Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
“It Will Not Sell at Kashi”
Prakashananda was a celebrated teacher of the Vedanta philosophy in Kashi, and gave public lectures to his many pupils. One day a Brahman of Kashi came to him, a Maratha named Raghunath. He had just seen a sanyasi, a wandering monk, who had come to the city. “His limbs are fair as the purest gold,” Raghunath said; “he is long-armed and lotus-eyed. His eyes run tears like the Ganges stream. Now he dances, now laughs, now sings and now weeps, or at times roars like the lion.” His name was Krishna-Chaitanya. The philosopher laughed and scoffed. “I have heard of a sanyasi in Bengal, an emotionalist, a fraud on the public. He is named Chaitanya, and with his emotional band he roams over the country dancing. Everyone who sees him calls him God. He is a sanyasi in name only, but really a great wizard. But his stock in trade of sentimentality will not sell at Kashi. Attend to Vedanta; do not resort to him.” How that stock sold after all is told in Chaitanya’s life, the Chaitanya-charit-amrita. It had begun at noon, on the Manikarnika ghat, the stone steps down to the river.
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
Noon at Manikarnika
Chaitanya was on his way to Mathura. He reached Kashi and bathed at noon at the Manikarnika ghat. Tapan Misra, a devotee of his, was bathing there too. He had only heard that Chaitanya had turned hermit, and was surprised to see him. When he was sure, he wept and clasped his feet; Chaitanya raised him and embraced him. Tapan Misra took him to the temples of Vishwanath and Bindu Madhava, and then home. There he danced in ecstasy with his garment fluttering, and he and his whole family drank the water that had washed Chaitanya’s feet. He begged him to dine nowhere else while he was in Kashi, and Chaitanya stayed some ten days, against his will. Raghunath the Maratha Brahman asked him to dine too, and was put off day after day. It was after seeing him that Raghunath went to Prakashananda, and came back grieved.
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
A Load Too Heavy to Carry
Raghunath told Chaitanya all that the philosopher had said. Chaitanya smiled. When the philosopher spoke his name in his abuse, Raghunath went on, three times he had said “Chaitanya” without adding “Krishna”. Philosophers like him, Chaitanya answered, cannot speak Krishna’s name, for the name and Krishna are one. Then he took up the philosopher’s jibe. “He has said that I have come to Kashi with a parcel of sentiments for which there is no customer here, and I must take it all back! Well, how shall I carry away this heavy load? I can sell it here even for a trifle.” Next morning he set out for Mathura. While he was away, his friends in Kashi used to meet and sing his praise, “mad with love.”
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
“I Have Always to Dwell in Kashi”
Later Chaitanya came back to Kashi, and this time he stayed to teach a disciple. But he had slighted the sanyasis, and they spoke ill of him everywhere; his devotees grieved to hear it. So did Raghunath. If he could bring the sanyasis and Chaitanya together, he thought, they would see the truth and follow him. “I have always to dwell in Kashi,” he said, “and if I do not effect this it will be a matter of everlasting regret to me.” He invited all the sanyasis to his house. Then he went to Chaitanya, clasped his feet, and with much entreaty made him accept. At noon Chaitanya went to Raghunath’s house, and there, the book says, he saved the sanyasis. From that day the city was stirred. Crowds came to see him. Scholars of every school came to argue, and he answered them all; they began to chant Krishna’s name. “All men laughed, sang, and danced.” The sanyasis left their studies and formed meetings of their own.
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
“A Stream of Nectar”
Then a disciple of Prakashananda, his equal in learning, spoke in open meeting. Chaitanya, he said, was Narayan, God himself. “Our teacher gives a fanciful explanation” of the scriptures; Chaitanya’s words “we feel to be truth indeed.” Prakashananda answered that Shankaracharya, eager to establish his Monism, had to twist the sense of the aphorisms he explained. Each school of philosophy only knocks down its rivals. “Only the words of great men are reliable. Chaitanya’s words are a stream of nectar.” Raghunath went in delight to tell Chaitanya. He met him on his way to the temple of Bindu Madhava, after his bath at Panchganga. Before the god, Chaitanya was enraptured and danced in the temple courtyard, while his devotees chanted the names of Hari and Krishna. Lakhs of men gathered round, shouting “Hari! Hari!” The cry filled earth and heaven.
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
At the Feet of Chaitanya
Prakashananda heard it, and came with his pupils out of curiosity. He saw Chaitanya dance, and he and his disciples joined the cry of “Hari!” Chaitanya trembled, spoke in a choking voice, changed colour, stood rigid, and bathed those near him with his tears, “to the marvel of the people of Benares.” Seeing the crowd, Chaitanya came to himself and stopped. He bowed very low to Prakashananda, and Prakashananda clasped his feet. “You are the instructor of the world,” Chaitanya cried, “and I am not worthy to be your pupil’s pupil.” “By touching your feet,” Prakashananda replied, “I have washed away all the sin of my former abuse of you.” He sat down with Chaitanya and asked him to explain the scriptures.
Chaitanya and Prakashananda
Given Away for Nothing
All the people of Kashi began to chant Krishna’s name, laughing, dancing and singing. Back at his lodging, Chaitanya turned the philosopher’s words into a jest: “I had come to Benares to sell my sentimental stuff for which there was no purchaser here. I could not carry my merchandise back to my country, as you would have been grieved to see me carrying the load. So to please you all I have distributed my goods freely!” His followers answered, “Benares alone was adverse to you, and now you have redeemed it.” Word spread, and country people came to the city in their millions. They lined the road on both sides to see him go to bathe or to the temple of Vishwanath. With arms raised he told them to chant Hari’s name. After five days Chaitanya walked away by night. His friends followed, Raghunath among them, wanting to go with him. He sent them back gently, giving them leave to come afterwards. Told from the Chaitanya-charit-amrita in Jadunath Sarkar’s translation, Chaitanya’s Pilgrimages and Teachings (1913), Introduction and ch. XV and XXIII, pp. 206-210 and 305-315; with the second edition, Chaitanya’s Life and Teachings (1922), ch. XV, pp. 186-187. Sarkar calls Prakashananda “the celebrated Vedantist,” and says he “was latterly converted to bhakti,” devotion, “by Chaitanya and changed his name into Prabodhananda.”