Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
The Sinking Pillar
On high ground above the Kapilmochan tank in Kashi there once stood a pillar. In the words of Reginald Heber, an English traveller, it was “a very beautiful shaft of one stone, forty feet high, and covered with exquisite carving.” It was called the Lat Bhairo, the pillar of Bhairo, the god called the magistrate of the city, and it was worshipped as an emblem of Shiva. It had stood in a Hindu temple. The emperor Aurangzeb destroyed the temple and built a mosque in its place, but left the pillar standing in the mosque’s courtyard. The Hindus went on coming to worship it, and the Muslims allowed it, because they were given half the offerings. There was a tradition about the pillar. It was slowly sinking into the ground. Once, it was said, it had stood twice as high as it did now. When its top was level with the earth, all nations would be of one caste, and the religion of Brahma would come to an end. In 1809 the pillar fell. The acting magistrate of the city that year, W. W. Bird, later told Heber what followed: “One half of the population was literally armed against the other.”
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
Ground Between Two Faiths
In the city stood another mosque of Aurangzeb’s, on the site of the old temple of Vishwanath. To H. R. Nevill, that was “the most sacred spot in the whole city.” The present temple of Vishwanath stood close by. Between the two lay neutral ground. In October 1809 someone began to put up a stone building there. Edwin Greaves says it was the Hindus, and that the Muslims resented it. The Julahas came out in large numbers. They were Muslim weavers, and with them came others of the poorer classes, all led by two brothers, Dost Muhammad and Fateh Muhammad. They destroyed the half-built shrine of Hanuman, and went on to defile other places nearby. The next day a large crowd of Hindus gathered on the spot, and Bird broke it up. On the Hindu side were many men of rank, and the moving spirits were the Rajputs of the city, the warrior caste. Heber and William Buyers, a clergyman, tell a different beginning. Two festival processions, one Muslim and one Hindu, met in the streets. Neither would give way, and the Muslims were beaten in the fight that followed.
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
The Pillar Falls
Two companies of sepoys, Indian soldiers, were brought in to guard the mosques. Then the Julahas set out to sack the temple of Vishwanath itself. The Hindus rose to meet them, and the two sides met at Gayaghat, one of the ghats, the stone stairways down to the river. After a stubborn fight in the narrow, crowded lanes, the Julahas were beaten back with a loss of some eighty persons. Meanwhile Bird and his soldiers put down another riot near the mosque, then marched off towards the temple. On their way back from the fight, the beaten Julahas found the place deserted, and turned on the Lat. They killed a cow inside its sacred ground, then threw the Lat down, shattering it into many pieces. Bird found no one there when he came, and set a strong guard. Nothing happened that night, but the Hindus were “in a state of great excitement.” Bird’s own telling runs another way. The pillar fell first, and the Hindus burned a mosque in revenge. Then the Muslims killed a cow and poured her blood into the sacred well. Buyers puts the cow on one of the holiest ghats. Greaves has the Lat fall once before a nearby mosque burned, once after. Heber also heard that the Hindus answered “by throwing rashers of bacon into the windows of as many mosques as they could reach.”
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
The Storm Broke
In Nevill’s account, “the next day, however, the storm broke.” About noon a great crowd of armed Rajputs, followed by hundreds of gosains, Hindu ascetics, “maddened,” made for the Lat. They set Aurangzeb’s mosque there on fire, desecrated it, and killed every Muslim in the neighbourhood. In Heber’s account every Hindu who could bear arms took up a weapon and attacked the Muslims wherever he met them, until they were “in danger of actual extermination.” The whole city was given up to plunder and slaughter. The troops could do nothing, and Bird withdrew them. Alone, he went to the Rajput leaders and talked them out of more harm, for a time. But when he left, they crossed the city to the shrine of Fatima and the tomb of a prince, Jiwan Bakht, near the Pisachmochan tank, and began to destroy them. Bird followed, and was forced to give the order to fire. The Rajput leader fell at the first volley. More troops came up, and the rioters drew back. Several bazaars were burning, and the whole weavers’ quarter was a scene of plunder and violence. In Nevill’s account, by the time the troops had restored order, “some fifty mosques had been destroyed and several hundred persons had lost their lives.” Buyers has one mosque pulled down, the rest saved by guards.
