Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Chet Singh and Hastings, I: The Demand
A Turban in His Lap
In July 1781 Warren Hastings, the Governor-General of the East India Company in Bengal, left Calcutta and went up the Ganges. At Buxar, the place nearest the border of his own lands, Raja Chet Singh of Kashi came to meet him, as custom required. He came with a great fleet of boats, crowded, Hastings learned afterwards, with two thousand armed and chosen men. Hastings took it as a breach of good manners, even between equals. When he had met the Nawab of Oudh at Kashi in 1773, the Nawab had sent away his large retinue on hearing that Hastings came unattended. The next day the Raja came to Hastings’ own boat and asked to speak to him alone. He was sorry, he said, that Hastings was displeased with him; his lands and all he had were at Hastings’ service. He spoke of his fear of plots among his own relations. Then he laid his turban in Hastings’ lap: a gesture that in India “marks the most profound submission and devotion.” Hastings answered that his business was with the Raja, and with him only. Once already the Raja’s oaths had deceived him, and he would not be turned from his purpose by words that cost little. The Raja owned that he was at fault in every way, and begged Hastings to forget the past. Hastings would say no more, and the Raja took his leave.
Chet Singh and Hastings, I: The Demand
The Son Who Became Raja
Chet Singh was not the lawful heir. He was the son of Raja Balwant Singh by a Rajput woman. When Balwant Singh died in 1770, his only lawful child was a daughter, and her infant son, Mahip Narayan, was the heir. But Chet Singh was “old enough and clever enough” to win the throne for himself. The old Raja’s confidential agent, Ausan Singh, pressed his claim. Chet Singh made his peace with his overlord, the Nawab of Oudh, “mainly by a bribe of 22 lakhs”: twenty-two hundred thousand rupees. The Nawab came to Kashi and Ramnagar to greet the new ruler. Hastings himself, by his own account, won him the sanad, the deed of grant, that made the province his. In 1775 a new Nawab ceded the province to the Company. Chet Singh kept it, under the eye of a Company officer, the Resident at Kashi, for a fixed yearly rent. He was shrewd, and played the factions in Hastings’ Council against each other. But he quarrelled with Ausan Singh, one of the most powerful men in the province. It was a rich province to hold. To T. B. Macaulay its city was among the foremost of Asia. Half a million people, it was believed, in “that labyrinth of lofty alleys, rich with shrines, and minarets, and balconies, and carved oriels.”
Chet Singh and Hastings, I: The Demand
Money and Horsemen
The trouble began with a war. In July 1778, when news came of war with France, the Raja was required to pay an extra five lakhs of rupees. In Hastings’ account he agreed “with a very ill grace,” and paid with a much worse one. The next year he paid only when two battalions of sepoys, the Company’s Indian soldiers, were quartered on him at his own cost. In 1780 he sent his manager to Calcutta to beg Hastings’ pardon and swear obedience. Hastings forgave him, on one condition: that this year’s five lakhs be paid at once and in full. The Raja promised. About a lakh came in; there he stopped. The last two and a half lakhs were paid only in October, and again only when troops were ordered to march. The Company’s army in Malwa, waiting for the money, was reduced to extreme distress, and many of its men deserted. This, Hastings held, was the time the Raja’s oaths had deceived him. In November 1780 the Raja was asked for cavalry: two thousand horse, then fifteen hundred, then a thousand. In Hastings’ words, “He offered 250, but furnished none.” The Raja’s own account was that he had five hundred horse and five hundred armed foot ready to go wherever they were sent, and never had an answer. In Macaulay’s account the Raja’s fixed tribute itself had always been paid “with strict punctuality.”
Chet Singh and Hastings, I: The Demand
Pay Largely for His Pardon
Hastings believed the Raja was rich and plotting. It was said that he had inherited a vast treasure from his father and kept it in his strong forts, adding to it every year. He was said to keep a large army and to write to the Marathas. An officer told Hastings that the Raja pleaded poverty and offered his jewels to pawn, yet begged him to accept two thousand rupees as a present for the officer’s “little girl.” Hastings made up his mind. “I was resolved to draw from his guilt the means of relief to the Company’s distresses,” he wrote. “In a word, I had determined to make him pay largely for his pardon, or to exact a severe vengeance for his past delinquency.” Before leaving Calcutta he told a close friend, in confidence, that the fine would be forty or fifty lakhs. If the Raja refused, he would take his lands from him, or seize his forts and take the money from the treasure in them. Hearing that Hastings was coming, the Raja offered twenty lakhs. Hastings would not have it. Macaulay, who quotes that sentence, says Hastings “was determined to plunder” the Raja. To Gleig, Hastings’ biographer, the Raja’s refusals deserved “not less than confiscation,” and Hastings was “too wise, as well as too humane,” to go so far.
