Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Ayodhya
1855: The Fight at Hanumangarhi
A Few Hundred Paces Apart
In Ayodhya, two holy places stood within a few hundred paces of each other, and in 1855 men died fighting between them. One was the Hanuman Garhi, the temple of Hanuman: “a massive structure in the shape of a four-sided fort”, with a round bastion at each corner. It stood on an ancient mound, all that was left of Ramkot, the old citadel. Above it, on the hill to the west, was the Janmasthan, the birthplace of Rama, where a mosque stood. To H. R. Nevill the mosque was a “desecration of the most sacred spot in the city”. It caused great bitterness between Hindus and Muslims, and on many occasions the feeling led to bloodshed.
1855: The Fight at Hanumangarhi
The Tower at the Gate
The Hanuman Garhi had a story of its own, from the tradition of the place. When Rama came back from the conquest of Ceylon, he occupied the fortress at Ayodhya that bears his name, whose bastions and earthworks were still pointed out. There he gave each of his generals a post. To Hanuman, the much trusted leader of the monkey army, he gave the command of the tower at the main gate, and the tower was called after him. Hanuman kept that command until the Ayodhya of those days was carried away to heaven. Up to the time of the Nawab Mansur Ali Khan, offerings of flowers and red lead were made to Hanuman. They were laid at the foot of “a glorious old tamarind tree” called Ram Chaura.
1855: The Fight at Hanumangarhi
The Nawab’s Illness
Then the Nawab Mansur Ali Khan was seized with a severe illness. It was thought that the prayers of Abhi Ram, the chief of the mendicants of Ayodhya, cured him. Abhi Ram won the Nawab’s gratitude and good offices. Afterwards, it is said, Hanuman appeared to Abhi Ram in a vision and asked him to build a temple at Ram Chaura. Abhi Ram built it, and was the first of the mahants who have presided over it ever since. P. Carnegy, writing in 1870, ended the story so: “Such was the comparatively recent origin of the Hanuman Garhi as we see it.” By 1905 it was the home of the Nirbanis. They were very numerous and very wealthy, with lands in five districts and a large income from the offerings of the pilgrims.
1855: The Fight at Hanumangarhi
Up the Temple Steps
In 1855 “a great rupture took place” between Hindus and Muslims. The Hindus held the Hanuman Garhi in force. The Muslims took the Janmasthan, and from it made “a desperate assault” on the temple. They charged up the steps of the Hanuman Garhi. They were driven back with considerable loss. Then the Hindus followed up their success and counter-attacked. At the third attempt they stormed the Janmasthan and took it. Seventy-five Muslims were buried at its gate, in the place known as the Ganj Shahidan, the martyrs’ resting-place. Eleven Hindus were killed. All the time several of the king’s regiments were looking on, and their orders were not to interfere.
1855: The Fight at Hanumangarhi
The Martyrs’ Grave
It is said that up to that time Hindus and Muslims alike had worshipped in the same building, the “mosque-temple”. In Nevill’s account, Maulvi Amir Ali of Amethi soon afterwards organized a regular expedition to destroy the Hanuman Garhi. But he and his forces were stopped in the Bara Banki district. The earlier gazetteer of the province gives his aim as seizing the site, as it was alleged to be, of an old mosque on the Hanuman Garhi. After the mutiny an outer enclosure was put up in front of the mosque. The Hindus were forbidden the inner yard. They made their offerings on a platform they had raised in the outer one, while at the gate the seventy-five lay in the martyrs’ grave. Told from P. Carnegy, A Historical Sketch of Tahsil Fyzabad (1870), the Ajudhia chapter, to p. 21; the Gazetteer of the Province of Oudh (1877), “Ajodhya”, p. 7; H. R. Nevill, Fyzabad: A Gazetteer (1905), pp. 63, 174, 176-177; and Alexander Cunningham, Four Reports Made during the Years 1862-63-64-65 (Archaeological Survey of India I, 1871), p. 322. Only the Oudh Gazetteer gives the eleven Hindus killed. Carnegy has a railing put up “since British rule”, the Muslims praying inside it, the Hindus outside. Nevill puts Ramkot in the west of the city, Cunningham on its east side; Cunningham dates the temple of Hanuman no earlier than Aurangzeb. Carnegy lists six mahants, Abhi Ram to Balram Das.