Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
Sarnath
On Top of the Tower
Some four miles north of Kashi lies Sarnath, the old Deer Park. Here the Buddha “first made known his doctrines to the world.” Of all the buildings raised there afterwards, one great tower still stood above the ground: the Dhamek. “On the 18th January 1835 my scaffolding was completed, and I stood on the top of the great tower.” The words are Alexander Cunningham’s, later a general and the author of the Archaeological Survey’s reports. When he cut the long grass up there, he found two iron spikes, each eight inches long and shaped like the head of a lance. The next day he took down the ruined brick pinnacle on the top and began to sink a shaft down into the tower. On 25 January, ten and a half feet down, he found an inscribed slab. It bore the Buddhist profession of faith: “Of all things proceeding from cause, their causes hath the Tathagata (Buddha) explained.” Cunningham judged the letters to be of the sixth century. To H. R. Nevill they were of the seventh.
Sarnath
Fourteen Months
The shaft went on down. The lower part of the tower is a solid mass of stone. Every stone, “even in the very heart of the mass,” is fixed to its neighbours by iron cramps. Each stone usually had eight, four above and four below, and all had to be cut out before it could be moved. Cunningham sent to Chunar for quarrymen, and the work kept them for several months. At last, 110 feet down from the top, the stone gave way to very large bricks, and 28 feet below those, to plain soil. “Thus ended my opening of the great tower after 14 months’ labour.” There was no relic. When he began, he had not known that many of the most hallowed Buddhist monuments were only memorial towers. He came to take this one for the tower that Xuanzang, the Chinese pilgrim, describes. Ashoka raised it near the spot where the Buddha began to “turn the wheel of the law,” that is, to preach his new doctrine. The villagers’ name for it, Dhamek, was short, he suggested, for Dharmmopadesaka, “Preacher of Dharmma.” The carving round the outside was left unfinished. On some faces the rest of the design is only traced in outline by the chisel. On one side alone are there animals: Brahmani geese seated on lotus flowers, and a frog.
Sarnath
Luri’s Leap
Rather less than half a mile south of the Dhamek stands a second, separate monument: a lofty mound of solid brick, crowned by a small eight-sided brick tower. When Cunningham first lived at Kashi, the mound was always called Chaukandi, a name no one could explain; in Nevill’s reading, the “square” mound. On a later visit Cunningham found that name nearly forgotten. People called the place Luri-ka-kodan, “Luri’s leap”: “Luri was an Ahir, who jumped from the top of the octagonal building some years ago, and was killed.” The little tower marks a visit by Humayun, the Mughal emperor. Over its door is an inscription. “As Humayun, King of the Seven Climes, now residing in paradise, deigned to come and sit here one day, thereby increasing the splendour of the sun, so Akbar, his son and humble servant, resolved to build on this spot a lofty tower reaching to the blue sky.” It is dated 996 AH, 1588. To Cunningham an inscription over one of its doorways recorded that it was built in Humayun’s reign; to E. B. Havell, Humayun built it himself. In 1835 Cunningham dug into this mound as well, sinking a well from the tower’s floor down to the plain earth. Here too there was no relic chamber.
Sarnath
A Floor for a Tent
Cunningham dug at Sarnath for eighteen months in 1835-36, at his own expense. Wherever he saw traces of walls he dug, and found only late dwellings. At last, “after a heavy fall of rain,” he noticed a piece of terraced floor and ordered it cleared, to pitch his tent on. After a few hours’ work the floor ended at the edge of a small square tank, with pairs of pillar bases all round it. In the rubbish inside lay a carved relief in grey sandstone of the Buddha’s death. The tank was the centre of a building with small cells round a veranda. It had been a monastery, perhaps three or four storeys high, for about fifty monks. “In all the cells I found pieces of charred wood, with nails still sticking in some of them, and in the middle cell on the western side I found a small store of unhusked rice only partially burnt.” In a building to the west the plaster still clung to the walls, “with borders of painted flowers, quite fresh and vivid.” Close by, in a small detached room, he found a large collection of statues and reliefs. One Buddha the Teacher was “in perfect condition, and coloured of a warm red hue.” He thought the monks had hidden them there in a time of persecution, before they fled to Nepal.
