Stories of India's Ancient Cities · Rajgir
The First Council at Rajagriha
A Flower on the Road
After the Buddha’s death, the first council of his monks met at Rajagriha, to chant his teaching together. It began with a flower on a road. The venerable Maha Kassapa, who would preside over that council, told the monks how it had happened. He had been travelling the road from Pava to Kusinara with a great company of about five hundred monks. He had left the high road and sat down at the foot of a tree. Along the road from Kusinara came a naked ascetic, carrying a Mandarava flower he had picked up there, a flower of the gods. Kassapa asked him whether he knew their Master, the Buddha. “Yea, friend, I know him,” said the ascetic, who called him the Samana Gotama. “This day the Samana Gotama has been dead a week. That is how I obtained this Mandarava flower.” Some of the monks were not yet free from their passions. They stretched out their arms and wept, some fell headlong on the ground, and some reeled to and fro in anguish. “Too soon has the Blessed One died! Too soon has the Light gone out in the world!” But the Arahats, the monks who were free from the passions, bore their grief calmly: all things that are put together must pass away.
The First Council at Rajagriha
“We Are Well Rid of Him”
“Enough, Sirs!” said Kassapa. “Weep not, neither lament!” Had the Buddha not told them that they must part from all things near and dear? Then an old monk spoke, Subhadda, who had left the world only in his old age. “Enough, Sirs! Weep not, neither lament! We are well rid of the great Samana. We used to be annoyed by being told, ‘This beseems you, this beseems you not.’ But now we shall be able to do whatever we like; and what we do not like, that we shall not have to do.” Then Kassapa spoke to the monks. Let them chant together the Buddha’s teaching, the Dhamma, and his rules of discipline, the Vinaya, he said. They must do it before what was not Dhamma spread abroad and what was Dhamma was put aside, and before those who argued against it grew strong. He remembered the evil words of the aged Subhadda. He remembered, too, that the Master had given him his garment, and so made him equal with himself, and that the Sage had commanded that the holy truth be established.
The First Council at Rajagriha
“Alms Are Plentiful”
Kassapa chose Arahats for the council, one short of five hundred. The last place was kept for Ananda. The monks begged Kassapa to choose him. Ananda had not yet reached the goal of an Arahat, they said. But he could not be led into error by partiality, malice, stupidity or fear, and he had learned the Dhamma and the Vinaya from the Buddha himself. So Kassapa chose Ananda. Where should they meet? The monks thought of Rajagriha. There alms were plentiful, and there were lodging-places in abundance. They would spend the rainy season there and chant together, and no other monks were to go up to Rajagriha for that season. Kassapa put it to the order, and the order agreed in silence. After the funeral rites the five hundred went about the land consoling the sorrowing people. In the month Asalha they came to Rajagriha.
The First Council at Rajagriha
A Hall Like the Gods’
The Buddha had praised the repair of what had fallen into decay. So in the first month of the rains the monks repaired the dwellings and told the king, Ajatashatru. When it was done, they told him they would now hold the council, and needed a place for the meetings. The king asked where, and they showed him. With all speed he had a splendid hall built by the side of the Vebhara Rock, at the entrance of the Sattapanni cave. It was like the assembly-hall of the gods. He had precious mats spread in it, as many as there were monks. On the south side stood a lofty and noble seat for Kassapa. In the middle of the hall was a high seat for the preacher, “worthy of the blessed (Buddha) himself.” Then the king sent word: “My work is finished.” When the Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang came, a large stone house stood in a great bamboo forest, and before it the old foundation-wall of the hall Ajatashatru had made. Faxian, another Chinese pilgrim, found the cave too, with a tope raised on the spot.
The First Council at Rajagriha
Before His Head Touched the Pillow
Ananda had been chosen, but in Xuanzang’s telling Kassapa sent him out. “You are not yet free from defects; you must leave the holy assembly.” Ananda had followed the Buddha as his attendant for many years. “The King of the Law having died,” he said, “I have lost my dependence and helper.” “Do not cherish your sorrow!” said Kassapa. “You were a personal attendant on Buddha indeed, and you therefore heard much, and so you loved (much), and therefore you are not free from all the ties that bind.” The Cullavagga tells what Ananda did. The assembly was to meet the next day, and he would not go into it still only on the way to the goal. He spent the whole night with his mind alert. At the close of the night he meant to lie down, and he bent his body. But before his head reached the pillow, while his feet were already off the ground, he became free from attachment to the world. In Xuanzang’s account Ananda then went to the assembly and knocked at the door. “Have you got rid of all ties?” Kassapa asked. “In that case exercise your spiritual power and enter without the door being opened!” And Ananda entered through the keyhole, bowed to the monks, and sat down. The Mahavamsa has him rise to his seat out of the ground or through the air; in Faxian’s, Ananda was outside the door and could not get in.
