Stories of Ancient India
Here Alexander Stopped
A Long Silence
The king had finished speaking, and no one answered. Alexander of Macedon had called his officers together on the bank of the Hyphasis, the river Beas of today, and urged them to cross it and go on. It was the fifth river they had come to in the Punjab. Then “a long silence followed”. No one dared to speak against the king, and no one wished to agree. Again and again Alexander asked for anyone to speak, even against him. The silence went on. This was in 326 BC, in the Punjab, and the story is told by the Greek and Roman writers of Alexander’s wars. The men in that silence had crossed from Europe with Alexander eight years before. On the river Hydaspes they had beaten the Indian king Porus, and Porus now fought on their side.
Here Alexander Stopped
What Lay Beyond
Arrian has Alexander hear that beyond the river lay a fertile land of good farmers, brave in war, ruled by an aristocracy that “exercised their authority with justice and moderation”. Its people had more elephants than other Indians, and larger and braver ones. The news only made him more eager. Curtius and Diodorus say instead that a desert of eleven or twelve days’ march lay beyond the river. Further on lay the Ganges. A local raja told him of the great king there, whom the historian V. A. Smith takes for one of the Nanda kings of Magadha, at Pataliputra. The reports gave that king 200,000 foot, and elephants by the thousand. Alexander could not believe it, and asked Porus. Porus said the numbers were true, but that the king was worthless and despised. Curtius has Porus add that the king’s father was a barber, whom the queen loved and who murdered the king. The historian Bevan asks whether it was sane to try to conquer such a country with an army nearly three thousand miles from home. He believes Alexander’s success had made nothing seem impossible to him, and that “his judgment of things was no longer completely sane.”
Here Alexander Stopped
Toils upon Toils
The army had had enough. The Macedonians lost heart “when they saw the king raising up without end toils upon toils and dangers upon dangers.” Men met and talked. The milder grieved over their lot; others said they would follow no farther, “though Alexander himself should lead the way.” Diodorus tells what they had to grieve over. Death had thinned their ranks. Their horses’ hoofs were worn away by endless marching, and their weapons were worn out. Their Greek clothes were threadbare, and they had to cut new ones from Indian cloth. For seventy days violent storms of rain had burst on them, with thunder and lightning. Alexander tried gifts. In the same account he let the soldiers plunder the rich country round. While they were away, he called together their wives and children, and promised the women a monthly allowance of food and the children pay by their fathers’ rank. Then, before the trouble could spread, he called together the officers in command of the brigades, and spoke to them.
Here Alexander Stopped
The King’s Speech
Arrian gives the speech at length. Alexander ran through the lands they had won, from the Hellespont to Egypt, Babylon and Persia, and now the Indus and the Hydaspes. Why should they hesitate to cross the Beas too? “For my part,” he said, “I think that to a man of spirit there is no other aim and end of his labours except the labours themselves.” The Ganges and the Eastern Sea were not far, he told them, and the great Ocean flowed round the whole earth. If they turned back now, the nations left unconquered might stir the conquered to revolt. “Life, signalised by deeds of valour, is delightful,” he said, “and so is death, if we leave behind us an immortal name.” He had shared their dangers, and the land and its treasure were theirs. Any who wished to go home he would send home; those who stayed he would make “objects of envy to those who go back.” In Curtius’s telling, not one soldier would answer. The officers kept their eyes fixed on the ground. Then “there arose, no one knew how, first a sighing and then a sobbing”, until the whole assembly was weeping, and even the king could not keep back his tears.
Here Alexander Stopped
Coenus Speaks
In Arrian’s account Coenus at last found the courage to speak. He was the cavalry general who had led the charge against Porus. He would speak, he said, not for the officers, who had been well rewarded, but “in behalf of the great body of the army.” The king could see how many had set out and how few were left. Some had been sent home, some settled unwillingly in the new cities, some killed in battle or crippled by wounds; most had died of disease. Those left had lost their strength, and their spirit even more. They longed to see their parents, their wives and children, “were it but their native land itself.” Let the king lead them home and see his mother again, and then, if he wished, come back with young men, for whom war still held no terrors. He ended: “Moderation, in the midst of success, is, O king! the noblest of virtues, for though, at the head of so brave an army, you have nothing to dread from mortal foes, yet the visitations of the deity cannot be foreseen.” Smith thinks the speech in substance a genuine report of a real speech. In Curtius, Coenus takes off his helmet to speak, and asks: “Which of us has a horse?”
