Stories of Ancient India
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Three Letters to Nalanda
In the reign of Harsha, emperor of northern India, a Chinese Buddhist monk named Xuanzang was studying at Nalanda, the great monastery in Magadha. Two records tell his story: his own account of his travels, and the Life of him by Hwui Li, which calls him “the Master of the Law”. Both call Harsha by his title, Siladitya. A messenger came to Silabhadra, the abbot of Nalanda, with a letter from Kumara, king of Kamarupa, in Assam. Kumara was a Brahman, no Buddhist, but he honoured learned men, and he had heard of the Master from a Brahman the pilgrim had beaten in debate. “Your disciple wishes to see the great priest come from China,” he wrote. Silabhadra refused: the priest of China, he told the messenger, wished to go home. The Master had indeed decided to go. The monks had begged him to stay: India was the Buddha’s land, they said, and China a land of barbarians. To the monks Silabhadra gave another reason. They had agreed to send him to Harsha, to argue for the Great Vehicle, the Mahayana school of Buddhism that Nalanda followed, against its rival, the Little Vehicle. If he went to Kumara, and Harsha was expecting him, how could they make sure of him? Kumara sent a second messenger: let the Master come, if only for a little while. Again Silabhadra refused.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
The Third Letter
Then the king “with great anger” sent a third letter. Since he first heard the Master’s name, he wrote, his body and soul had been overjoyed; he had hoped the seed of religion would open in him. By refusing, the abbot seemed to wish the world plunged for ever in darkness. If the Master did not come, “your disciple will then let the evil portion of himself prevail”. Not long ago, he reminded the abbot, a king of Bengal had destroyed the Law and uprooted the Bodhi tree. “Do you, my Master, suppose that your disciple has no such power as this? If necessary then I will equip my army and elephants, and like the clouds sweep down on and trample to the very dust that monastery of Nalanda.” Silabhadra sent for the pilgrim. The king’s better mind was weak, he said, but if Xuanzang could open his heart, his people would follow, as branches wither when the root is cut. If he refused, evil deeds might follow. “Do not shrink from this slight trouble.” So the Master went with the envoy.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
“Send the Head”
Kumara met him with his great officers and lodged him in his palace. Every day there was music and feasting, with flowers and incense. So more than a month passed. Then Harsha came back from a war and heard where the Master was. “I frequently asked him to come here before this,” he said, “and he did not come, how is it that he is now living there?” He sent word to Kumara to send the priest of China at once. Kumara replied, “He can take my head, but he cannot take the Master of the Law yet.” Harsha was furious. “Kumara-raja despises me,” he said. He sent another messenger, with a short message: “Send the head, that I may have it immediately by my messenger who is to bring it here.” Kumara was “deeply alarmed at the folly of his language”; in E. B. Havell’s plainer words, “he saw it was no joking matter.” He made ready twenty thousand elephants and thirty thousand ships, and went up the Ganges with the Master to meet the emperor.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Torches on the River
Kumara left the Master in a pavilion on the bank and went on with his ministers to Harsha. The emperor was overjoyed to see him and did not repeat his threats; he knew how Kumara loved the Master. Where was the priest of China? In a pavilion, said Kumara. Harsha said he would come to him the next day. “I suspect he will come to-night,” Kumara told the Master. At the first watch of the night men reported several thousand lighted torches on the river, and the sound of drums. “This is Siladitya-raja approaching,” said Kumara, and went out with torches to meet him. Wherever Harsha marched, several hundred men went with him beating golden drums, one stroke for every step he took. No other king was allowed them. He bowed at the Master’s feet, scattered flowers before him and praised him in verses without number. “Your disciple invited the Master in former days to come,” he said; “why did you not comply with my request?” The Master answered that he had come from far to hear the Yoga-sastra explained, and when the king’s order came he had not finished.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
The King’s Sister
The next morning Harsha received the Master and Kumara in his palace. After the feast he asked to see the treatise the Master had written against false doctrine. He read it and was delighted. “I have heard that when the sun rises in its splendour the light of the glow-worm is eclipsed,” he told his attendants. Behind the king sat his widowed sister, Rajyasri, a woman learned in another school of Buddhism. As she heard the Master praise the Great Vehicle, “she was filled with joy, and could not cease her praises.” But others in other lands, Harsha said, would still cling to their foolish doctrine. He would call a great assembly at Kanauj, his capital. That same day he sent orders through all the kingdoms. The monks, Brahmans and men of every sect of all India were to meet at Kanauj “to investigate the treatise of the Master of the Law, of China”.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Ninety Days up the Ganges
