Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Pataliputra and Patna
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
A City on a City
On 20 August 1824 Reginald Heber came up the river to Patna. From the water it was “a very great, and … a very striking city,” full of large buildings, “with remains of old walls and towers, and bastions projecting into the river.” The buildings ran along the bank for about four miles, then thinned into cottages and bungalows among trees, until, three miles further on, came Bankipore, with the Company’s opium warehouses and courts. Beneath Patna and Bankipore lies Pataliputra. Founded in the fifth century BC, it became the great capital of India under Chandragupta, and in the third century BC his grandson, the Emperor Ashoka, filled it with palaces, monasteries and monuments. A sign of it came up in the cold season of 1876, when workmen digging a public tank in Patna struck, 12 or 15 feet below the swampy ground, a long brick wall and beside it a line of leaning timber palisades. One well they cleared out still gave good drinking water; in its rubbish lay iron spear-heads. J. W. McCrindle took this for what must have been the wooden wall described by Megasthenes, on whose journals the Greek accounts of the city are based.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
The Lost Capital
Yet in 1892 L. A. Waddell could still write that no one had proved where the city lay. Mr Beglar and most other scholars of the region believed the Ganga had swept it all away centuries before. Sir A. Cunningham had placed Ashoka’s palaces and monuments on one narrow mound near Patna, Chhoti Pahari, scarcely 200 yards by 80, where his “numerous excavations” had yielded nothing but broken bricks. The two Chinese pilgrims had known it. Faxian spent three years there, learning to read and speak Sanskrit. Xuanzang, about AD 635, found a mass of crumbling ruins, “long deserted”: monasteries, temples and stupas in ruins by the hundred, “only two or three remaining.” When Sher Shah came, in 1541, it seems to have been an unimportant village, until Sher Shah ordered a fort built on the old site, and Patna grew into a great town. Visiting Patna, Waddell explored it, taking Xuanzang’s account as his guide. He was surprised to find the site practically untouched by the river, and in a single day he had found most of the pilgrim’s landmarks.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
The Hill of the Mendicant Monk
Xuanzang had written of two hills for monks in Ashoka’s capital: one built for Prince Mahendra, Ashoka’s brother, and one for Upagupta, the saint who converted Ashoka. Near Patna, Waddell heard of a Bhikhna Pahari, “the Hill of the Mendicant Monk.” He went there at once. It was an artificial hill of brick debris, over 40 feet high and about a mile round, now crowned by the house of the Nawab Sahib of Patna. Several largish stones lay strewn about. And at its north-eastern foot stood the shrine of the Bhikhna Kunwar, “the Mendicant Prince.” What was worshipped there under that name was the image of a hill with many peaks: a path climbed from its foot along a ledge and up a steep valley to a winding recess where a cave had been. It had never had a wall round it or a roof over it. Waddell was sure this was a model in miniature of the hermitage hill Ashoka built for Mahendra, “who afterwards became the Buddhist Apostle of Ceylon.” The prince’s hermitage was still worshipped under his name, and the ward of Patna beside the hill was called Mahendru. Writing again in 1903, Waddell gives the hill as smaller, about twenty feet high and a quarter of a mile round, with the image standing on its top.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
Flowers, Milk and Silk Thread
The image was worshipped by the Dosadhs, Ahirs and Goalas of the country with flowers, fruit, milk, sweets and silken thread. The Dosadhs added their wine and now and then a pig; but these went on the outer side of the little hill, while the milk, rice, sweets, flowers and fruit were laid in the recess halfway up, where the cave had been. Hindus of the higher castes paid the Dosadhs to make offerings for them. It was about four and a half feet high and made of clay. Standing in the open, it was partly washed away in every rainy season and mended after it, always in the same shape, handed down in the priest’s family. The priest could not say why it had that shape. Neither he nor the worshippers knew “that the object which they worship is a hill!” The hereditary priest told its story. From time immemorial the image had stood on top of the mound, and had given the hill its name. Then, about 1780, the present Nawab’s ancestor began to build his house on the hill, close to it. The building fell down several times and could not be finished, until the noble begged the priest’s great-grandfather to move the image, and gave him money. It was moved to the place where it stood in Waddell’s day.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
A Name in the Jain Temple
With Mahendra’s hill fixed, the rest followed. Waddell made straight for the great mound south of Patna called Panch Pahari, “the five hills.” The most southerly of all the old city’s monuments had been Ashoka’s five great stupas, described in the seventh century as “like little hills”; by their position, form and traditions he was sure these were they. Between the two ends, about two miles apart, lay mound after mound, with carved slabs of Ashoka’s age lying under trees, at wells, or plastered into walls. The city had not been washed away. At the hamlet of Nayatola, by the roadside, he saw a fine carved pillar of polished sandstone, two divine mothers cut on it in very old style. Cattle used it as a rubbing post. It had come from Kumrahar, a village standing on a vast mound of brick debris about a quarter of a mile square. When the villagers dug wells there, carved stones turned up 8 to 15 feet down. This, they said, had been the palace of the early kings of the country, the home of Bikramadyit, Balal Sen and Nanda Lal. And as positive proof, in the Jain temple he found an inscription that gave the name of the place as “Padali-pura.” It seemed to him the first time the old name had been found at or near Patna.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
