Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Pataliputra and Patna
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
A Dinner for Plassey
On 23 June 1763 the English at Patna were keeping the anniversary of the battle of Plassey with a dinner in their factory. Then the news came: a force of 3,000 men with six guns was marching on the city. The troops were Mir Qasim’s. He was the Nawab, the ruler the English had quarrelled with endlessly, and his headquarters were at Monghyr, down the river. War seemed certain, and Ellis, the English Agent at Patna, resolved to strike first. To Ghulam Husain Khan, who was at Mir Qasim’s court that year and wrote a history of the time, Ellis’s heart was already “full against the Nawab”. Ladders of bamboo and of wood were made ready. Ellis sent for Dr Fullarton, a doctor who lived in the middle of the city. He had treated most of the great men of the Nawab’s court, and Mir Qasim counted him a friend. He knew nothing of the plan, but when he reached the factory he soon saw what was afoot. The governor of Patna, Mir Mehdi Khan, knew nothing either. He was asleep in the citadel, at the far end of the city. The men set to guard the walls were either unarmed and fast asleep upon them, or at their ease in their own homes.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
Over the Wall
The English marched out of their factory at the rising of the morning star. They set their ladders against a tower close by and climbed the city wall in silence. It was a Friday, the 12th of Zilhijja in the year 1176 H. (1763). The few guards who were there wounded some of the English and their sepoys, the native soldiers of their battalions, and fled. Inside, the English went in two bodies, firing as they went, one of them along the main street and through the markets. Mir Mehdi Khan and his officers, roused by the guns and “half asleep”, came out to meet them. One volley with a little grapeshot wounded many of them, and the rest lost heart and fled. Mir Mehdi Khan fled too, on the road to Monghyr. Only two places in Patna held out. A wounded officer shut himself into the Chehel Sitoon, a stone building in the city, with what men he could gather. A Hindu officer of the Nawab shut the gate of the citadel and opened fire. All the rest of the city, from the western gate to the eastern, was in English hands.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
Not So Much as a Straw
In the account of Arthur Broome, historian of the Bengal Army, Ellis and his gentlemen, with Captain Carstairs, who commanded the troops, then went back to the factory for breakfast. Their troops broke into the town and plundered it “without scruple”. Ghulam Husain tells it from the side of the townspeople. The sepoys spread through Patna with the rabble that followed them, homeless men who lived by begging and cutting grass for the cavalry. They plundered the citizens’ houses at their leisure, in some of them “without leaving so much as a bit of straw.” It was a treatment “the more strange, as it had never been experienced from any English army.” Mir Mehdi Khan, fleeing, had got as far as Fatwa when he met troops on their way from Monghyr to strengthen his garrison. They belonged to Markar, an Armenian general of the Nawab. Hearing that the citadel and the Chehel Sitoon still held out, they turned back with the governor along the river, and in a couple of hours they stood before the eastern gate of Patna.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
Rockets at the Eastern Gate
The English there were not dismayed. They opened the gate, set two guns on the bridge over the moat and drew up in line. The commander of Mir Qasim’s rocket-men attacked with rockets and musket fire and broke the line. The English thrust an iron needle into the touch-hole of each gun and scattered “for their lives.” Those still on the towers and ramparts lost their nerve too and fled. In one day Mir Qasim’s men had won back the walls and towers of Patna. The English shut themselves in their factory. Markar came up with six regiments of trained sepoys and eight field guns, and pressed the attack hard. He mounted guns on the city ramparts and kept up a steady cannonade, and his musketry was so heavy that no one inside could show himself at a window. After four days, with food running short, the English crossed the river by boat on the night of 29 June. They were making for the lands of the Nawab of Oudh, who was on good terms with the Company. To Ghulam Husain, Ellis “had now lost all courage.”
