Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Prayag
The Pillar That Fell and Rose Again
Alexander’s Pillar?
Between 1608 and 1611 the traveller William Finch wrote of “Alabasse”, a town and castle on the far side of the Ganga, “called anciently Praye”. It was held one of the wonders of the East. Many Pathan kings had tried to build a castle there, and none could do it until Akbar laid the foundation. It stood on the point where the Yamuna falls into the Ganga. It had been forty years in building and was not finished yet; by report, twenty thousand people had worked on it for many years. Inside its high red walls, through two fine gates, lay a fine court. In it stood a pillar of stone, fifty cubits above the ground, and set so deep in the earth that no end of it could be found. From what the people told him, it seemed to have been set up by Alexander, or some other great conqueror who could go no further because of the Ganga. It was not Alexander’s. By the time Alexander Cunningham surveyed the place in 1862-63, the old city of Prayag had totally disappeared, and its one Hindu monument left was this pillar. It carried the words of three rulers: King Ashoka, Samudragupta and the Mughal emperor Jahangir. Each of them, in turn, had raised it up.
The Pillar That Fell and Rose Again
Ashoka’s Pillar
Ashoka set the pillar up in the third century before Christ, to carry his edicts on spreading the Buddha’s teaching. It is a single round shaft of polished sandstone, thirty-five feet long. Its capital is lost; H. R. Nevill thought it was probably crowned with a lion or some such figure. On it are six of Ashoka’s edicts, with an opening address to the rulers of Kausambi, an old city on the Yamuna about twenty-eight miles away. So, it has been suggested, it may first have stood at Kausambi. One of the early Muslim kings of Delhi may then have brought it to Prayag, as two other Ashoka pillars were brought to Delhi. Cunningham thought it had probably stood not far from where it stands now. Nevill found that nothing could be discovered of where it first stood. The Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang described Prayag in the seventh century and said nothing of any pillar. Cunningham thought that perhaps it was not standing in the pilgrim’s day. Ashoka’s edicts on this pillar are told in full in The Edicts of Ashoka on this site.
The Pillar That Fell and Rose Again
“An Arm of the Earth”
Some time after Ashoka the pillar was thrown down. Samudragupta of the Gupta kings set it up again. On it was cut a long poem in his praise, composed by his minister Harishena, who calls himself the slave of his lord’s feet. It tells of a king skilful in a hundred battles, whose only ally was his own arm. His body was beautiful with the scars of a hundred wounds from battle-axes, arrows, spears and swords. He captured the kings of the south and set them free again. Nine named kings of Aryavarta, and many others, he violently exterminated, and he made all the kings of the forest countries his servants. Frontier kings paid him every tax, and the people of far lands and islands sent him gifts of maidens. And the poem speaks of the stone itself. “This lofty column” is “as it were an arm of the earth”, proclaiming the fame of Samudragupta, who has gone to the abode of Indra. That fame, like the waters of the Ganga set free from the matted hair of the god Pashupati, purifies the three worlds. Of his poem Harishena says: “let it be for the welfare and happiness of all existing beings!”
The Pillar That Fell and Rose Again
Names Cut Sideways
How do we know when the pillar lay on the ground? From the names that visitors cut on it. James Prinsep noticed that some names in an old script ran up and down, at right angles to the rest. No one could have cut them like that while the pillar stood. They would have been out of reach, and an ambitious visitor does not put his name where no one can read it. So the pillar had been thrown down some time after Ashoka. So the stone told its own history. After Samudragupta it probably stood until, in Prinsep’s words, it was overthrown again by “the idol-breaking zeal of the Musulmans”. On one side, the side that faced the sky while it lay flat, are names with dates from 1363 to about 1660. One of the names is Raja Birbal’s, who came to Allahabad in 1575 for the Magh Mela, the fair of the month of Magh. The pillar must have been lying on the ground then. All that cutting did harm. The upper part of Samudragupta’s poem was badly damaged by medieval writing cut over and between its lines, and by the peeling of the stone. A large crack runs down through it too.
The Pillar That Fell and Rose Again
The Emperor and the Engineer
Then the third ruler raised it. The Mughal emperor Jahangir set the pillar up again, to mark his accession to the throne in 1605. He placed it in the middle of the fort, with his own inscription on it. It stood there until 1798. That year General Kyd, who was strengthening the fort of Allahabad, pulled it down, because it stood in the way of his new rampart near the gateway. Prinsep had named him General Garstin; Cunningham believed that was a mistake, and called Kyd “the Vandal Engineer”. His name is still kept in Kydganj, a suburb on the Yamuna just below the city. Even with the pillar on the ground, visitors went on cutting their names, from “the passion for recording visits of piety or curiosity”, as Prinsep put it. A few roughly cut names in Nagari letters, with Samvat dates of 1800 and more, showed it.
The Pillar That Fell and Rose Again
A Stuffed Poodle
In 1838 Captain Edward Smith of the Engineers set the pillar up once more, and designed a new capital for it. At first a fancy flower was to have topped it. But the people had a tradition that a lion once stood on top of the column. So a committee of the Asiatic Society asked that the new capital be made as like the old as possible, after the old pillars at Bakra and Lauriya. Cunningham had seen the lions on those two pillars and admired them: real lions, half crouching, heads raised and mouths open, on capitals that swelled out boldly to hold them. To him, Smith’s capital was “a signal failure”. It narrowed towards the top, under a slab narrower than the pillar itself, and the animal on it was small and lying down. “Indeed, it looks to me not unlike a stuffed poodle stuck on the top of an inverted flower pot.” Told from William Foster, ed., Early Travels in India 1583-1619 (1921), pp. 177-178 (William Finch, 1608-11); Alexander Cunningham, Four Reports Made during the Years 1862-63-64-65 (Archaeological Survey of India I, 1871), pp. 298-300, quoting James Prinsep (1837); J. F. Fleet, Inscriptions of the Early Gupta Kings (Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum III, 1888), pp. 2, 10-17; and H. R. Nevill, Allahabad: A Gazetteer (1911), chapter V, including p. 166. Cunningham dates Ashoka’s pillar about 240 BC and its last raising 1838; Nevill has 232 BC and 1833. Nevill gives Birbal’s visit as 1575 and, elsewhere, 1576; he thinks the pillar stood perhaps till Ala-ud-din Khilji, and briefly again under Firoz.