Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Delhi
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
One Thought: Flight
On 14 September 1857 the English stormed Delhi. The King of Delhi, Bahadur Shah, the last of the Mughals, and his advisers were deeply impressed by the storm. Unless the English drew back, they decided, the game was up. When the morning of the 15th showed the English still in their places, the hearts of the King and his advisers fell. As long as the palace, the Jama Masjid and the Lahore Gate held, no step was taken towards retreat. Then, on the night of the 19th, the Burn Bastion was taken, and the thought that had been uppermost in every heart came out. That thought was flight. Bakht Khan, the commander-in-chief of the rebel army, left the city that night with every fighting man he could trust. He used all his eloquence to make the King come with him. All was not lost, he said. The English had the stronghold, but the open country lay before them. Under the shadow of the King’s name the war could go on. The King promised to meet him the next day at the tomb of Humayun.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
The Wiliest of the Nobles
In Kaye and Malleson’s account, the wiliest of the nobles round the King was Ilahi Bakhsh Mirza, whose daughter was the widow of the King’s eldest son. He had listened to Bakht Khan without a word. When the general had gone, he took the King home with him for the night. There he set out the hardships that would follow if the King went with the army, and its certain defeat. Then he showed the other side of the shield. Let the King break with the sepoys at once, and the victorious English would believe he had acted under compulsion until now. The next day, at the tomb, the King, the women of his household, his sons and his nobles met Bakht Khan and would not go with him. They chose to trust to the mercy of the conqueror. Bakht Khan and the rebel army went their way. Ilahi Bakhsh’s next step was harder: to betray his master. He opened talks with Munshi Rajab Ali, chief of the agents the English kept to watch the enemy during the siege. Keep the royal family at the tomb for twenty-four hours, Rajab Ali told him, and leave the rest to me.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
Hodson Rides Out
Rajab Ali took the news to Hodson of Hodson’s Horse. Kaye and Malleson draw him harshly: daring, reckless and unscrupulous, a man in whom “human suffering awoke no feeling.” On 30 August he had written that if he got into the palace, “the House of Taimur will not be worth five minutes’ purchase.” Hodson asked General Wilson, the English commander, for leave to bring in the King. Wilson was inclined to treat the King as a man outside the law. Only with the greatest difficulty did those about him persuade him to add a condition: the King, if he surrendered, must be brought in alive. Hodson took fifty of his troopers and galloped down towards the tomb. Near it he posted his men in the shade of some ruined buildings, and sent in word inviting the King to surrender. Inside, the King’s favourite wife was pleading with the old man. Her son was a boy, not old enough to have had a part in the rising, yet not too young to be massacred. She begged the King to yield if his life was promised. For two hours he wavered. At last he sent word that he would surrender if Hodson gave his word that his life would be spared. Hodson gave it.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
“Hodson Bahadur?”
Hodson stood alone in the open space before the gate of the tomb. The Queen and her son came out first, in palanquins; then the King, carried in another. Hodson rode up to the King’s palanquin and demanded his arms. The King asked whether his captor was Hodson Bahadur. Told that he was, he asked for a promise from the Englishman’s own lips: his life, and the lives of his wife and her son. The promise was given, the arms were handed over, and the procession moved slowly towards the city. Hodson brought the King in by the Lahore Gate, along the Chandni Chowk, to the palace. The King asked to see General Wilson. Wilson refused to see him, and had him placed under a European guard in the Begum’s palace. Four days later Hodson wrote in his journal that he would much rather have brought the King in dead than living. In the same journal he cleared him of any active part in the revolt.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
The Princes at the Tomb
Then the same agents brought Hodson fresh news. Two of the King’s sons and a grandson, said to have taken part in the massacre of May, were hiding at Humayun’s tomb. “I am not cruel,” Hodson wrote afterwards, “but I confess that I did rejoice in the opportunity of ridding the earth of these ruffians.” He rode out the next morning with his second in command, Lieutenant McDowell, a hundred troopers and his two informers, Rajab Ali and Ilahi Bakhsh. The three princes, Mirza Mughal, Mirza Khizr Sultan and Mirza Abu Bakr, were in the tomb with a large crowd. The boldest offered to defend them to the last, but the princes hoped, like their father, to win a promise of their lives. For two hours they begged for it. Hodson refused, and they surrendered. He made the crowd give up its arms, and the princes were driven towards the city in a covered cart, the crowd following.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
The Carbine
To Kaye and Malleson, Hodson “wanted blood.” Five-sixths of the way had been covered without the least hostility. Then Hodson made the pressing of the crowd his excuse. He stopped the cart and ordered the princes to get down and strip to their under-garments. In a loud voice he told his troopers that these men were butchers who had murdered English women and children. It was the will of the Government, he said, that they should die. Then he took a carbine from a trooper and shot his three unresisting prisoners dead. Their bodies were exposed for twenty-four hours in front of the Kotwali, the police station. Mainodin tells it otherwise. In his narrative the King was brought in from the old fort, with four princes in a bullock-cart. The princes were shot in front of the Hall of Public Audience, where the English women and children had been butchered.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
“A Brutal and Unnecessary Murder”