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
Surrender at Manjhi
The rains had set in with great violence, and the whole country was under water. Short of food and ammunition, the English were harried by the enemy behind them, and the people of the country rose against them on every side. The commander of the Saran district attacked them, and Somru, a European in Mir Qasim’s service, crossed the river with a strong force to cut them off. At Manjhi, on 1 July, they were surrounded. One battalion fired off all its ammunition, charged with the bayonet and drove the enemy back. But the Europeans, worn out with fatigue and hunger, refused to charge, and the sepoys, seeing that, and seeing the enemy reinforced, lost heart. Carstairs fell, with seven or eight other officers, 50 Europeans and a number of sepoys. Then the whole force laid down its arms, though it still had three battalions and, in Ghulam Husain’s words, “might have done many things.” Many of the sepoys took service with Mir Qasim, and so did many of the foreign soldiers among the Europeans; the rest of the sepoys were stripped and let go. The officers, the gentlemen of the factory and all the English soldiers were carried back to Patna as prisoners, and more prisoners from Monghyr joined them there. Some were shut in the house of one Haji Ahmad, the rest in the Chehel Sitoon.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
The Order
Mir Qasim’s armies were beaten by the English in three battles. He left Monghyr for Barh, and there he butchered the two Seths, the great bankers of Murshidabad. Not content with their deaths, he had their bodies left out under guard for beasts and birds of prey, so that they could not be burned with the rites of their religion. Then he came to Patna. There he heard that the fort of Monghyr had been given up to the English: by treason, in Ghulam Husain’s telling. At that his temper, soured by misfortunes and betrayals, “broke all bounds”. He ordered all the English prisoners to be put to death. None of his officers would carry out the order until Somru offered to do it. Ghulam Husain calls him a man “of a flint-like heart”, who took the task without horror and without reluctance, with no regard for the Christian faith he shared with the prisoners. Two or three days before, the prisoners had tried, through their servants, to get hold of a musket for each man, with powder and shot. With them they meant to break out by force, or else kill enough men to “avenge their death, and do honour to their memory.” The muskets never reached them.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
Haji Ahmad’s House
On the evening of 5 October Somru came to Haji Ahmad’s house with two companies of sepoys. The day before, he had taken away all the prisoners’ knives and forks, pretending that he would give them a dinner. Fullarton, in the letter he wrote afterwards, tells what followed. Somru surrounded the house, went into a small outer courtyard, and sent for Ellis and two others. Six more gentlemen came out with them. They “were all terribly mangled and cut to pieces, and their bodies thrown into a well in the square, and it filled up.” Then the sepoys went into the large courtyard, where the rest were. They fired on them, rushed on them and cut them to pieces “in the most inhuman manner”, and threw them into another large well, until it too was filled. In Broome’s account the sepoys climbed onto the roof and fired down on the prisoners crowded below; those the volley missed ran into the rooms, and the sepoys followed them in. The prisoners fought back with what they had, bottles, bricks, stones and furniture, to the last man. One of them, Lushington, though wounded, ran at the man who had shot him, wrenched the sabre out of his hands and cut him down. In L. S. S. O’Malley’s account the prisoners drove the sepoys out, and the sepoys came back with muskets and shot them down to the last man. Ghulam Husain too has them killed with musket balls; Fullarton has them fired on and then cut to pieces.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
Work for Sweepers
Some of the sepoys were struck by the prisoners’ courage. Give the English arms, they said, and they would fight them to the death; but butchering unarmed men was work not for soldiers but for sweepers. Somru, enraged, struck down those who objected and forced the rest to go on. In 1766 the translator of Ghulam Husain’s history saw, at Benares and at Murshidabad, three or four of Mir Qasim’s commanders who had refused the order with indignation. One, an elderly, stout man with a large pair of whiskers, said: “I only desired the Nawab to give them swords and bucklers, and that I would fight them then: but as to killing prisoners disarmed, that I will never do.” The translator took his last words to point to the custom in India that scavengers, and no one else, acted as executioners. O’Malley gives a commander’s answer in the same spirit: Mir Qasim might send his sweepers to do such work. The next morning, when the bodies were being thrown into the well, the men found Gulston, a young man of the civil service, still breathing. They talked of saving him. But he abused them and threatened them with his countrymen’s revenge. They took him by the legs and threw him, still alive, into the well with the others. Neither age nor sex was spared. Somru murdered Ellis’s infant child, and Broome thought Mrs Ellis was probably among the women who died.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
The Chehel Sitoon
The prisoners in the Chehel Sitoon waited nearly a week for the same end. Fullarton begged two men of the court to plead for them, and he was there when one of them did. Mir Qasim gave no answer, and sent orders to Somru to cut them off. On 11 October they were killed. Fullarton says there were seven of them; O’Malley, who says there are no precise particulars, writes that it appears they were shot down sixty at a time. How many died in all, the records do not agree: 49 Europeans in Haji Ahmad’s house alone, says O’Malley; more than 50 officers and 100 European soldiers, says Broome; 198, says Ghulam Husain’s history, as O’Malley quotes it. Of all the prisoners, only Fullarton was spared. Four serjeants escaped as well. They had been held at Purnea, and were being sent to Mir Qasim by boat to die with the rest, when they overpowered the crew and carried the boat down to the English army.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
“Fraud with Friends!”