The First Council at Rajagriha
Questions in the Hall
The monks met in the splendid hall. Kassapa sat in his lofty seat and asked the questions. On the rules he questioned Upali, who in Xuanzang’s telling clearly understood the rules of discipline and was well known to all; on the teaching he questioned Ananda. Each answered from the preacher’s seat, and all the monks repeated each passage after him. Some of the answers led back to the city itself. A rule against taking what had not been given had been laid down at Rajagriha. One of the Buddha’s teachings had been given at Rajagriha, in Jivaka’s Mango Grove, to King Ajatashatru. Then Ananda told the assembly that, as he was passing away, the Buddha had allowed the order to revoke “all the lesser and minor precepts” if it wished. But Ananda had not asked him which they were, and the monks could not agree. Kassapa warned of what lay people would say: that the Buddha’s rules had lasted only “until the smoke should rise from his funeral pyre.” So the order agreed to make no new rule and revoke no old one, but to keep them all as they had been laid down.
The First Council at Rajagriha
“Out of My Faith in You”
Then the elders called Ananda to account. It was ill done, they said, that he had not asked which were the lesser precepts. He had forgotten to ask, he said. They found four faults more. He had stepped on the Buddha’s rainy-season robe to sew it: he had meant no lack of respect, he said. He had let women salute the Buddha’s body first, so that it was defiled by their tears: he had not wanted them kept beyond their time. The Buddha had given him a clear hint, and he had not begged him to remain on, for the good and happiness of the great multitudes. He had been possessed, he said, at that moment. And he had worked to have women admitted to the order. That he had done, he said, thinking of Maha Pajapati the Gotami, the sister of the Buddha’s mother. She had been the Buddha’s nurse, and when the mother who bore him was dead, she suckled him herself. To each charge Ananda gave the same answer. “I see no fault therein. Nevertheless, out of my faith in you, I confess that as a fault.”
The First Council at Rajagriha
From the Very Mouth
In the Mahavamsa the work was done in seven months, and the earth trembled six times, rejoicing that Maha Kassapa had made the Buddha’s message endure for five hundred years. Xuanzang has it finished when the three months of rain were past. Not everyone had been let in. Xuanzang describes a stupa built by King Asoka to the west, where those shut out of Kassapa’s assembly, a hundred thousand learners and Arahats, met on their own. “Whilst Tathagata was alive we all had a common master,” they said, “but now the King of the Law is dead it is different.” Because common folk and holy men were mixed together in it, it was called the assembly of the great congregation. When the chanting was over, the venerable Purana came to the Veluvana, the bamboo garden at Rajagriha. He had been away wandering through the Southern Hills with five hundred monks. The monks of the council told him to learn the text as they had rehearsed it. It had been well sung, he answered. “Nevertheless, even in such manner as it has been heard by me, and received by me from the very mouth of the Blessed One, in that manner will I bear it in my memory.” Told from The Cullavagga, XI.1.1-11, in Vinaya Texts III, translated by T. W. Rhys Davids and H. Oldenberg (Sacred Books of the East XX, 1885), pp. 370-381; The Mahavamsa, translated by Wilhelm Geiger (1912), chapter III, verses 1-42; Xuanzang’s Si-yu-ki, translated by Samuel Beal, vol. II (1884), book IX, pp. 161-165; and Faxian’s record, translated by James Legge (1886), chapter XXX, p. 85. In Xuanzang, Kassapa learns of the death by divine sight and from a Brahman holding a divine flower, and calls the assembly by sounding the great gong on Mount Sumeru; he has 999 Arhats and Kassapa reciting a third collection, and calls it the Sthavira convocation, after its president. Faxian calls the cave Srataparna and seats Sariputtra and Maudgalyayana beside Kassapa.