In Xuanzang’s own record, Harsha marched up the south bank of the Ganges followed by several hundred thousand people, and Kumara kept pace on the north bank. “Divided by the stream of the river, they advanced on land and water,” with drums and horns, flutes and harps. After ninety days, in February or March 643 by V. A. Smith’s dating (Havell has 644), they came to Kanauj. There the kings who owed Harsha allegiance were waiting, with thousands of monks and Brahmans, a thousand of the monks from Nalanda. Their followers came on elephants and in palanquins, “like the clouds for multitude”. On the river bank the king had built a great monastery. Beside it stood a tower about a hundred feet high, holding a golden Buddha “of the same height as the king himself”.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
A Head on a Placard
Each morning a smaller golden Buddha was carried in procession on a great elephant. Harsha walked beside it dressed as the god Sakra, and Kumara as the god Brahma, with elephants behind for the princes, ministers and chief monks. As he went, Harsha scattered pearls and flowers of gold and silver. In the pilgrim’s own account, he washed the image at the altar in scented water and carried it on his own shoulder to the tower. Then the Master of the Law was seated on a precious couch as “Lord of the discussion”. He praised the Great Vehicle and set the subject, and a monk of Nalanda read it to the assembly. Outside the door hung a placard with the same words, and this added: “if there is any one who can find a single word in the proposition contrary to reason, or is able to entangle (the argument), then at the request of the opponent, I offer my head as a recompense.” In the Life, no one came forward until night to say a word. Harsha, well pleased, closed the assembly for the day.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Eighteen Days of Silence
After five days men of the Little Vehicle, seeing that the Master had overturned their school, plotted to take his life. Harsha heard of it and issued a proclamation: “If, then, any one should hurt or touch the Master of the Law, he shall be forthwith beheaded; and whoever speaks against him, his tongue shall be cut out; but all those who desire to profit by his instruction, relying on my goodwill, need not fear this manifesto.” “From this time,” the Life goes on, “the followers of error withdrew and disappeared, so that when eighteen days had passed there had been no one to enter on the discussion.” Smith thought the terms of the contest “not quite fair”: Harsha was determined that his favourite should not be beaten, and the biographer adds the eighteen days “naively”. Harsha offered the Master ten thousand pieces of gold, thirty thousand of silver and a hundred robes of fine cotton, and each of the kings offered jewels. He refused them all. So the king set him on a great elephant and had it proclaimed through the crowd that he “had established the standard of right doctrine, without gainsaying.” It was the custom, Harsha told him, and could not be passed over.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Fire in the Tower
Xuanzang’s own record ends the assembly otherwise. In it the assembly lasted twenty-one days, not the twenty-three that R. K. Mookerji reckons from the Life. On the last day a great fire broke out in the tower, and the pavilion over the monastery gate was burning too. Harsha cried out: “I have exhausted the wealth of my country in charity … In the presence of such calamities as these, what need I of further life?” He burned incense and made a vow: “let the force of my religious conduct destroy this fire; or if not, let me die!” Then he rushed headlong at the gate, and, in the pilgrim’s words, “suddenly, as if by a single blow, the fire was extinguished and the smoke disappeared.” In Smith’s words, “pious hearts recognized a miracle.” The kings fell at his feet in tears. The crowning work of his life lay in ashes, they said, and the heretics were rejoicing. Harsha answered with his face unchanged. The fire, he said, only proved the Buddha’s teaching, “that all things are impermanent”. His work of charity was done. “This is a great happiness, and not a subject for lamentation.”
The King Who Gave Everything Away
A Knife on the Stairs
Then the king went with the kings to the great stupa and climbed to the top to look out over the scene. As he came down the steps, a man rushed at him, knife in hand. Harsha stepped back a few steps up the stairs, then bent down and seized the man himself. His officers were so frightened that they could not move to help him. The kings all demanded that the man be killed at once. Harsha, “without the least show of fear and with unchanged countenance”, forbade it, and questioned him himself. “What harm have I done you, that you have attempted such a deed?” The man answered that he had been led astray by heretics. “Great king! you have assembled the people of different countries, and exhausted your treasury in offerings to the Sramanas,” the Buddhist monks, “but the heretics who have come from a distance have scarcely been spoken to.” Then five hundred Brahmans were questioned, closely. They confessed that they had fired the tower with burning arrows, hoping to kill the king in the confusion. When that failed, they hired the man with the knife.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Pardoned or Executed?
