Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
The City That Sat in Dharna
Three Hundred Thousand on the Plain
On the plain that surrounds Kashi, “above 300,000 persons, as it is said,” sat down “with folded arms and drooping heads.” They had left their houses and shut their shops. Work on their farms had stopped. They lit no fires and cooked no food; many of them did not even eat. In the story as the English traveller Reginald Heber set it down, it was done before the government had the least idea of the plan. They were sitting dharna against a tax. In 1810 a new regulation brought in a general tax on houses. Kashi already paid a tax for its watchmen, and even that “was at first stoutly resisted.” In Heber’s words, the new tax was imposed “unadvisedly,” and deeply unpopular both for its amount and for being new. The people had an answer. The land tax was the government’s, as it had been the Mughals’, and so were the duties on goods for market. “But that their houses were their own.” And the power that taxed their homes this year “might do the same next year on their children and themselves.” The magistrates backed the people with strong protests of their own. In Calcutta they had no effect.
The City That Sat in Dharna
Sitting Dharna
So “the whole population of Benares and its neighbourhood determined to sit ‘dhurna’ till their grievances were redressed.” To sit dharna, “or mourning,” is to stay without moving, without food and open to the weather, until the person it is aimed at grants what is asked. Hindus believed that whoever died sitting dharna became a tormenting spirit, to haunt and afflict the man who would not give way. It was not rare between private people. A man might sit dharna at a door to make someone pay a debt, or to have his own debt forgiven. It was common not only for dread of what the petitioner’s death would bring. Many held that while a man sat dharna at their door, they themselves must not eat, or do any worldly business. Some people, it was said, even hired Brahmins to sit dharna for them. It could be done by proxy, and a Brahmin’s dharna was “naturally more aweful in its effects than that of a soodra,” a man of the lowest caste. Heber did not know whether, under the old Hindu princes, any large part of the people had ever used it against oppression. But at Kashi it was done “with great resolution, and surprising concert and unanimity.”
The City That Sat in Dharna
The Handbill
It had begun with some of the leading Brahmins. They sent out written handbills to the wards of Kashi nearest the college, and to some of the villages round about. In a few words each handbill gave the causes of what they were about to do, and why it had to be done. Each called on “all lovers of their country and national creed” to join. And each commanded everyone who received it, under many bitter curses, to send it on to his next neighbour. It “flew over the country.” Three days after it went out, the plain was full. The officials at Kashi were at a loss. Very many of the people might die, of their own stubbornness or of the diseases they would catch sitting out there. With the fields idle at the most critical time of the year, famine might follow. The revenue was certain to suffer, with all trade stopped. And despair, and the excitement of so great a show of numbers, might lead to something far stronger than sitting dharna.
The City That Sat in Dharna
Their Own Affair
Yet the officials were not allowed to give in. To Heber it would not have been wise to yield to “such a demand, so urged,” and they behaved “with great prudence and good temper.” Many of the people seemed to expect, and the Brahmins perhaps hoped, that the officials would outrage them further by breaking up the gathering by force. They did no such thing. They reasoned calmly with some of the leaders: the government, they said, could not possibly yield to protests pressed in this way. But when asked, they said plainly that if the people chose to sit dharna, that was their own affair. So long as they harmed only themselves and kept the peace towards others, the government would not meddle with them. All the same, they brought a strong body of European troops from Dinapur and Ghazipur to the cantonment nearby. They did it without seeming to watch the people, or putting it into their heads that they were suspected of violence. That is Heber’s telling. H. R. Nevill tells of something rougher: the house tax brought “fresh riots,” and troops again had to be stationed throughout the city to put down the disorder until the tax was withdrawn.
The City That Sat in Dharna
A Tax on Houses
At last the crowd began to grow very hungry. A thunder-shower fell and left them wet, cold and uncomfortable. Some proposed a change of plan: a deputation of ten thousand should go and put their case to the Governor-General in person. A majority, tired of sitting, carried it eagerly. The next question was how to feed these men on the road. One leading Brahmin proposed a tax on houses. “A string was here struck which made the whole instrument jar.” “A tax on houses! If we are to pay a tax on houses after all, we might as well have remained on good terms with our Government, sitting under our vines and fig-trees, and neither hungry nor rheumatic.” Many seized the excuse to break away, and got up to go home. The rest decided that all should go to the Governor-General, each man at his own cost. But the split had begun, and most stayed away from the muster held three days later. Even so, between ten and twenty thousand gathered with what food they could find, and set out.
The City That Sat in Dharna
Melted Away
The magistrates still left them alone. They reckoned that food would run short and the journey grow wearisome, and they only watched the marchers from a distance with a body of cavalry. They knew that hunger would drive the men to plunder, and that the hilly, jungle road from Kashi towards Burdwan offered little to feed so great a crowd. Within a few days the marchers had melted away to so few that the rest were ashamed to go on. To Heber the magistrates’ whole conduct was “wise and merciful.” The government then repealed the tax. In Nevill’s account the disturbance was so serious that some concessions were made, and in 1811 the measure was given up. So ended, in Heber’s words, “a disturbance which, if it had been harshly or improperly managed, might have put all India in a flame.” Told from Reginald Heber, Narrative of a Journey, vol. I (1828), pp. 325-329, and H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 166-167 and 209. Heber gives no year for the dharna; the years 1810 and 1811 are Nevill’s, who names the law Regulation XV of 1810. In Nevill the house tax came before peace had been restored in the city. The older tax paid the city’s watchmen and was collected by the heads of the wards; in 1803 the magistrate fixed it himself for wards that had failed to provide watchmen, at three annas a month for a stone house, two for brick and six pies for mud. In 1809, Nevill adds, it yielded Rs. 1,264 a month and paid 381 watchmen.