Sarnath
Into the Barna
Those statues were not safe. More than forty of them, with most of the carved stones Cunningham had collected and left lying on the ground, “were afterwards carted away by the late Mr. Davidson.” They were thrown into the Barna river under the bridge, to stop the water cutting away its bed between the arches. They were not the first stones to go. At the end of the eighteenth century Jonathan Duncan, the Resident at Kashi, had built a bridge over the same river. To Nevill, part of its stone came from “the ruthless spoliation of the ancient Sarnath buildings.” Twelve years after Cunningham, Major Kittoe dug at Sarnath at the government’s cost. He was not only an antiquarian but an architect and builder, and he was building Queen’s College in Kashi at the time. Much of the stone he dug out of Sarnath went into the college. Almost every monument laid bare was soon pulled down for its materials or left to crumble. When Cunningham came back to Sarnath years later, he wrote: “nothing whatever now remains of all my excavations, every stone and every brick having been removed long ago.”
Sarnath
“Sacked and Burnt”
Kittoe left for England in ill health in January 1853, taking all his notes with him to write up his finds. He died early, and no one knew what became of his papers. What Cunningham knew of Kittoe’s finds came mostly from one long letter, dated 19 May 1852. “How do you make out three towers at Sarnath?” Kittoe asked. “I make out four, to say nothing of innumerable smaller affairs down to the size of a walnut, which I have laid bare.” He had found stupas and shrines four and five deep, built one over the other. Round one courtyard stood twelve stone pillar stumps, “split in all directions as if destroyed by fire.” He found burnt stone umbrellas, and the white marble head of a nearly life-size Parvati, partly calcined by fire. Every dig near Sarnath had turned up traces of fire; Cunningham himself had found charred timber and half-burnt grain. Kittoe summed it up in a few words: “all has been sacked and burnt, priests, temples, idols, all together. In some places, bones, iron, timber, idols, &c., are all fused into huge heaps; and this has happened more than once.”
Sarnath
Wheaten Cakes
After Kittoe left, the digging went on under E. Thomas, a judge at Kashi. He and those after him laid bare a whole monastery: 28 rooms round a court fifty feet square, with an old well in one corner. Its end seemed to have come all at once. In a small recess Kittoe had found “the remains of ready-made wheaten cakes.” In one cell lay rice, wheat and other grain, part of it spread out, Thomas wrote, “or, possibly, scattered at the moment of the destructive inroad.” The rooms on the east side were “filled with a strange medley of uncooked food, hastily abandoned on their floors.” There was the pottery of everyday life, and lumps of brass where the cooking pots had melted. Above lay the charred roof timbers, the iron nails still in them. The heat had been so fierce that the clay binding the walls was baked as hard as the bricks. Had the fire been an accident, Thomas argued, so well-peopled a monastery would hardly have been abandoned so hastily. The building, “by whomsoever caused,” was destroyed “by fire applied by the hand of an exterminating adversary.”
Sarnath
Whose Hand
Thomas named no one, and the writers who came after him do not agree. To M. A. Sherring, Buddhism’s “adversary, Brahmanism, became too strong for it, and, eventually, crushed it for ever.” To Nevill, Sarnath was still thriving in the twelfth century, and “probably” fell to “the iconoclastic Moslems under Qutb-ud-din Aibak, who devastated Benares in 1194.” After that, Sarnath was wholly deserted. All its buildings but one great stupa were buried in the heaps of their own debris. In 1868 a large stone figure stood near a stream to the north, sunk in the soil and so broken that it was hard to say what it was. It might once have been the Buddha. It was “now worshipped by the Hindus, who profess to derive great benefit from their homage to it.” Told from Alexander Cunningham, Archaeological Survey of India: Four Reports, vol. I (1871), Report 1861-62, pp. 106-129; H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 345-358; M. A. Sherring, The Sacred City of the Hindus (1868), ch. XVIII, pp. 235-270; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), ch. XI, pp. 144, 147-148; with E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), ch. III, pp. 49-55. Thomas’s and Kittoe’s words are quoted by Cunningham and Sherring. On Sarnath’s end, Havell blames “the fierce Muhammadan invaders”; Greaves says only that it is surmised the place was destroyed at the close of the twelfth century.