Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Prinsep Measures the City
A Hundred and Fifty in a House
In 1803 the kotwal of Kashi, the city’s chief of police, counted its people for the city magistrate. His report found about 30,000 houses and 600,000 inhabitants. Years later James Prinsep, who held an official post at Kashi, looked into how the kotwal had reached his figure. Nowhere else in India had anyone counted more than five or six people to a house. The kotwal had counted twenty. And for a house of six stories he had allowed, in Prinsep’s words, “the extravagant estimate of 150 persons!” The size of the city had been stretched in the same way. English writers made it six miles long and four wide. The survey measured it at “barely three miles” along the river, and its depth did not average a mile. Prinsep lived at Kashi for ten years. In his leisure he drew views of it, and he made a map of the city. Artists, he thought, had done little to show Europe the holy city; the travellers’ sketches of it had “little either of minuteness or of fidelity.” His own claim was a plain one: “The only merit aimed at, has been that of faithful delineation.”
Prinsep Measures the City
Fifteen Hundred Turtles
One of Prinsep’s drawings shows the Mundakini, one of a line of ponds that ran through the town nearly parallel to the river. The pond was full of turtles, which the Hindus revered and fed. A few years before he wrote, a tunnel drain was cut under the town at Trilochan, and the ponds were laid dry. One of them was now a grain market. When the Mundakini was drained, a merchant offered to pay two annas a head for every turtle carried alive to the river. More than 1,500 were caught and moved. Many weighed two or three maunds, upwards of two hundred pounds. Another pond, the Machodari, was drained by Prinsep himself. M. A. Sherring thought it good for the city’s health, and no loss to the people, with the Ganges only a few steps off. But the Machodari was no longer a place of pilgrimage, and the old temple of Kameshwar beside it was largely deserted once the pond was gone.
Prinsep Measures the City
Every House and Its Owner
In 1828 and 1829 Prinsep set out to count Kashi again. He did it “unofficially.” He made a full register of the houses and their owners, with their names, their families and their trades, in the city itself, in the European station of Secrole and in the villages close by. He found 30,205 houses. But the people living in them came to about 180,000, some six to a house: not 600,000. To test his work, he went back to seventeen wards after more than a year and counted them again. The second count came out close to the first, and most of the difference came from lodgers who had moved. He counted a thousand Hindu temples in the city, and 333 mosques. The Muslims were about a fifth of the people: a large share, he remarked, for a Hindu town. But many of the populous wards in the suburbs were peopled almost wholly by Muslim weavers.
Prinsep Measures the City
The Staple Article of Commerce
At an eclipse of the sun or moon, or a lucky meeting of the planets, “incredible multitudes” poured into Kashi from every side to bathe at the ghats. Once more than 50,000 people were actually counted coming in along the roads, and the crowd from outside was often more than twice that. A full pilgrimage took longer. The round of all the thousand temples, with rites, prayers and circlings at each, would take a strong walker no less than a week. Hence the saying about Kashi, Pryag and Gaya: “Kashi hunde, Pryag munde, Gya dunde,” which Prinsep rendered, “At Kashi ‘keep moving,’ walk and pray; At Pryag shave, at Gya pay!” At Kashi the pilgrim walks the round of the shrines. At Pryag, where the Jumna meets the Ganges, he shaves, for every hair thrown into the meeting of the rivers was believed to buy him an age of bliss. At Gaya he pays: to Prinsep the line was aimed at the priests of Gaya, who fleece pilgrims “to the last rupee.” Not less than 20,000 Brahmins at Kashi lived on charity or on endowments. The city had rich merchants too, and a trade in sugar, indigo, opium and embroidered cloth. But religion, in his words, was “the staple article of commerce through which the Holy City flourishes and is enriched.”
Prinsep Measures the City
The Privilege of Paying
Another of Prinsep’s drawings comes with a drier story. At Rajrajeshwari Ghat the flight of steps down to the water had never been finished, probably, he thought, because of a quarrel over the boundary between the man who built it and his neighbour. Both had long been dead. But when the city’s Improvement Committee wanted to run a drain under the ghat, a violent dispute broke out over “which party should have the privilege of paying for it.” Each side hoped that by paying he would prove the ground his own. Prinsep’s drawing of the place shows the Committee’s daroga, its overseer, and his men “settling this knotty point by actual inspection of the premises!” H. R. Nevill tells of drains on a larger scale: nothing had been done for the city’s drainage since 1792 until “Mr. J. T. Prinsep, when collector of Benares about 1823,” began a system of drains of brick and rough stone. They ran down the middle of the paved lanes, from one to six feet wide and up to nine feet deep, joined to the courtyards and the shafts of the houses. Nevill does not say whether this was James Prinsep. To Nevill the system was “unscientific”: “The surprising thing is that such a system did not lead to terrible epidemics.” It fouled the city and the river.
Prinsep Measures the City
The Leaning Minarets
Above the river at Madhoray Ghat stood the two minarets of Aurangzeb’s mosque. Prinsep measured them: only eight and a half feet across at the base, seven and a half at the top, and 147 feet 2 inches high from the floor of the mosque to the pinnacle. The terrace they stood on was about 80 feet above the river at low water. When he drew them, the mosque and minarets were being repaired, “a hazardous undertaking,” for both minarets were found to lean outwards fifteen inches. On the very day the scaffolding came down, one was struck by lightning. It lost only one stone from its upper cornice. He also drew the old temple of Vishveshwar, whose walls now carried the city’s principal mosque. The Muslims had turned it into a mosque without destroying more than half its walls, so that its plan and even its full elevation could still be traced: “Antiquarians will be well pleased.” His plan of it shows the Indian way of laying out a temple by squares. Complete, it must have been “a picturesque groupe of nine spires around a central pyramid.” In the centre the lingam had stood in a reservoir, with a drain beneath to carry off the Ganges water poured over it day and night. One of his sketches had shown a building unfinished; by his second edition it was complete. That drawing “no longer pourtrays Benares as it is, but as it was in the years 1820-25.” Told from James Prinsep, Benares Illustrated (1831), the preface, the introduction and the notes to the plates; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 254, 259-260 and 264; and M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), pp. 24-25, 41-42 and 115. The 1803 census was made for Mr. Deane, the city magistrate, and published by Lord Valentia; the travellers whose sketches Prinsep found wanting are Heber and Lord Valentia, and the writer of the six miles by four is Hamilton; Prinsep printed his own in the Asiatic Researches, vol. XVII. The map, he says, was published in 1824. By the castes he counted about 122,000 Hindus and 31,000 Muslims, to which he added some 26,000 for children and omissions. A census of 1827, he notes, counted 264 Hindu and 500 Muslim dancing girls in the town. The Kameshwar temple is Kamananath in Sherring, and Nevill’s gazetteer has the Machodari drained by “Mr J. Prinsep.” In the recount of seventeen wards the figures stood at 8,814 and 8,932. Sherring, giving the thousand temples and 333 mosques more than thirty years later, thought they left out the countless small shrines in niches and walls. Nevill writes that the Mint at Secrole was begun about 1820, that Mr. Prinsep, arriving just after its foundations were laid, revised the plans, and that it was abolished in 1830; Prinsep notes in 1833 that its buildings now belonged to the Raja. Sherring calls James Prinsep “the great Indian archaeologist,” but says he made no important discoveries in the city, and that his views are “chiefly of a popular cast.”