Chet Singh and Hastings, I: The Demand
An Answer by Night
Hastings reached Kashi on 14 August and lodged in the garden house of Madho Das, on the west side of the city. The Raja was living at his own house at Shivala Ghat, a strong fort on the river some two miles off. A ghat is a stairway of stone steps down to the water. Hastings would not let him visit that day. On the 15th the Resident, William Markham, carried the Raja a paper of charges, with a demand for an answer at once. “But you deceived me,” it ran. The subsidy had been held back until the army was in the last distress, and “many hundreds deserted.” Of the horse: “nor to this hour have you contributed a single horseman.” And robberies and murders went on “even in the streets of the city of Banaris itself.” Late that evening the Raja’s answer came. Hastings had never replied to his many letters. He had paid the five lakhs in full, and sending it on to the army had never been his to do. He had made the horse ready and heard nothing. Robbers in his lands he impaled or otherwise punished. “My enemies, with a view to my ruin, have made false representations to you. … I am in every case your slave.” Hastings found it “not only unsatisfactory in substance, but offensive in stile.” At ten that night he ordered Markham to go early next morning and put the Raja under arrest.
Chet Singh and Hastings, I: The Demand
Your Slave
Early on 16 August Markham went to Shivala Ghat with a few orderlies and Lieutenant Stalker, and told the Raja he was under arrest. Any attempt to rescue him, he warned, would end in the Raja’s own destruction. The Raja submitted quietly. His lands, his forts and his treasure he would lay at Hastings’ feet, he said, “and his life if required.” He asked only for a living, and begged Hastings to allow for “his youth and inexperience,” and for his father’s name. A quarter of an hour later two companies of grenadier sepoys arrived. Markham left the Raja in their charge, under three English officers, with orders to disarm all his servants and to allow him eight or ten attendants of his choosing. The Raja wrote to Hastings at once. “Whatever may be your pleasure, do it with your own hands: I am your slave. What occasion can there be for a guard?” Then: “Whoever with his hands in a supplicating posture is ready with his life and property, what necessity can there be for him to be dealt with in this way?” Seeing his despair, Hastings sent him a line: “Set your mind at rest, and do not conceive any terror or apprehension.” The Raja wrote back: “My Protector! Wherever you spread your shadow over my head, I am entirely free from concern and apprehension.” Told from Warren Hastings, A Narrative of the Insurrection at Banaris (1782), pp. 1-9, 13-23 and Appendix p. 163, with Edward Wheler’s statement and the letters of Hastings, Chet Singh and Markham printed in it; G. R. Gleig, Memoirs of Warren Hastings, vol. II (1841), pp. 398-410; T. B. Macaulay, Warren Hastings (1841), pp. 97-105; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 202-203; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 197-199; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), pp. 6-7. At Buxar the Raja also spoke of his fear of Ausan Singh, then in Hastings’ train. Nevill and Greaves date the sanad 1772, at a meeting of the Nawab and Hastings in Kashi; Hastings dates it September 1773. At Buxar, Hastings has two thousand armed men in boats, and a list in his appendix about 140 boats with near five hundred horse and two thousand matchlockmen on the bank; Gleig has six hundred cavalry; Macaulay has the Raja come near sixty miles with his guards. Of the cavalry, Hastings says 250 were offered; the Raja and Gleig, five hundred horse and as many matchlockmen (the Raja says burkandazes). The fine: Edward Wheler, the friend Hastings confided in, forty or fifty lakhs, Gleig and Nevill fifty, Macaulay half a million pounds; the Raja’s offer: twenty lakhs in Gleig, £200,000 in Macaulay. Macaulay alone tells that in 1780 the Raja secretly offered Hastings a bribe of £20,000, which Hastings took, concealed for a time and then paid into the Company’s treasury, and adds a fine of £10,000 for delay. The distance from Hastings’ quarters to Shivala is about two miles in Hastings, nearly three in Sherring.