Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
1669: The Vishwanath Temple Pulled Down
News for the Emperor
On 15 Rabi-ul-akhir a report reached the Mughal emperor Aurangzeb, whom his chronicler calls “his religious Majesty, leader of the Unitarians.” It said that “in obedience to order, the Government officers had destroyed the temple of Bishnath at Benares.” In that one sentence the Maasir-i-Alamgiri, the chronicle of Aurangzeb’s reign by Saqi Mustaid Khan, records the end of Kashi’s Vishwanath temple. In H. R. Nevill’s words it was “the celebrated temple of Bisheswar.” To the historian Jadunath Sarkar it stood with Somnath and the Keshav Rai temple of Mathura among “the great shrines that commanded the veneration of the Hindus all over India,” and all three fell under the emperor’s “destroying hand.” Yet the order had begun with the schools. News had reached the emperor that in Thatta, Multan and Benares, “but especially in the latter,” “foolish Brahmans” were teaching “frivolous books.” Students came to them from far away, Muslims as well as Hindus, to learn “the wicked sciences they taught.”
1669: The Vishwanath Temple Pulled Down
Razed to the Ground
The chronicle calls the emperor the “Director of the Faith.” He ordered the governors of all the provinces “to destroy with a willing hand the schools and temples of the infidels.” Their teaching and worship were to end. His officers carried out the order in Kashi. The temple was razed to the ground, and on its site a great mosque was built out of its own material. Its walls show a great deal of old Hindu carving. The dates differ. The chronicle, in Elliot and Dowson’s translation, dates the news that led to the order 17 Zi-l ka’da 1079 AH, 18 April 1669. Sarkar, from the same chronicle, dates the order 9 April 1669, and puts the pulling down in August 1669 and the news at court on 2 September. And where the chronicle has officers carry out the order, Edwin Greaves has Aurangzeb himself “swept down on the city.”
1669: The Vishwanath Temple Pulled Down
The Temple Before
It was not the first Vishwanath temple. The first, it seems, stood on the high ground by the Carmichael Library, and is believed to have been destroyed by Shahab-ud-din Ghori in 1194. A second was built soon after, between the library and the present Vishwanath temple; this was the temple Aurangzeb pulled down. In 1868 its remains could still be seen, forming a large part of the mosque’s western wall. Judged by them, the old temple had been taller and larger than the Vishwanath temple of that day. Its courtyard was four or five times the whole area of the newer temple. On three sides of the terrace under the mosque stood pillars of a simple, very early kind, taken for Buddhist. By 1909 the mosque’s domes, “standing out in their white simplicity,” dominated “the golden temple and the most hallowed shrines of the city.”
1669: The Vishwanath Temple Pulled Down
A Cause of Offence
The mosque itself was plain, with scarcely any carving, its walls daubed with dirty whitewash; its best feature was a row of Buddhist or Hindu columns in front. M. A. Sherring believed it had been put there “from motives of insult,” and called it “a constant source of heart-burnings and feuds” to Hindus and Muslims alike. The Hindus claimed the courtyard between the mosque and the wall as theirs, and let the Muslims in by one public entrance only. To Nevill its presence “has ever been a cause of offence to the Hindus,” and the place saw serious riots early in the nineteenth century. Sherring saw the strictness of Muslim rule in the city’s other temples too. Kashi was strewn with them, yet he thought it would be hard to find twenty from Aurangzeb’s time, 1658 to 1707. Nearly all were small. To him it seemed clear that, for the most part, the emperors had let the Hindus build only small shrines for their gods, “of the size of cages.”
1669: The Vishwanath Temple Pulled Down
The God in the Well
Beside the mosque is the Gyanvapi, the well of knowledge. Its legend runs like this. Once Kashi suffered a drought: no rain fell for twelve years. Then a rishi, a sage, took Shiva’s trident and thrust it into the earth at this spot. A spring bubbled up, enough to save the whole city, and Shiva came to live in the well, where he remains to this day. E. B. Havell knew a second legend too, one he thought had “perhaps more historical foundation.” When Aurangzeb destroyed the old temple, a priest took the image of the god and threw it down the well. Fitzedward Hall, in his introduction to Sherring’s book, knew the tale another way. In the tale he reports, no one threw it. When Aurangzeb threw down the old temple, the lingam, the stone emblem of Shiva, “cast itself, unassisted, into the Jnanavapi.” Told from the Maasir-i-Alamgiri of Saqi Mustaid Khan, in Elliot and Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. VII (1877), pp. 183-184; Jadunath Sarkar, History of Aurangzib, vol. III (1916), ch. XXXIV p. 302, Appendix V p. 321 and the chronology; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 197 and 250; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 31-32 and 51-52, with Fitzedward Hall’s introduction, p. xxxv; E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), p. 182; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), pp. 4-5.