Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Pataliputra and Patna
Spooner’s Pillared Hall
Three Piles in a Line
At Kumrahar, on the site of old Pataliputra near modern Patna, Dr Spooner’s men were digging in the season of 1912-13. They kept finding fragments of polished stone, more than could all have come from one pillar. There had been some building here. But what was it, and where had it stood? The clue was three piles of stone fragments in one straight line, fifteen feet apart from centre to centre. Trial pits were dug at the same distance in every direction, and found more such piles. On the 7th of February, just one month after the work began, the hall was established. Spooner reported: “We have succeeded in definitely locating a vast pillared hall of Mauryan date (3rd century B.C.).” The dig was new in two ways. For the first time the Government of India had taken up the thorough examination of some of the great city sites of antiquity, Taxila in the Punjab and Pataliputra. And for the first time a private man, Mr Ratan Tata of Bombay, had offered to pay for one of them. Pataliputra was his.
Spooner’s Pillared Hall
The Pillar That Was a Hall
The fragments were not new. In 1896 L. A. Waddell had noticed villagers digging large old bricks out of a field at Kumrahar, and had a trench cut there. On 1 July his surveyor, Ahmad Hossain, found twelve feet down a large piece of a colossal pillar of Ashoka, about seven feet seven inches round. Two more pieces came up, with about a cart load of sharply shivered chips. None bore an inscription, and the base was not found. Waddell took the spot for the place of a pillar of Ashoka that Xuanzang, the Chinese pilgrim, called the “Nili” column. How had it been shattered? The main crack ran straight down the larger pieces, so he thought of lightning; or of Sasanka, in his words “the fanatical Brahmanist king of Western Bengal”, who, in the pilgrim’s telling, had overrun Pataliputra about twenty years before his visit and destroyed what Buddhist monuments he could. Yet Xuanzang’s words suggest that the pillars were still standing in his day. Where Waddell had looked for one pillar, Spooner found a hall.
Spooner’s Pillared Hall
Eighty Columns
By the time of the report they had found 8 rows of 10 columns, all fifteen feet apart, and the hall was probably larger still. Even so, it was plainly a hall “of exceptional magnitude and magnificence.” The columns were polished monoliths of Chunar sandstone, about three and a half feet thick at the base and not less than twenty feet high. They had no pedestals and no sockets. They stood free on the wooden floor of the hall, or on square platforms of logs laid for them. On the columns, with no stone capitals between, lay a roof of heavy sal logs, held by thick bars of metal, presumably copper, sunk nearly a foot into the tops of the columns. The wooden floor lay about seventeen feet below the ground of Spooner’s day. In Spooner’s eyes its plan was strikingly like the famous hall of a hundred columns at Persepolis, in Persia.
Spooner’s Pillared Hall
Logs Twenty Feet Down
Just south of the last row of columns lay something stranger: a row of long wooden platforms, seven so far, each 30 feet long and 6 feet wide, made of 30-foot sal logs “in wonderful preservation.” No one knew what they had been for. Spooner thought the most likely guess was that they were foundations, each for one or two specially heavy columns. Or they might have been pre-Asokan altars. Most visitors liked to think they were landing stages for pleasure barges in some Venetian garden of the Maurya palace, a theory which to his mind had nothing to recommend it but its appeal to the great majority of visitors. Whatever they were, “these massive platforms as they lie there, 20 feet and more below the modern surface, are remarkable and impressive monuments.” They seemed “invested with a singular solemnity”. Nowhere else on the site could a visitor get a truer idea of how vast the old building had been.
Spooner’s Pillared Hall
Flood and Fire
The hall stood in use for some centuries. A large Bodhisattva statue from Mathura, which Spooner dated to about the start of the Christian era or a little later, shows that much. Then, perhaps in the early Gupta age, a flood came over it, and left eight or nine feet of silt on the floor. When about three feet had settled, at least one column, its footing weakened, toppled over and came to rest leaning on the silt. The rest stood and held up what was left of the roof. Perhaps the hall was used again after the flood, the top of the silt serving as its floor. Its end came in a great fire, about the 5th century. The fire consumed almost all the woodwork and left a thick layer of ash over the whole floor. Its heat made the metal bolts in the tops of the columns swell, and since they were sunk deep in the stone, they split the columns into countless fragments, which dropped close to where they had stood. Only the upper halves were exposed to the fire; the lower eight or nine feet were buried in silt and stayed upright and whole. Afterwards the place must have been a field of ashes, with heaps of ash and broken stone every fifteen feet. Waddell had thought of lightning or Sasanka; Spooner put the shattered columns down to the fire.
Spooner’s Pillared Hall
The Sinking Columns
Some of the stumps, at least, must have stood up out of the ash, and the next comers wanted the ground. They broke them off and levelled the site, broke some of the pieces into chips to lay a rough pavement, and covered the rest with brick buildings. All this happened in Gupta times, very soon after the fire, in the 5th or 6th century. Later, the wooden floor under the columns rotted, and the water below the ground rose. With nothing to hold them, the columns began to sink, slowly at first, until their tops passed below the old floor. Each left a round hole in the dry silt, and into each hole fell what lay above it: the ash, the broken stone, and any Gupta wall that happened to cross it. So the Gupta buildings were ruined in their turn, and the site was given up, “until modern Muhammadan times at any rate.” Told from the Archaeological Survey of India, Annual Report 1912-13, part I (1915), its opening review and pp. 24-27, Dr Spooner’s report; and L. A. Waddell, Report on the Excavations at Pataliputra (1903), pp. 30-31, 33-34. Waddell’s report dates the first pillar find to 1 July 1896 here, and to June 1896 in an earlier chapter.