Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Jonathan Duncan’s Kashi: The College and the Casket
Where Was the Box?
Sarnath, near Kashi, is a field of ruins: the remains of old Buddhist buildings, with a great tower called Dhamek standing over them. In 1835 Alexander Cunningham, then a lieutenant, was digging into that tower, and he kept asking the people round him one question. Everyone had heard the story. Long before, workmen digging here for bricks had found a stone box that held bones, jewels and gold. But no one, it seemed, knew where. At length an old man came forward. His name was Sangkar, a Rajbhar of the village of Singhpur close by. As a boy, he said, he had been one of those workmen. They were digging for Jagat Singh, the diwan, or chief minister, of Raja Chet Singh of Kashi. He wanted bricks for a new market in the city, to be named after himself: Jagatganj. Sangkar remembered the find. A large round box of common stone, and inside it a cylinder of green marble about fifteen inches high. In the marble box lay pearls and rubies, gold and silver earrings, and three pieces of a human arm bone. The marble box was taken to the Bara Sahib, the great gentleman, as Sangkar called Jonathan Duncan. The stone box was left where it lay. Here, Cunningham saw, was a ready test of the man’s word. Could he show the spot? Sangkar said yes, without any hesitation.
Jonathan Duncan’s Kashi: The College and the Casket
Before Sunset
They went together to the place, then a low, uneven mound in the middle of a hollow. Sangkar marked out a small space about four feet across and began to dig. Before sunset he had reached the stone box, twelve feet down and less than two feet from the middle of his pit. It was a large round block of sandstone, with a rough chamber hollowed in its centre and a flat slab for a lid. For Cunningham it was “the most complete and convincing proof” that the old man told the truth. The box had stood, Sangkar said, in a small square hole only just large enough to hold it. Round it was a stupa: a solid dome of brick built over relics, here forty-nine feet across. Jagat Singh’s men had dug out only part of it. Sangkar had one more thing to show. While they were digging, he said, the workmen had come upon a small building full of statues. They pulled down its walls and carried off the bricks, but left the statues standing. Cunningham dug where he pointed. Two feet down he found about sixty statues and carved panels, all upright, packed close together in a space less than ten feet square.
Jonathan Duncan’s Kashi: The College and the Casket
What Became of the Treasure
Cunningham dates the first find to January 1794; H. R. Nevill has 1793. The workmen rifled the box, and the finders seem to have disposed of most of the treasure. Only the green marble casket, with a few charred bones, pearls, rubies and gold leaves, reached Jonathan Duncan, the Resident: the officer of the British government at Kashi. Duncan wrote a short account of it, the earliest mention of the Sarnath ruins that Cunningham knew. To Duncan the casket held a few human bones, some decayed pearls, gold leaves “and other jewels of no value.” With the boxes the workmen had found a statue of the Buddha. It too was carried off to Jagatganj. Many years later, at Cunningham’s suggestion, another officer, Major Kittoe, searched the plundered stones there and found it, broken and mutilated, at Jagat Singh’s own house. Only its base was left. But its inscription could still be read. It was dated Samvat 1083, AD 1026, and it told of two brothers who, “having restored religion, raised this tower.” Cunningham believed that tower was the very stupa Jagat Singh had dug into: an ancient one, which the brothers had repaired.
Jonathan Duncan’s Kashi: The College and the Casket
Stone by Stone
Jagat Singh did not stop at that stupa. The work-people told Cunningham that he had deliberately destroyed the beautiful stone facing of the lower part of Dhamek too, to save a few rupees on new stone. Each block was slowly worked loose by cutting out the iron clamps that held it to the next, and carried off at once. To Cunningham the saving was little and the damage “quite irreparable.” He put it down to Jagat Singh’s “meanness.” Other builders used Sarnath too. Forty-eight statues and carved stones from Sarnath were thrown into the Barna river as a breakwater for a bridge. Fifty or sixty cart-loads went into another. To M. A. Sherring, “this vandalism hardly equals that of Babu Jagat Sinh,” who carted away a whole sacred tower. Even Duncan’s works had their share. When he built a new bridge over the Barna, some of its stone came “from the ruthless spoliation of the ancient Sarnath buildings.” Nearly half the core of Jagat Singh’s stupa was still standing in 1835. Later diggers took it for the stupa Ashoka built, and dug it out “until only a mere shell was left, without result.”
Jonathan Duncan’s Kashi: The College and the Casket
The Resident’s College
Duncan had come to Kashi as Resident in 1787. He made his name by ending the tolls and dues that landholders levied, and he brought the potato to the district. In the city he also founded a college. He was struck that Kashi had no Sanskrit college. In 1791 he won leave from Lord Cornwallis to set aside surplus revenue for a Hindu academy, to preserve and study Sanskrit literature in Kashi. It would make the British government popular, he thought. It would help recover and collect “the little known writings of ancient times.” And he hoped for a school of Hindu law, to train assessors and pleaders for the courts. On 28 October 1791 the college opened in a hired house; elsewhere the gazetteer dates its founding to 1792. Duncan drew up its rules himself, and its discipline was to be the one laid down by Manu, the ancient lawgiver. Its first principal was Kashinath Pandit, with eight teachers under him. It did not go well at first. In 1798 an inquiry dismissed several professors for neglecting their duty, and in 1801 Kashinath himself was dismissed. The college was made over again, with twelve teachers for the 121 free scholars on its rolls.
Jonathan Duncan’s Kashi: The College and the Casket
What Was Kept
The college lived. In 1853 it became part of Queen’s College, and by 1868 it was regarded as “the Oxford of India” for Hindu learning. In 1909 a library was rising in its grounds for its Sanskrit manuscripts. The casket did not. The green marble vase that Duncan gave to the Asiatic Society of Bengal in 1794 had vanished by 1834. The plain stone box that Sangkar dug up again went to the same society, a gift from Cunningham. Long after, he found it in their museum, listed as a coffin “found in the tope of Manikyala”: another stupa altogether. He printed the entry with an exclamation mark. In Nevill’s day the box was in the Indian Museum at Calcutta. Edwin Greaves tells it otherwise: the stone box was found inside the stupa when Major Kittoe and Mr Thomas investigated it some years later. And Jagat Singh’s market still stood in 1909, a quarter of the city’s suburbs, “built by Babu Jagat Singh from materials taken from Sarnath.” Told from Alexander Cunningham, Archaeological Survey of India: Four Reports, vol. I (1871), pp. 103-104, 113-119 and 128-129, with Jonathan Duncan’s account as he quotes it; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 67-68, 41-42, 137-138, 170-178, 184, 256-257, 341-342 and 359-360; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 25-26 and 332-333; E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), pp. 45-46; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), pp. 16-17 and 145-146. Sangkar counted 40 to 46 pearls, 14 rubies, 8 silver and 9 gold earrings. Cunningham dates the digging 1793-94; Nevill’s Sarnath entry, Havell and Greaves give 1794; Sherring dates the college 1791. Kittoe found the statue in 1849, Nevill says, and its base is now in Lucknow; the inscription names the brothers Sthirapala and Vasantapala, and Mahipala, king of Gauda. Greaves calls the box now in Calcutta “the marble box”; Cunningham says Kittoe and Thomas removed the rest of the stupa’s core about eighteen years after his dig. Duncan also gave land worth 2,400 rupees a year for the poor and stranger sick, and ended the farmed monopolies of lime and firewood. Emma Roberts wrote in 1834 of “cart loads” of tiles with figures of the Buddha dug up at Sarnath; Cunningham could find none.