Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Akbar’s Punishment, Then the City Flowers
A Hundred Thousand Temples in a Day
Scattered about Kashi in odd corners, placed under pipal and banyan trees for worship, are numbers of tiny temples. Each is carved from a single block of stone, with the curved Hindu spire. Some are carved all over with many minute temples, all of the same shape. The popular story about them is this. Raja Man Singh of Amber lived in the reign of the emperor Akbar. He made a vow to present a hundred thousand temples to the city, and ordered them to be begun and finished in one day. The only way to do it was to carve them all in miniature. E. B. Havell does not believe it. He calls the tale an invention of the Brahmans; the stones, he thinks, are votive shrines from long before Man Singh’s time. To H. R. Nevill, Kashi had sunk into relative insignificance before Akbar; under Akbar’s tolerant rule it “flourished greatly,” and many temples were built by Hindu princes, Man Singh above all. Yet Akbar’s reign in Kashi began with a punishment.
Akbar’s Punishment, Then the City Flowers
The Emperor’s Punishment
The man who first brought the district into Akbar’s hands, in 1559, was one of his own commanders, Khan Zaman. Then he rebelled against his sovereign. In 1565 Akbar came to Jaunpur and Kashi himself and settled matters. But Khan Zaman proved faithless again: he seized Kashi “as soon as Akbar’s back was turned.” He was soon driven out of the city, but he was not brought to bay and killed until 1567. Then the emperor went to Kashi. The city was plundered, “for the share taken by the inhabitants in the rebellion.” Seven years later Akbar passed that way again, on his campaign to Bengal. He came to Kashi by river, stayed three days, and went on downstream to Patna.
Akbar’s Punishment, Then the City Flowers
Man Singh’s Palace
Man Singh left a building on the river that still stands. The great palace on Man Mandil Ghat is the oldest of the palaces in Kashi, built by him about the year 1600. Its beautiful stone balcony is part of the first work. Most of the rest fell into ruin, and in the middle of the nineteenth century it was patched with brick and plaster in a very inferior style. From the first it was called Manamandira, after Man Singh, and the name has worn down to Manmandil. In James Prinsep’s day no building in the town could be traced further back than Man Singh’s time. Fitzedward Hall thought it might be the only notable Hindu building of the city that had stood whole for so long. Havell has Man Singh’s descendant Raja Jai Singh turn it into an observatory in 1693. Prinsep and Hall tell it otherwise: Man Singh built the observatory himself, and Jai Singh, about a century later, only gave it its instruments; Prinsep dates them to 1680.
Akbar’s Punishment, Then the City Flowers
Flowering, or a Blank?
Not every writer agrees that the city flowered. To Hall, who wrote the introduction to M. A. Sherring’s book on the city, its history under Muslim rule was “well-nigh a blank.” Its religion was no recommendation to its masters, “and commercial or political importance it had none.” “Even Akbar, with all his toleration of Hinduism, and occasional partiality to it, did nothing to prop the sinking fortunes of Benares.” Nevill holds that the city did flourish under Akbar, and he adds what came of it. “The rapid growth of the city that then ensued attracted the attention of Akbar’s more bigoted successors, and notably of Aurangzeb, who razed to the ground all the most celebrated temples.” Told from H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 194-196 and 236; E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), pp. 127-128 and 200-201; Fitzedward Hall’s introduction to M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. xxxv-xxxvi and notes; and James Prinsep, Benares Illustrated (1831), text to the plate of Man Mandil.