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
Even with the Ground
Heber was told that the sepoys’ temper was “extremely doubtful.” Most were Hindus, and perhaps half were Brahmins. In the front rank of the mob that faced them came Brahmins, yogis and gosains. Their bodies and faces were smeared with chalk and ashes, and their long hair was untied, as men vowed to die. They showed their sacred threads, and screamed the bitterest curses of their religion at any soldier who kept up “an unnatural war against their brethren and their gods.” The sepoys did not move. They held their military oath the most sacred of all bonds. They fired at a Brahmin as readily as at anyone else. They guarded the gate of a mosque as faithfully as if it had been the gate of their own temple. In Heber’s words, “Their courage and steadiness preserved Benares from ruin.” Two Brahmin sepoys stood guard in the mosque where the broken pillar lay on the ground. “Ah,” said one, “we have seen that which we never thought to see. Siva’s shaft has its head even with the ground. We shall all be of one caste shortly. What will be our religion then?” “I suppose the Christian,” the other answered. “I suppose so too,” said the first: after all that had passed, he was sure they would never turn Muslims. In Buyers’ telling it is the second soldier who says that.
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
Ganges Was Ganges Still
When the fighting was over, the Brahmins held that the holy city had been profaned. A cow’s blood had been mixed with the purest water of the Ganges; salvation could no longer be had at Kashi. All the Brahmins of the city, many thousands of them, went down to the river in a sorrowful procession, with ashes on their heads, naked and fasting. They sat on the main ghats with their hands folded and their heads hanging down, and would not go into a house or taste food. After two or three days the fast began to tire them. A hint reached the officials that a visit of sympathy would comfort the mourners. So the British officials went down to the main ghat and said they were sorry for the distress they saw. But, they reasoned, it made no sense for the Brahmins to punish themselves for an act they had no part in. That won them over. “After much bitter weeping,” it was resolved that “Ganges was Ganges still,” and that costly offerings from the people of Kashi might wipe out the stain. Bird was one of the officials who went. He spoke of “the gaunt squalid figures of the devotees,” their anguish and dismay, and the screams of the women round them. It was “a spectacle of woe such as few cities but Benares could supply.”
1809: The Riot and the Lat Bhairo
What the Lat Became
To Nevill, it was Bird’s “tactful persuasion” that slowly brought order back, and for months guards stood by the chief temples and mosques alike. Of the broken pillar, people said that it had been carried to the Ganges and thrown into the river. Greaves gives that as what “some say,” and thought it likelier that the pieces were gathered up, once things were quiet, and cased in copper. In 1868 a pillar seven or eight feet high stood on a low stone platform above the tank, cased in copper and carefully watched over by Brahmin priests. M. A. Sherring thought it might be a piece of the old one. A great fair had once been held there every year. By then the place was well-nigh abandoned, and the fair drew no more than a few dozen people. By 1905 the Lat Bhairo was “reduced to a height of a few feet.” It was covered with copper sheeting, painted red, and worshipped as a lingam. “No Muhammadan is permitted to approach it.” Told from Reginald Heber, Narrative of a Journey, vol. I (1828), pp. 290 and 323-325, with what W. W. Bird told him; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 207-209; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 190-195, quoting William Buyers, Recollections of Northern India; E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), pp. 204-209, also from Buyers; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), pp. 9-10 and his entry on the Lat Bhairo. Heber calls the pillar Siva’s walking-staff; Havell says it is believed to be a fragment of a column of Ashoka. The processions were the Mohurram and the Janmashtami in Heber, the Mohurram and the Holi in Buyers; Havell says both were “inflamed with religious excitement, bhang, and alcohol.” Heber elsewhere has the cow killed at the Gyanvapi well and her blood poured into its water. Heber has the Hindus on the point of burning every mosque within twenty-four hours, but for the sepoys; Greaves gives fifty mosques and several hundred dead as what “is said”. Bird called the fury of both sides “more like that of demoniacs than rational enemies.” Heber dates the riot “a few years ago”, Sherring “some sixty years ago” from 1868. Bird is the acting magistrate in Nevill, the Collector in Greaves. After the riot a feud broke out between the soldiers and the police, Hindus and Muslims on both sides, which ended with a reorganisation of the police in October 1810.