On the morning after the massacre, Ghulam Husain went to court, still knowing nothing of it. After an hour he rose to take his leave. “Stay,” said the Nawab, “a friend is coming.” Who? Ghulam Husain asked. “Well, you may go,” Mir Qasim answered, “I shall send for you again.” He went back to his tents and sat waiting, fully dressed. A mace-bearer came for him, and he had hardly sat down before the Nawab when Fullarton came in, in Hindustani dress. The doctor offered a few rupees, as the custom was. Mir Qasim would not take them. “There was no such custom between you and me hitherto,” he said, embraced him, and told him to sit by his friend. Then he looked at him steadily. “Fraud with friends! and treason with acquaintances!” Fullarton, he said, had taken armed men into his house in the town as if they were sick, and let them out on the night they surprised the city walls. Fullarton answered without the least fear. “My Lord Nawab, I do not fear death: you have killed all those countrymen of mine: kill me likewise: you may: you are the master: but never will I admit that I am guilty of treason.” Sitting opposite was a nobleman whose house in Patna was parted from his own by a single wall. “That nobleman is my neighbour: ask him.” To Ghulam Husain, the charge had no ground, and the nobleman said so.
1763: Mir Qasim and the Patna Massacre
A Column Without a Name
Mir Qasim let Fullarton go about the city with attendants, and live in the Dutch factory. As the English army came near, the Nawab left Patna in great confusion. Fullarton paid his attendants and the guard by the river, crossed in a small boat to the English boats opposite the city, and at eleven o’clock that night reached the army of Major Adams. Adams laid siege to Patna, and on 6 November 1763 the citadel was taken by storm. Mir Qasim fled to the Nawab of Oudh. The next year he came back with him to besiege the city, and was beaten off. On 23 October 1764 the battle of Buxar made the British, in O’Malley’s words, “undisputed masters of the Lower Provinces of Bengal.” Haji Ahmad’s house became the burying-ground of the English, and took its name from them. A plain column was raised to the dead. When Broome wrote, in 1850, it still stood, but it bore no inscription. Told from Ghulam Husain Khan, Seir Mutaqherin, translated by Nota Manus, vol. II (1789), pp. 242-247, 283-287, with the translator’s note on p. 284; Arthur Broome, History of the Rise and Progress of the Bengal Army (1850), pp. 362-365, 390-392, and Appendix T, Dr Fullarton’s letter; and L. S. S. O’Malley, Patna (Bengal District Gazetteers, 1907), pp. 34-36, who gives the Seir’s count. O’Malley dates the attack to 24 June, Broome to the 25th; O’Malley has the English hold the factory a day and a half. In the Seir the rocket commander, Mir Nasir, leads the return; Broome says Markar decided on it, and the Seir’s translator that Markar urged the attack. Broome has Ellis breakfast at the factory, O’Malley at Bankipore; O’Malley dates Fullarton’s escape to 25 October. O’Malley names Somru Reinhardt; Broome calls him French. The translator heard the Seths were drowned at Monghyr.