Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Kashi
The Lion Pillar Comes Out of the Ground
Battered Down
At Sarnath, the Deer Park near Kashi, the law of the Buddha was first made known. Shortly before E. B. Havell wrote, the Archaeological Department had begun a systematic dig there. Just west of a ruined shrine, the top of a broken stone shaft was showing a few inches above a concrete pavement. It was a sandstone column. Its upper part, with the capital that crowned it, lay broken against the side of the shrine. “Evidently it had been violently battered down.” The stump still standing is 16 feet 8 inches high. With its capital, the whole column seems to have stood about fifty feet. The lowest seven and a half feet were left rough, to be buried in the earth. The rest is “so highly polished that it resembles granite rather than sandstone.” That the column was set up by the Emperor Ashoka is clear from its style, and from an edict of his cut on the stump.
The Lion Pillar Comes Out of the Ground
The Emperor’s Order
Any monk or nun who causes a split in the Sangha, the Buddhist congregation, is to be made to put on white clothes and live outside the convent. The emperor wanted the order made known to the lay followers as well. The superintendents of the sacred law were to learn it, and make it known in their own circles and beyond. So H. R. Nevill reads it, and so, in fewer words, does Edwin Greaves: an edict enjoining obedience to the order and warning against schism. Havell, writing a few years earlier, found that the main part of the inscription was missing. About three feet below the concrete pavement, the diggers found an older floor round the column, made of slabs cut from an ancient railing. On its east side this floor ends in three steps, rising to the level of the pavement. Nevill thought it might have been sunk on purpose, when the ground round about had risen, “in order to keep the edict open to view.”
The Lion Pillar Comes Out of the Ground
Smooth as Jade
Xuanzang, the Chinese pilgrim, saw a pillar at this place. “A stone column has been set up, some seventy feet high,” he wrote. “The stone is smooth as jade, and shines like a mirror.” Havell took the column the diggers found for that very pillar. Nevill was less sure. This column could not have been more than sixty feet high, and Xuanzang says not a word about its lion capital. Greaves too found that silence the strongest objection. But, he wrote, “the traveller was not an artist but a devotee.” Among the other finds are two colossal carvings: a statue 9½ feet high and a gigantic stone umbrella ten feet across. Nevill calls the statue a Bodhisattva, Greaves a standing Buddha. Their inscriptions say they were set up at Sarnath in the reign of King Kanishka. They are of red Agra sandstone, made in the school of Mathura and brought here. A broken inscription gave up the name of the monastery itself: Dharmachakra-pravarttana, “the turning of the Wheel of the Law.” That is the common name of the Buddha’s first sermon.
The Lion Pillar Comes Out of the Ground
Four Lions
But it is the capital that the writers praise. It is seven feet high and shaped like a bell, in the style of ancient Persepolis. On top, in Nevill’s words, are “four magnificent lions sitting back to back with a wheel between them.” The wheel stands for the law of the Buddha first made known at Sarnath. Beneath them runs a drum carved with a lion, an elephant, a bull and a horse, a wheel between each and the next. Havell thought the four lions probably stood for the four quarters. To Nevill the lions and the animals below them were “wonderfully vigorous and true to nature,” and he went further: “India certainly has produced no other sculpture to equal them.” Greaves describes the capital as four lions’ heads, one looking in each direction. Its surface was wonderfully preserved. The heads were not perfect, but three of the four were, in the main, whole. They were “as sharp and clear as though they had but now come out of the workman’s hands.” Told from H. R. Nevill, Benares: A Gazetteer (1909), pp. 354-362; E. B. Havell, Benares, the Sacred City (1905), ch. III, pp. 45-49; and Edwin Greaves, Kashi the City Illustrious (1909), ch. XI, pp. 151-153. The writers differ, as told above: on the lions (Nevill four lions sitting back to back, Greaves four lions’ heads), on the inscription (Havell found its main part missing; Nevill and Greaves give the edict), and on whether this is the pillar Xuanzang saw. Nevill dates the Kanishka statue to the third year of Kanishka’s reign; Greaves puts that reign in the first century AD.