What happened to the plotters, the tellers do not agree. In Xuanzang’s own record, as Mookerji retells it, the kings demanded that the heretics be wiped out. But Harsha “only punished the chief of them, and pardoned the rest, banishing the 500 Brahmins to the frontiers of India.” Smith believed the confession was forced out by torture and was probably false. In his account, the men named as leaders were put to death on the strength of it, and some five hundred Brahmans sent into exile. Havell, too, cites an account in which “some of the conspirators were executed”. And in the Life there is no fire and no knife at all. There the plot was against the Master, and the king’s proclamation ended it.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
The Arena of Charity
When the assembly broke up, the Master came to take his leave. Harsha asked him to wait. “Your disciple, succeeding to the royal authority, has been lord of India for thirty years and more,” he said. Every five years, at Prayaga, between the two rivers, he held a great assembly and gave away his treasure. Five had been held; the sixth was due. Would the Master not stay and see it? The Master answered: “If your Majesty does not grudge his treasure for the good of others, how can Hiuen-Tsiang grudge a short delay?” Hiuen-Tsiang is the Life’s spelling of Xuanzang’s name. West of where the Ganges and the Jumna meet lay a great plain, “flat and even like a mirror”. Kings had given alms there from of old, for a tradition said that one mite given in charity in this place was worth a thousand given anywhere else. Inside a bamboo hedge a thousand paces each side, scores of thatched buildings held gold, silver and pearls, and hundreds of store-houses held silk, cotton and coin. About half a million people were waiting. Smith thought it must have looked much like the crowded fair held each year on the same ground in his own day.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
Seventy-Five Days of Giving
On the first day an image of the Buddha was set up in a thatched hall, and the finest clothing and precious things were given away. On the second day the image of the Sun was honoured, and on the third the image of Siva, each with gifts half as great. On the fourth day ten thousand Buddhist monks came forward, arranged in a hundred ranks. “Each received 100 pieces of gold, one pearl, one cotton garment,” with food and drink, flowers and perfumes. For twenty days after that the gifts went to the Brahmans. For ten days more they went to the Jains and the other sects (twenty in Havell’s account), and for ten to beggars who had come from far away. Then for a month they went to the poor, the orphans and the destitute. So the Life tells it, over seventy-five days. Xuanzang’s own record says the king gave away the wealth of five years “in one day”.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
A Borrowed Garment
“By this time the accumulation of five years was exhausted,” the Life says. Only the horses, elephants and arms the army needed to keep order were left. Then the king gave away his own things: his gems, his clothing, his necklaces, ear-rings and bracelets, and the bright jewel he wore on his head. “All being given away, he begged from his sister an ordinary second-hand garment, and having put it on he paid worship to the Buddhas of the ten regions.” With his hands joined, rejoicing, he said: “In amassing all this wealth and treasure I ever feared that it was not safely stored in a strong place; but now having bestowed this treasure in the field of religious merit, I can safely say it is well bestowed.” Xuanzang remembered his cry in other words: “Well done! now all that I have has entered into incorruptible and imperishable treasuries.” In the Life, the kings then bought back his necklaces and robes from those who had received them and gave them back to him. In a few days he had given them all away again.
The King Who Gave Everything Away
The Last Farewell
At last the Master asked to go. Harsha kept him ten days more, and Kumara offered to found a hundred monasteries if he would stay in his kingdom. The learned men of China were waiting for what he had learnt, Xuanzang answered: “Whoever hinders men from a knowledge of religion shall, for generation after generation, be born blind.” The king let him choose. He would take nothing but a cape of skin lined with soft down, Kumara’s gift, against the rain. “On their final separation they could none of them restrain their tears.” His books and images went on horseback with the escort of a king of the north. Harsha added an elephant, and three thousand gold and ten thousand silver pieces for the road. Three days later Harsha, with Kumara and several hundred horsemen, rode after him to say goodbye once more. Xuanzang reached China in the spring of 645, with 657 books on twenty horses. He spent the rest of his life translating them, and died in 664. Harsha died at the end of 646 or early in 647, not long after his guest had gone. C. V. Vaidya thought no emperor in the history of the world, perhaps, had given away so much: “Such was this great Emperor Harsha, at once munificent, philosophic and brave.” Told from V. A. Smith, The Early History of India, 4th ed., revised by S. M. Edwardes (1924), ch. XIII; R. K. Mookerji, Harsha (1926), chs. II, III and V; E. B. Havell, The History of Aryan Rule in India (1918); and C. V. Vaidya, History of Mediaeval Hindu India, vol. I (1921), chs. II and III. The pilgrim’s story is from Hwui Li’s Life of Hiuen-Tsiang, translated by S. Beal (1911), Books IV and V, and Xuanzang’s Si-yu-ki, translated by Samuel Beal, vol. I (1884), Book V.