Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Bindu Madhava Falls: The Mosque on Panchganga
Off the Southern Minaret
Above Panchganga ghat in Kashi, one of the great stone stairways down to the Ganges, stands a mosque built by the Mughal emperor Aurangzeb. Its two minarets rose above every building in the city, and could be seen from many miles away. James Prinsep, who drew Kashi, records what some men did with that height. In the ten years before he wrote, four or five men threw themselves from the top of the southern minaret. One had gambled away his money and his wife during Diwali. Another was a sailor who, he thought, was deceived by the height and believed the river was within reach. He fell on the roof of the house beside the terrace, and was killed on the spot. One man lived. A fakir, a wandering holy man, made the same leap. He crashed through the tiles and matting of a roof, which tore the flesh from his sides, and landed on the floor below with every bone whole. Such an escape was thought a miracle, and crowds came to reward and tend a man so favoured by heaven. Then, to complete their wonder, he vanished as soon as his bruises healed, and with him vanished “sundry solid moveables of his host.”
Bindu Madhava Falls: The Mosque on Panchganga
The Temple of Bindu Madhava
A temple stood there first, and Aurangzeb built the mosque on its site and out of its materials. To Prinsep it was the temple of Bindu Madhava, a form of Vishnu, which the French traveller Tavernier had described as filling the whole ground from Panchganga to Ram Ghat, with other temples and many houses of its priests inside its walls. H. R. Nevill says only that it was a temple of Vishnu. In Nevill’s day its common name was still the Deorha of Madho Das; Prinsep called it the Madhoray mosque. Edwin Greaves took Madho Das for the architect who carried out the emperor’s wishes. It was not the only mosque of Aurangzeb’s in Kashi that stood where a temple had been. Near the small Ratneshwar temple is the Alamgiri Masjid, built, tradition says, from the stones of the temple of Kirtti Bisheshwar. In M. A. Sherring’s day Hindus still came on pilgrimage to worship the spout of a fountain in its courtyard. By the Lat Bhairo, an ancient stone pillar, Aurangzeb destroyed a temple of Bhairo and built a mosque, and from then on, down to 1905, the terrace there was “a frequent battle-field” for Hindu and Muslim factions.
Bindu Madhava Falls: The Mosque on Panchganga
Over the Rooftops
The minarets were only eight and a quarter feet across at the base and seven and a quarter at the top, and rose from a terrace about 80 feet above the river. The writers give their height as 147 feet 2 inches (Prinsep), 142 feet (Nevill) and not less than 150 (Sherring). When Prinsep drew them, both towers leaned outward by 15 inches and were under repair. On the very day the scaffolding came down, lightning struck one of them. They had once been some fifty feet higher, and were cut down when they showed signs of weakness. The mosque below them was plain. Prinsep believed the emperor was not satisfied with triumphing over the Hindus’ religion: he carried his minarets so high to look down into the privacy of their houses, whose upper rooms and roof terraces belonged to the women of the family. To Greaves it was “a cruel irony” to have set the mosque “right in the very heart of Hindu sacred shrines,” and the irony was the greater because it was known by a Hindu’s name.
Bindu Madhava Falls: The Mosque on Panchganga
The Keeper of the Mosque
For all its height, the mosque stood almost empty. Sherring found it astonishing that a building so visited by Europeans, who counted it among the chief sights of Kashi, should be almost abandoned by Muslims. A few gathered there to pray on Fridays, and on no other day. For the other six days it was left to two men: a mullah, its prayer-leader, and his servant. A small village had once paid part of its costs, but the village had lapsed to the Government, and in Sherring’s day the gifts of visitors paid for its repairs. In Prinsep’s drawing of Panchganga, the minarets tower up from behind a massive stone house. It belonged in name to the Raja of Jaipur, but a family of Brahman temple priests lived there. In 1909 the only person usually in the mosque was its mullah: “a descendant, it is said, of the man first appointed by Aurangzeb.”
Bindu Madhava Falls: The Mosque on Panchganga
A Stupendous Jest
Nevill saw the mosque as a joke of the emperor’s. To him it was hard to say whether Aurangzeb’s bigotry was “real or feigned.” But the emperor “was certainly not devoid of a grim humour,” never shown more strikingly than by this “stupendous jest”: “the mosque on the river bank whose minarets tower above the sacred city of the Hindus.” In one thing Aurangzeb failed. He gave Kashi a new name, Muhammadabad. The people never took to it. It lasted only a short time in official papers. It is also found on the coins of his reign and the reigns after, for Kashi had been a mint town since the days of Akbar. Greaves found it, it seems, only in a few state papers. Fitzedward Hall, in his introduction to Sherring’s book, had met it in an Urdu book, and believed it never had any currency. In Greaves’s day the minarets still stood over the city; of the name, he wrote: “Probably few know that it was ever so named.” Told from James Prinsep, Benares Illustrated (1831), the text to the plates “Madhoray Ghat and the Minarets” and Panchganga and Ram Ghat; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 110-113 and 312-313, with Fitzedward Hall’s introduction, p. xxxv; E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), pp. 76 and 204-205; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 197, 244-245 and 253; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), pp. 3 and 53-54. The Lat Bhairo battlefield is Havell’s phrase.