalus, who died there. When Alexander left the Punjab he posted no Macedonian garrisons there, but gave the care of his interests to “king Poros”, with Ambhi as his colleague. About 317 BC one of Alexander’s officers, left in command of a garrison on the Indus, went away from India, taking with him 120 elephants. He had obtained them “by treacherously slaying a native prince, perhaps Poros, with whom he had been associated as a colleague.” That “perhaps” is as far as Smith will go. So Porus is known only from the Greek books. It would have seemed a strange fate to him, had any astrologer foretold it. His fate was “to pass quickly out of the memory of his own people, and to be a familiar name for centuries in lands of which he had no conception, away to the West!” Told from V. A. Smith, The Early History of India, 4th ed., revised by S. M. Edwardes (1924), chs. III and V, and Bevan’s chapter XV in The Cambridge History of India, vol. I, ed. E. J. Rapson (1922). The march, the crossing and the battle are from Arrian, Anabasis V 8-19 and Indika 16; Curtius VIII 12-14; Diodorus XVII 87-89; and Plutarch, Life of Alexander 59-60; all in J. W. McCrindle, The Invasion of India by Alexander the Great (1893), with his notes.