To many of the foremost men in India the shooting seemed “a brutal and unnecessary murder.” The princes could have been brought safely in, as the King had been. That has always been Kaye and Malleson’s own view. But the camp, excited by the capture of Delhi, held that Hodson was right. His defenders argued that the small force, about 6,000 strong, had about 1,400 killed and wounded in the assault. Some 40,000 rebels had left the city, no one knew where. The King’s name and his son’s were still “a tower of strength” to the “scum” within the city. The shooting left them no one to look to, and in the princes’ death, they held, any attempt to reverse the victory got its final blow. Kaye and Malleson grant the force of this, and still find the killing unnecessary. The King was alive, one prince had been spared, and the rebels knew the House of Timur was still represented. To them it remains “one of the most painful episodes” of the Mutiny. H. C. Fanshawe calls Hodson’s disarming of the crowd at the tomb a marked display of cool daring. But he finds it scarcely credible there was any real fear of a rescue. The city was mostly deserted, and on the whole road from the tomb no one had tried.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
The Gallows before the Kotwali
In Mainodin’s account no one’s life was safe in the city. The city was plundered from the Lahore Gate to the Kashmiri Gate. All able-bodied men who were seen were taken for rebels and shot. In the deserted fort the few people found here and there were shot. Shah Samund Khan, commander of the King’s bodyguard, was caught leaving by the Kashmiri Gate. Known as a general of the Raja of Jhajjar’s forces, he was shot out of hand. Another man, Mirza Buktour Shah, was caught later and executed. In the bazaar before the Kotwali, gallows were put up, and on them many leading mutineers met their end. Among them were Nawab Abdurrahman Khan of Jhajjar and Raja Nahar Singh of Ballabgarh. The Raja had been all but governor of the city during the siege, and the death of a Mr. Munder was laid at his door. With the chief of Farrukhnagar these two were hanged for rebellion, and the three were buried in one grave with the princes of Delhi.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
The Hall of Special Audience
On 27 January 1858 a military court sat in the Special Hall of Audience of the palace. The prisoner, “Muhammad Bahadur Shah, Ex-King of Delhi,” was brought in. It was the hall that had been the very heart of the Mughal Empire since Shah Jahan. Here Nadir Shah had been received by his unwilling host. Here Ghulam Kadir, the Rohilla, had blinded the Emperor Shah Alam. Here in May 1857 the mutinous soldiers had declared Bahadur Shah king. Asked whether he objected to any of his judges, the King answered, “No.” He was charged with aiding the mutiny and rebellion, and with proclaiming himself King and Sovereign of India. He was charged too with causing the murder of 49 persons in the palace on 16 May 1857, chiefly women and children of European and mixed descent. The charge said too that he had ordered rulers to slay Christians and English people wherever found. “Not Guilty,” he answered. The trial could end in a verdict only, the prosecutor, Major Harriott, explained. The King’s life had been promised him by Captain Hodson, acting on General Wilson’s instructions, and no sentence could be passed on him even if he were found guilty.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
“I Swear by God”
The King’s answer was a written defence, set down, he said, from his own dictation. From the day the soldiers came and killed the English officers, he said, he had been their prisoner. They made him put his seal to papers, sometimes on empty envelopes. They demanded his queen, Zinat Mahal, to keep her prisoner. “No person demands the wife of the poorest man, saying ‘Give her to me, I will make her a prisoner.’” They never even saluted him, and walked into the Hall of Special Audience with their shoes on. “What confidence could I place in troops who had murdered their own masters?” Weary of his life, he had put on the earth-red robe of a religious beggar, meaning to go at last to Mecca; the army would not let him. Twice, he said, he had talked the soldiers out of killing the Europeans they held prisoner; the third time they would not listen. “I gave no orders for this slaughter.” And: “I swear by God, who is my witness, that I did not give orders for the death of Mr. Fraser or of any other European.” Fraser, he said, had sent to him for two guns on the first morning, and the commandant of the palace guards for palanquins for two ladies. Before the palanquins could reach them, Fraser, the commandant and the ladies had all been killed. When the troops fled, the King said, he slipped away under the palace windows to Humayun’s tomb, and came in on a promise of his life.
The Emperor Taken, Tried and Sent Away
The Last Rooms
On 9 March 1858 the court found the prisoner “Guilty of all and every part of the charges.” Since his capture he had been kept in three rooms of a house in the palace, by the Delhi Gate, with four sentries round it. Lieutenant Ommaney, who had charge of him, described him as about eighty-five, a striking man in his prime, with an aristocratic face and a marked nose. He had a pleasant expression and a sense of humour. He was too old, Ommaney thought, to have begun the horrors of those days or taken any part in them. He was the tool of “the bolder and more truculent spirits, male and female, about him.” Ommaney took him to his exile. The King, with his queens and certain princes, was banished to Rangoon, and sent there under a European guard. The Government granted an allowance for their keep. And the King was allowed to take with him four of his old retainers as servants. Told from Kaye and Malleson, History of the Indian Mutiny, vol. IV, pp. 49-57, with Hodson’s journal and letters in its notes; C. T. Metcalfe, Two Native Narratives of the Mutiny in Delhi (1898), Mainodin’s narrative, pp. 70-74; H. C. Fanshawe, Delhi Past and Present (1902), pp. 36-37, 41-43, 50, and Lieutenant Norman’s narrative with Fanshawe’s notes, pp. 184-185; and the Proceedings on the Trial of Muhammad Bahadur Shah (1858), pp. 1-3, 133-140, and the finding. Mainodin has the King brought in by Ilahi Bakhsh and Hakim Ahsanullah. By McDowell’s account in Fanshawe, Hodson shot the princes in the cart, between the Jail and the Delhi Gate. Kaye and Malleson and Norman date the shooting 22 September; Fanshawe’s Kotwali page, the 18th.