Here Alexander Stopped
Three Days in the Tent
The officers answered with loud applause, and many with streaming tears. Alexander resented the freedom of Coenus’s words. He broke up the meeting, and the next day called the officers back. He would go on, he told them, with any who would follow him of their own free will. The rest could go home and tell their friends that they had left their king in the midst of his enemies. Then he shut himself in his tent and saw no one until the third day. “The battle of wills remained in grim deadlock.” In Arrian’s account Alexander was waiting for the soldiers to change their minds. But a deep silence lay over the camp. He offered sacrifice for the crossing, as his officer Ptolemy records, and the omens were against it. Smith says the soothsayers “judiciously discovered” that they were unfavourable; Bevan thinks Alexander did it “to save his face probably”. He told the army that he would march back; Smith dates the order to September 326 BC, Bevan the turn back to about the end of July. The soldiers shouted for joy, and many wept. Some came to his tent and called down blessings on him, “because by them and them only did he permit himself to be vanquished.”
Here Alexander Stopped
Twelve Altars
To mark how far he had come, Alexander had the army build twelve altars, each as high as the highest war towers, and broader. They were thank-offerings to the gods who had led him so far as a conqueror, and a memorial of his labours. He sacrificed on them and held games. Then he gave all the country west of the Beas to Porus to govern. Curtius and Plutarch add something less noble. Curtius says he had the camp walls drawn out wide and left couches too large for ordinary men, to astonish later ages “by deceptive wonders”. Plutarch adds arms, stalls and bridles made far beyond the usual size. Smith calls such tales “a ridiculous addition designed to gratify the king’s childish vanity.” The kings of the Prasii, Plutarch says, “even to the present day hold in veneration” those altars, and cross the river to sacrifice on them in the Greek fashion. By Smith’s day the river had cut back its bank and swept away every trace of them. A late writer, Philostratus, tells of a brass column there inscribed “Here Alexander stopped”. He supposed the Indians beyond the river had put it up, to their own glory, for having stopped him.
Here Alexander Stopped
Ten Thousand Brides
The army marched back the way it had come. On the way Coenus fell ill and died. Alexander grieved. But in Curtius’s account he could not keep from remarking that Coenus had made a long speech for the sake of a few days, “as though he alone were destined to see Macedonia again.” Then Alexander went down the rivers towards the Ocean. At times he landed and attacked the towns along the banks. Further down a strong league of free tribes was waiting for him “with a high courage”. These were the Malavas, whom the Greeks called the Malloi, and their neighbours the Kshudrakas, the Greeks’ Oxydrakai. The two peoples were usually at war with each other. Now they forgot their old quarrel and made common cause against the invader. In Diodorus’s account they sealed the alliance by marriage, each people giving and taking ten thousand of its young women as wives. Together they could field some 80,000 foot. But they quarrelled over who should command, and never joined their forces. While they argued, Alexander struck.
Here Alexander Stopped
The Attack, the Capture, the Massacre
The Macedonians were alarmed at what they faced. A second refusal like the one on the Beas was only just prevented by a stirring speech from the king. Bevan thinks the army’s spirit had begun to fail, so that its leader had to take desperate risks himself. Then came the first blow. Horsemen with the king at their head rode all night across a waterless waste, and early in the morning broke upon a town at the desert’s edge. Most of the Malloi were working unarmed in the fields. Many were “ruthlessly cut down”, without even turning to resist. “And here first was enacted what was repeated in city after city of the confederacy—the attack, the capture, the massacre.” A town with a citadel on a height was stormed under the king’s own direction, and 2,000 of its garrison were slain. People who fled to the marshes by the river were hunted down even among the reeds. A town of Brahmans was taken by mining and by ladders: “about 5,000 in all were killed, and as they were men of spirit, very few were taken prisoners.” In Diodorus’s account, before one city a soothsayer warned Alexander that the omens foretold a dangerous wound if he besieged it. The king rebuked him sharply for hampering the courage of men in action.
Here Alexander Stopped
Alone on the Wall
The Malloi fled to the strongest town in the neighbourhood. Curtius places what followed among the Oxydrakai; Arrian calls that the common error, and says the town and the men in it were Malloi. The Macedonians took the town and turned to its citadel. The men with the ladders were slow, and Alexander snatched a ladder from one of them, set it against the wall and climbed, crouching under his shield. After him came Peucestas, carrying the sacred shield from the temple of Athena at Ilium, believed to have been carried in the Trojan War. Others followed, among them Abreas, a soldier who drew double pay for his merit. The guards, afraid for the king, crowded onto his ladder until it broke. Alexander stood on the wall, a mark for every missile, “by the splendour of his arms and the astonishing audacity he displayed.” In Arrian’s account he reckoned that if he stayed there he would achieve nothing. If he leapt down, he might strike the Indians with terror; and if he died, he would die not ignobly, but after deeds worth remembering. In Curtius, his friends below called to him to leap back down to them. Instead, he leapt into the citadel.
