Stories of Ancient India
They Would Not Fight Their Own
A Horrible Thing
On a little hill outside the city of Massaga, in the hills of the north-west, a body of hired Indian soldiers made camp. They had been paid to defend the city against Alexander of Macedon. When the city could hold out no longer, it was agreed that they would change sides and serve him. There, as they talked together, “it seemed to them a horrible thing that they should march with the Yavanas against their own people.” Yavanas was the Indian name for the Greeks. The story is told by the Greek and Roman writers of Alexander’s wars, Arrian, Curtius, Diodorus and Plutarch. The people of Massaga, the Assakenoi of the Greeks, were “the first Indian people to receive the brunt of the invasion”. The fighting in these hills “seems to have been of exceptional ferocity”. What the soldiers on the hill decided, and what it cost them, the old writers tell in two different ways.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
The Greatest City in Those Parts
Massaga was the greatest city in those parts. It was the seat of the chief the Greeks call Assakenos. All the tribes as far as the Indus owned him as overlord, and he had taken command there himself. The Assakenoi were said to be waiting for Alexander with 20,000 horse, more than 30,000 foot and thirty elephants. Curtius puts the army that defended the city at 38,000 foot. On the east a mountain torrent with steep banks barred the way. To the south and west, nature had piled up gigantic rocks, as if to make a rampart, with yawning chasms at their foot; and a great wall ran round the city. Inside it, in Arrian’s count, were the hired soldiers: “a body of Indian mercenaries brought from a distance, and no less than 7000 strong”. They came from the plains of India. Plutarch calls such hired troops “the best soldiers to be found in the country”. They flocked to the cities Alexander attacked, defended them with the greatest vigour, and cost him serious losses.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
The First Fight
As the Macedonians began to make camp, the defenders ran out at them. Alexander wanted the fight far from the walls, so that a beaten enemy could not escape by a short flight into the city. He had his men fall back to a little hill. Taking it for flight, the Indians charged at a run, in no order. Then, at a signal, Alexander wheeled about. His horse-lancers and archers struck first, and the phalanx followed. The Indians broke and fled back into the city, leaving about 200 dead. At the walls, Alexander was hit by an arrow from the battlements. The wound was not serious, and he would not leave off directing the work. In Curtius’s account, as the pain grew, he said that though he was called the son of Jupiter, he felt all the defects of a weak body.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
Towers That Moved
Then the siege was laid. The soldiers tore down houses outside the city and threw tree trunks and masses of rock into the chasms. In nine days they had raised a mole level with the ground, and towers on it. The towers frightened the defenders most. In the same account they had never seen such things, and believed that those vast fabrics, moving with no visible aid, were driven by the gods. Still the Indians threw back attack after attack. Once Alexander had a bridge thrown from an engine to a breach in the wall, and led his guards across it. It broke under the crowd, and the Macedonians fell with it, while the defenders, cheering, rained stones and arrows on them. As long as their chief was alive they kept up the defence with great vigour. Then a missile from an engine struck him and killed him. Some had fallen and most were wounded, and they sent a herald to Alexander.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
Terms
In Arrian’s words, “to him it was always a pleasure to save the lives of brave men.” He agreed with the hired soldiers that they should change sides and serve in his ranks. In Diodorus the terms were sworn with oaths, and the queen of Massaga, admiring his magnanimity, sent him costly presents. Curtius tells the surrender his own way: the city’s ruler, Assacanus, had died shortly before, and his mother Cleophis ruled the city. The queen came out with a great train of noble ladies, who poured wine from golden bowls, and set her son, still a child, at Alexander’s knees. She won not only pardon but leave to keep her rank as queen. The chief’s mother and daughter were left in the enemy’s hands. In the judgment of the historian Bevan, it was not among Alexander’s faults to fail in chivalry to the women whom war put at his mercy. The hired soldiers left the city with their arms and camped by themselves on a small hill facing the Macedonian camp.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
The Little Hill
What happened next, Arrian tells this way. The mercenaries “had no wish to take up arms against their own countrymen”, and they resolved to rise in the night and make off for home with all speed. But someone had betrayed their plan. When night fell, they found the hill beset on every side by Alexander’s soldiers. Alexander surrounded the hill that same night with all his troops, caught the Indians in the midst of their flight, “and cut them to pieces”. The historian V. A. Smith has him, told of their plan, fall on them “while they reposed in fancied security”. Then Alexander stormed the city, stripped now of its defenders. In the whole siege, from first to last, he lost twenty-five men. That is Arrian’s telling: the Indians meant to break their word first.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
Who Broke Faith?
Diodorus tells it the other way. The mercenaries marched out as agreed and camped unmolested, “without thought of what was to happen”. But Alexander, “actuated by an implacable enmity against the mercenaries”, had kept his troops under arms. He went after them, fell on them suddenly, and made a great slaughter. The Indians cried out that they were attacked against sworn oaths, and called on the gods he had dishonoured by swearing falsely in their name. Alexander answered in a loud voice that his covenant bound him only to let them leave the city. It was “by no means a league of perpetual amity” with the Macedonians. Plutarch too says Alexander made peace with them, then set upon them on the road as they went away, and killed them all. “This rests as a foul blot on his martial fame, for on all other occasions he observed the rules of civilised warfare as became a king.” Smith takes Arrian’s side: the slaughter was “the tremendous penalty for a meditated breach of faith on the part of the Indians”, and if so, “not altogether undeserved”. McCrindle, the translator, calls it a “gross violation” of the compact.
They Would Not Fight Their Own
The Ring
Diodorus tells the fight itself. The mercenaries, undismayed, drew their ranks into a ring and put the women and children inside, guarded on every side. It was “a hollow circle, with the women and children in the centre”. Desperate now, they fought so hard that the Macedonians, for honour’s sake, would not be outdone. It was hand to hand. The Macedonians’ long spikes shattered the Indians’ shields and pierced their vitals; the mercenaries’ javelins, thrown into the dense ranks so close, never missed. Many were wounded and many killed. Then the women took up the arms of the fallen and fought beside the men. Some, armed, covered their husbands with their shields; others, unarmed, flung themselves on the enemy and caught hold of their shields. At last, fighting on with their wives, they were overpowered by numbers. In Bevan’s words, “the Macedonians suffered none of them to live till morning.” Diodorus has Alexander spare the unarmed crowd and the women still alive, and take them away under guard of his cavalry. Of the men who would not march against their own people, Diodorus leaves this: they “met a glorious death which they would have disdained to exchange for a life with dishonour.” Told from V. A. Smith, The Early History of India, 4th ed., revised by S. M. Edwardes (1924), ch. III, and Bevan’s chapter XV in The Cambridge History of India, vol. I, ed. E. J. Rapson (1922). The siege and the fate of the hired soldiers are from Arrian, Anabasis IV 26-27; Curtius VIII 10; Diodorus XVII 84; and Plutarch, Life of Alexander 59; all in J. W. McCrindle, The Invasion of India by Alexander the Great (1893).