Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
1857, II: Martial Law
A Row of Gallows
On the morning after the disarming parade at Kashi, one writer of the time recorded, the first thing he saw from the Mint was a “row of gallowses.” The parade, on 4 June 1857, had been called to disarm the Indian soldiers, the sepoys, of the station. Instead the 37th regiment revolted, the Sikh regiment was fired on by the English, and the scattered soldiers poured out into the country. On 9 June martial law was proclaimed over the Kashi and Allahabad divisions. That same day the commissioner at Kashi, Henry Tucker, asked the Governor-General for something else: to give the power of life and death to the civil magistrates. He preferred that to martial law, because “I do not think the greater proportion of the military can be intrusted with the power of life and death,” he wrote. “The atrocious murders which have taken place have roused the English blood, and a very slight circumstance would cause Natives to be shot or hung.” A civilian, he believed, was used to weighing evidence. “No civilian is likely to order a man to be executed without really good cause.” Kaye, who wrote the history of these months, answers him in one line: “Time soon exploded the error contained in these last words.” Yet he grants that Tucker was right about the hot English blood.
1857, II: Martial Law
Every Man for Himself
The city stayed quiet. The countryside did not. Within a few days of the parade law and order were swept away in the villages round Kashi. “I could not have believed,” Tucker wrote on 13 June, “that the moment the hand of Government was removed there would have been so sudden a rising of landholders to plunder each other and people on the roads.” The landholders who had bought land at auction were driven out, their agents often murdered. “The Native idea now is,” he added, “that British rule has slipped off, and that it is every man for himself.” The landholders had a cause. Under the revenue policy of early British days one old Rajput clan had lost a great part of its lands to auction-purchasers. In H. R. Nevill’s words, its people “never reconciled themselves to their changed position, and in 1857 it proved necessary to teach them more than one severe lesson.” Now, in almost every case, the Rajput landholders drove the purchasers out, “in many instances” with murder. “Those who had lost their estates under our rule,” wrote one official in his report, “thought this a good time to regain them.” At Jaunpur, forty miles away, the Sikh detachment heard that their own regiment had been fired on at Kashi, and rose. Their officer and the joint magistrate were shot, and the English houses burnt.
1857, II: Martial Law
Pariah-Dogs
The answer was swift. In Kaye’s words, English officers were hunting down criminals of every kind “and hanging them up with as little compunction as though they had been pariah-dogs, or jackals, or vermin of a baser kind.” Within a few days military courts sat daily, “sentencing old and young to be hanged with indiscriminate ferocity.” They were called “Colonel Neill’s hangings.” But Neill left Kashi four or five days after the parade, and the sentences were not his to confirm. Once some young boys, who had perhaps in mere sport waved rebel colours and gone about beating tom-toms, were tried and sentenced to death. One of the officers of the court, “a man unsparing before an enemy under arms,” went with tears in his eyes to the commanding officer and begged him to spare them, “but with little effect on the side of mercy.” Worse, Kaye feared, was what was done with no form at all. Volunteer hanging parties went out into the districts. One gentleman boasted of the numbers he had finished off “in an artistic manner,” with mango-trees for gibbets and elephants for drops, the victims strung up, as though for pastime, “in the form of a figure of eight.”
1857, II: Martial Law
The Gibbet and the Lash
Mounted troops rode out “to punish the worst villages,” and many more such expeditions followed, “often conducted by volunteers.” In Kashi a permanent gallows was set up. The city jail had held through the rising; no prisoner was let loose. But it could not hold the numbers now brought in. So, in Kaye’s words, “the Gibbet disposed of the higher class of malefactors, and the Lash scored the backs of the lower.” The new laws, he adds, “fed the gallows with equal prodigality, though, I believe, with greater discrimination.” The two writers judge it differently. To Nevill, the “sharp lesson” of the gallows “bore the most beneficial results.” To Kaye, the military courts had hanged “with indiscriminate ferocity.” Nevill gives the chief credit for the city’s peace to the judge, Frederick Gubbins, who had taken on the magistrate’s work. Kaye adds that he was severe at the height of the crisis, but held his hand once the worst had passed. “Banaras was safe.” Parties of English troops came up from Calcutta more and more often. Tucker kept the few white soldiers on the move, showing them first at one place, then another, “to make an appearance of many, as in a mimic theatre of war.”
1857, II: Martial Law
Nine Miles Out
The country was still against them. On 11 July Colonel Gordon wrote from Kashi to Neill. Allahabad at least had a fort, he said; Kashi was far more exposed: “A few hundred Europeans separated from the river by a city containing half a million of inhabitants, and the country people already becoming more and more hostile every day.” Early in July the Rajputs of the Jaunpur district, with others from north of the city, marched on Kashi to attack it. They came within nine miles. There, in Nevill’s words, “they were met and severely chastised,” and on the 17th their leaders came in and gave full submission. Edwin Greaves says only that “the attack was repelled.”
1857, II: Martial Law
The Fort on the Heights
The English had seen how weak their position was: a few hundred men, cut off from the river by the city. In Nevill’s account, a large fort was built in July, “mainly by means of convict labour,” on the site of the old Hindu castle at Rajghat, on the high bank of the river. That castle was said to have been built by Raja Banar, and was certainly very old. M. A. Sherring places the work on the high ground behind Barna Ghat, near the old fort. He has it begun at an early stage of the rising. Embankments were “thrown up with incredible speed.” Step by step the fortress was strengthened, and until it was abandoned it was one of the strongest and largest in India. To Nevill, by this means “the place was effectually dominated”; to Greaves, from there “the city could be more easily overawed.” In time the fort was given up. Greaves thought its ruins were probably broken down when the Dufferin Bridge was built. Not long before he wrote, on a train close to the spot, he met an old soldier who told him he had been quartered in the fort many years before. But in 1868 Sherring had written: “The heights overlook the entire city, which lies completely at the mercy of the force in occupation of them.” Told from Kaye and Malleson, History of the Indian Mutiny, vol. II (1898 ed.), Book V, chapter “Banaras and Allahabad”, pp. 175-180, with Tucker’s letters and the official narrative of Taylor in its notes, and Gordon’s letter to Neill of 11 July, c. p. 296; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 213-214, 245 and 301; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 187-188; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), pp. 11-12. The clan was the Raghubansi Rajputs of Katehir. Of the boys sentenced to death, Kaye adds that what in England is a boy by years is in India a man, “a husband, a father.”