Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
Squeezing the Universe
“Who is this Bhairava who stands in Kashi? What is his form, what is his work, and what are his names?” In the Kashi Khanda, a Sanskrit text of the Skanda Purana, the sage Agastya puts this question to the god Skanda, who tells him the city’s stories. Skanda begins with a picture of the god. He grips the whole egg of the universe in both hands like a ripe mango. He squeezes it again and again and drinks its juice like a madman, dancing his wild tandava. May this Great Bhairava, Skanda prays, guard the three worlds from harm. Then he tells how Bhairava came to be. Not even Vishnu, he says, nor Brahma the creator, knows the greatness of Shiva. Shiva’s maya, his power of illusion, is hard to cross, and it deludes them all.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
Who Is the Highest?
Once, on the peak of Mount Meru, the great sages bowed to Brahma and asked him: “What is the one reality that never perishes?” Shiva’s maya clouded Brahma’s mind, and he named himself. “I am the womb of the world, the self-born, the one Lord. No one is freed who does not worship me. There is none greater than me.” Vishnu, who was there in the form of the sacrifice, laughed, his eyes red with anger. “What are you saying? I am the maker of the worlds. Without me the worlds cannot live. It is at my bidding that you create.” So the two asked the four Vedas to judge, and each of the Vedas named Shiva. But the two only smiled. “How can that lord of goblins be the highest? He sports with his wife on the burning ground, naked, grey with dust, with matted hair, a bull for his mount and snakes for his ornaments.” Then Om, the sacred syllable, took a form and laughed at them. “His wife is no stranger come from outside. She is his own power, his own bliss.” Even so, their delusion did not end.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
The Fifth Head Blazes
Then a great light rose between them, filling all the space between earth and sky. In the middle of it stood a great being, blue and red, with a trident in his hand. He had an eye in his forehead, and snakes and the moon for his ornaments. It was Shiva. Brahma had five heads then, and the fifth blazed with anger. It was Brahma who spoke to the being in the light. “I know you, moon-crested one. Long ago you came out of my forehead. You wept, and so I named you Rudra, the one who weeps. Come to me for refuge, son. I will protect you.” At these proud words Shiva grew angry, and out of himself he brought forth a being in the form of Bhairava.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
The Names of Kalabhairava
“This Brahma is yours to punish, Kalabhairava,” Shiva told him, and he gave him his names, each with its reason. “You blaze like Kala, Time the destroyer, so you are Kalaraja, King Time. Even Time will fear you, so you are Kalabhairava. You will eat up the sins of your devotees in an instant, so you will be Papabhakshana, the Eater of Sins.” Then he gave him a city. “Kashi, my city of release, is greater than all others. Its lordship is yours forever. Of those who sin there, you alone will be the judge.” Bhairava took these gifts, and in that instant, with the tip of the nail of his left finger, he cut off Brahma’s fifth head. It was the head that had spoken the insult, says the Kashi Khanda, and so it was the one to pay. The Matsya Purana tells it otherwise: there Shiva himself cuts off the head, with the nail of his left toe.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
The Woman in Red
Brahma, afraid, chanted a hymn to Shiva, and Shiva comforted him. Then he gave Bhairava a vow. Bhairava, the Kashi Khanda says, was Shiva’s own self in another form. “Carry Brahma’s skull,” Shiva told him. “To wipe out the sin of killing a Brahmin, wander the world begging, under the vow of the skull-bearer.” Then Shiva made a maiden called Brahmahatya, the Killing of a Brahmin. She was red, dressed in red, with red garlands. Her mouth was fearful with fangs, her tongue lolled, and she drank much blood. She was terrible even to Bhairava. “Follow him, fierce one, until he reaches holy Varanasi,” Shiva told her. “You may go anywhere but Varanasi.” And he vanished. Skull in hand, Bhairava wandered the three worlds. Brahmahatya would not leave him: not in Brahma’s world, not in Vishnu’s heaven, not in the city of Indra, king of the gods. He went from holy place to holy place, and nowhere was he set free.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
At Vishnu’s Door
With his goblin attendants around him, Bhairava came to Vishnu’s home. Vishnu saw him and fell flat on the ground like a stick, and all around him the gods and the sages fell down too. “Look,” he said to Lakshmi, his wife. “We are blessed: we see the lord of the world.” “What is this, lord?” he asked. “Why do you go begging?” “Brahma’s head was cut off with the tip of a nail,” said Bhairava. “To undo that sin I keep this vow.” Vishnu smiled. “Play as you please, but you cannot hide yourself from me. At the end of time you sweep away the gods and the worlds: where is your sin of killing a Brahmin then? A garland of the bones of Brahmas long gone shines on your neck. Where was Brahmahatya following you then?” Lakshmi dropped alms into the begging bowl, and Vishnu begged Brahmahatya to let him go. “By this pretext I serve him and make myself pure,” she said. “When would I be so near him again?” And she did not leave his side.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
The Skull Falls
So Bhairava went on through the worlds, and came to the city called Varanasi, the mother of release. The moment he set foot inside the holy field, Brahmahatya cried out “Ha! Ha!” and sank into the underworld. Brahma’s skull, which had never once left his hand wherever he wandered, fell from it in an instant. Everyone saw it fall, and he danced for joy. “The sin that left him nowhere vanished in Kashi in a moment,” says the Kashi Khanda. “How can Kashi not be hard to win?” In the Matsya Purana, too, the skull clings to Shiva until he reaches Kashi. Shiva begs Vishnu for alms, and Vishnu digs in his fingernail; blood runs out for a thousand years of the gods, and still the skull is not filled. Only when Shiva settles in Kashi does it fall, and break into a thousand pieces, and vanish “like the riches a man obtains in his dream.”