Here Alexander Stopped
The Tree by the Wall
He landed on his feet. With his back to the wall he cut down those who came at him, the Indian governor among them, and threw stones at others. After that they kept back and hurled at him whatever they had. Curtius adds an old tree by the wall, whose leafy branches caught more of the missiles than his shield did. Arrian has Peucestas, Abreas and one other, the only men to reach the top before the ladder broke, leap down after him; Diodorus has the king alone. Abreas fell, shot in the forehead. Then an arrow went through Alexander’s cuirass into his chest, “so that, as Ptolemy says, air gurgled from the wound along with the blood.” He fought on while his blood was warm; then he grew faint and fell on his shield. In Curtius the archer who shot him ran up to strip the body, and Alexander, roused by the outrage, drove his sword up into the man’s side. Peucestas stood over the fallen king, holding up the sacred shield from Ilium, though he too was badly wounded.
Here Alexander Stopped
Neither Man, Woman, nor Child
Outside, the Macedonians could not reach him. The wall was of earth, and some drove pegs into it and swung themselves up; others climbed on one another’s shoulders. Those who got in found the king fallen, and fought over him, one after another holding his shield before him. Others broke the bar of a gate and forced it in. Then they began to kill the Indians, “and in the massacre spared none, neither man, woman, nor child.” Thinking the king dead, the army “gave way to a fury of blood-lust”. In Curtius they took every man they met for the one who had wounded the king. The arrow was barbed and had to be cut out. In Curtius the surgeon stood pale and weeping with fear. “If die I must,” Alexander told him, “free me at least from the pain I suffer.” He would not be held, and did not flinch. The blood poured out, and he swooned.
Here Alexander Stopped
The King on the River
In the main camp the first news was that Alexander had died of his wound. The army fell into despair: who would lead them home, through warlike nations on every side? When word came that he lived, they would not believe it. So, as soon as he could bear it, Alexander had himself carried to the river and taken down by boat to the camp. As the vessel drew near, he had the awning taken off the stern so that all could see him. Still they thought it carried his body, until he raised his arm and stretched out his hand to them. The army cheered, and many wept. He would not be carried ashore on a litter, but called for his horse. Near his tent he got down, so that they could see him walking. The soldiers crowded round him, touching his hands, his knees, or only his clothes. Some threw garlands over him, others the flowers of the season. Nearchus, who commanded the fleet, tells how some of Alexander’s friends reproached him for risking himself like a common soldier. Then an old man from Boeotia came up and spoke to the king in his own dialect: “O Alexander, it is for heroes to do great deeds.” He added a line of verse: he who does a great deed must also suffer.
Here Alexander Stopped
India Remained Unchanged
The Malloi who were left now made their humble submission, and the Oxydrakai bought peace with tribute and gifts. Smith judges that the refusal on the Beas did not spoil the campaign. Had the soldiers let Alexander go deeper into India, his small force might have been overwhelmed. In Smith’s words, “Koinos and his fellow remonstrants may be credited with having prevented the annihilation of the Macedonian army”; Koinos is the Greek form of Coenus’s name. But within three years of Alexander’s going his officers had been ousted, his garrisons destroyed, and almost every trace of his rule was gone. The campaign was in Smith’s words “no more than a brilliantly successful raid on a gigantic scale, which left upon India no mark save the horrid scars of bloody war.” His last word on it: “India remained unchanged. The wounds of battle were quickly healed; the ravaged fields smiled again as the patient oxen and no less patient husbandmen resumed their interrupted labours.” Told from V. A. Smith, The Early History of India, 4th ed., revised by S. M. Edwardes (1924), chs. II, III and IV, and Bevan’s chapter XV in The Cambridge History of India, vol. I, ed. E. J. Rapson (1922). The Hyphasis and the Malloi are from Arrian, Anabasis V 25-29 and VI 9-13; Curtius IX 2-5; Diodorus XVII 93-94 and 98-99; and Plutarch, Life of Alexander 62-63; all in J. W. McCrindle, The Invasion of India by Alexander the Great (1893).