Beams in the Wells
Next day he found the wooden walls that Megasthenes had described, still in place. When villagers dug wells in certain spots, they struck great upright beams of sal wood, of immense girth and in excellent condition, 15 to 20 feet down. Unable to explain the huge posts so far below ground, they usually gave up the well and filled it in. He traced three such places. In Ram Charan Koiri’s field, by the railway, a well had been abandoned about a year before with the beam still in it. In Meghu Koiri’s field the well had been left open, and in April 1892 the beam could be seen from above, about 18 feet down, a little out of the upright. And beside the Maharaj Khanda, “the Emperor’s Moat”, some 25 or 30 beams had been laid bare when a tank was dug about 25 years before, and stood visible for a long time. He took them for one of Megasthenes’ towers. In the low fields, where the old moats had run, wells constantly turned up old boats and planks. The people living in the small wards beside the old wooden walls were almost all Dhanuks, “Bow-men”: probably, he thought, the descendants of the soldiers who had once kept watch on those walls.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
A City Built of a City
Where had Ashoka’s great stones gone? Whenever one came to the surface it was carried off and used. They had gone into the Stone Mosque and other mosques, and served as washermen’s slabs at the ghats and tanks, as weights on the levers that raised well water, and broken up, as weights for grain merchants. They were roughly carved into Goraiya “stools”, which people there worshipped, set up as sati pillars, and broken for road metal. Wherever Waddell went he saw fragments of old carved stone in such use, or lying in heaps by the road. The bricks had gone the same way: “A great part of Patna is built of Pataliputra bricks,” and much of the old city must have been poured into the fortifications of Sher Shah and Akbar. He reported his two days’ work at once to the Government of Bengal, which printed his notes. Scholars in Europe were stirred, and the Government granted money to dig.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
“Have Found Stone Carvings”
The first digging, in 1894, while Waddell was away on sick leave, was in his view misdirected, though it confirmed his five stupas. In 1895 he was asked to direct the work, and since he could not be there himself, C. A. Mills of the Public Works Department, then stationed at Patna, took charge on the ground. In May 1896 trenches were opened where Waddell had pointed, and within days so much came up that he was called by telegram. “Have found stone carvings, beams, one coin supposed to be Chinese, images, foundation of buildings, moulded bricks, stone pebbles, etc.,” Mills wired on 22 May. “Please come by Saturday’s mail if possible.” Twelve feet down in the Bulandi mango grove lay a colossal capital of a distinctly Greek type, at a spot Waddell had marked with nothing to guide him but a large flat stone. Of that stone the story went that it could not be taken away, but always came back to its place. To Waddell the capital was “the most Grecian sculpture yet found in India” outside Ashoka’s pillars and the sculptures of the Panjab. In June, Mills and his surveyor, Ahmed Hossain, found about ten feet down the broken pieces of a gigantic polished pillar of Ashoka. Nearly half of it came up, but no trace of its inscription. Then the rains came, and a famine elsewhere in the province called Mills away. In 1897 a subordinate was sent in his place, who followed Waddell’s instructions only in part, and little more was learned.
Waddell Finds Ashoka’s City under Patna
Ashoka’s Plot
In March 1899 Waddell was allowed a few days at Patna to review the whole question. He went over the ground several times: several square miles, thickly built over, cut by winding stretches of water, old channels of the Son, and screened by groves of trees. By his own account the review confirmed his first findings in most particulars, and added much, above all on the limits of the palace. By 1907, as L. S. S. O’Malley summed them up, Waddell’s researches had shown the city on a long strip of high land about eight miles from end to end, with the Ganga to the north and deep moats on its other sides. Ashoka’s palace with its grounds had covered more than four square miles, from Chhoti Pahari to Kumrahar, and a great part of it lay buried beneath that village. To the east of it was a place called the Emperor’s moats. And the land to the west, in O’Malley’s words, “is still called Asoohak or Asoka’s plot.” Told from Reginald Heber, Narrative of a Journey through the Upper Provinces of India, vol. I (1828), pp. 236-238; J. W. McCrindle, Ancient India as Described by Megasthenes and Arrian (1877), pp. 206-208; L. A. Waddell, Discovery of the Exact Site of Asoka’s Classic Capital of Pataliputra (1892), pp. 1-3, 7-11, 19-21, and Report on the Excavations at Pataliputra (1903), pp. 13-19; and L. S. S. O’Malley, Patna (Bengal District Gazetteers, 1907), pp. 204-206. In 1892 Waddell has the beams 10 to 15 feet down, in 1903 15 to 20. McCrindle had reported beams under Mangle’s Talao in the city, but Beglar found no trace of them.