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
Kashi’s Two Guards
In Kashi there is a holy bathing place called Kapalamochana, the Release of the Skull. With that pool before him Bhairava stayed, eating up the sins of his devotees. The messengers of Yama, the god of death, are afraid of them, says the Kashi Khanda. Whoever lives in Kashi and does not worship Bhairava sees his sins grow like the waxing moon. Shiva set a second guard over the city. The Matsya Purana tells of a Yaksha, one of the spirit folk, who did penance in Kashi until he was a skeleton of white, shining bones. “The gods say you are hard,” Parvati told Shiva, “and it is true: you give no boon even to such a devotee.” So Shiva gave him a body like his own and made him guardian of the field, with a mace in his hand. In the Kashi Khanda Shiva names him Dandapani, Staff-in-Hand. “Drive out the wicked, the enemies of Kashi, and guard my city always,” he says. Dandapani confuses the sinners and leads them out of the city; and even a devotee of Shiva, the book says, cannot live in Kashi without his favour.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
The Kotwal
When M. A. Sherring wrote in 1868, in the people’s eyes Vishwanath, the Shiva of Kashi, was the city’s king. He ruled through Bhairava, whom the people called Bhaironath, as his kotwal, his chief of police. The kotwal’s watchmen were the gods along the Panchkosi road, the sacred boundary, nearly fifty miles round. They fought off any enemy who tried to break in, and reported to Bhairava. A story was told of one enemy who broke through. A powerful demon beat the watchmen, crossed the road and pressed on toward the city. Bhairava met him at the spot where the tank of Pisach-Mochan, the Release from Ghouls, now lies, and cut off his head. The head had lost neither its life nor its tongue. It begged the king to let it stay where it fell, and that every pilgrim bound for Gaya should visit it first. The king agreed, on one condition: no other evil spirit should ever enter the city. The demon’s great ugly head, carved in stone, sat at the top of the ghat, the steps down to the water.
Bhairava, Brahma’s Fifth Head and the City’s Kotwal
The Stone Staff
Bhairava’s temple stood a little over a mile north of Vishwanath’s. On the wall by its door Sherring saw him painted deep blue, almost black, with the dog he rides. Sweet-sellers made little dogs of sugar for worshippers to offer him, and dogs were let into his temple, though into no other. Inside stood the god, of stone with a silver face, in a shrine all of copper; and because he liked strong drink, spirits were among his offerings. Baji Rao of Poona had built the temple “upwards of forty years ago.” A kotwal must have his truncheon, and Bhairava had one, in a temple of its own a short way off. It was a cudgel of enormous thickness, “not, indeed, of wood, but, what is more terrible, of stone.” It was a stone about four feet high, worshipped by a great many people every Tuesday and Sunday. The people called it Dandpan; properly, Dandapani was Shiva’s attendant, and his staff had become a god. And beside the stone sat a priest with a rod of peacock feathers. In the name of Dandpan he gently tapped each worshipper, and so punished them for their sins. Told from the Kashi Khanda of the Skanda Purana (Sanskrit; our translation), ch. 31 v. 1-157 and ch. 32 v. 150-164; the Matsya Purana, translated by a Taluqdar of Oudh (1917), ch. 180 v. 80-100 and ch. 183 v. 81-106; and M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 47-48, 61-65 and 123-124.