Stories of India's Ancient Kingdoms · The Rashtrakutas
The Balhara, One of the Four Great Kings of the World
Four Kings of the World
There are four great kings in the world, the people of India and China agree. First comes the king of the Arabs, the Khalif of Baghdad, the greatest of kings, first in wealth and in the splendour of his court. The king of China reckons himself next. After him comes the king of the Greeks. “And lastly the Balhara, prince of the men who have their ears pierced.” So wrote a merchant named Sulaiman, who set out on the Persian Gulf and made several voyages to India and China. His account bears the Muslim year 237, AD 851. After him, other Arab travellers and geographers wrote of the Balhara too. Sulaiman never gives his name: Balhara, to him, is a title borne by every king of the dynasty, like the Cosroes of the Persians, and “not a proper name”. Who was he? Historians of later centuries read these writers and argued over it. Vincent A. Smith answered plainly: Sulaiman’s Balhara was the Rashtrakuta king Amoghavarsha, who moved his capital to Manyakheta, “the Mankir of the Arab writers”.
The Balhara, One of the Four Great Kings of the World
A Friend of the Arabs
In Sulaiman’s account, the Balhara is the most eminent of the princes of India, and the Indians acknowledge it. Every prince in India is master in his own state, but all pay homage to the Balhara. His envoys are received with the deepest respect, to do him honour. He pays his troops regularly, as the Arabs do. He has many horses and elephants, and immense wealth. His kingdom begins on the sea, at Komkam, the Konkan. The kings of that country live long, often reigning for fifty years. And the people of the Balhara’s country believe that their kings live and reign so long only because of the favour they show to the Arabs. “Among all the kings there is no one to be found who is so partial to the Arabs as the Balhara; and his subjects follow his example.” A later writer, Abu Zaid of Siraf, never went to India himself but questioned those who had. In his telling the princes of India own no single sovereign; each is his own master. “Still the Balhara has the title of ‘king of kings.’”
The Balhara, One of the Four Great Kings of the World
Enemies on Every Side
In the merchant’s account the Balhara is at war with the kings around him, but greatly excels them all. Among them is the king of Jurz. No prince in India has so fine a cavalry. He is unfriendly to the Arabs, and no prince in India is a greater foe of the Muslim faith; yet his land is the safest in India from robbers. Beyond them lies a kingdom called Ruhmi, at war with both. Its king, it is said, rides out to battle followed by some 50,000 elephants, and only in winter, because elephants cannot bear thirst. Al Mas’udi, a later writer, names another enemy: the king of Kannauj, who bears the title Bauura. He is surrounded on all sides by warlike kings, so he keeps four armies, one for each quarter of the wind. The army of the north fights the prince of Multan and the Muslims of the frontier. “The army of the south fights against the Balhara, king of Mankir.”
The Balhara, One of the Four Great Kings of the World
Mankir, the Great Centre of India
Mas’udi’s book describes the nations of east and west as they stood in the Muslim year 332. Its Balhara is still “the greatest of the kings of India in our time”, and the book gives him a city. Mankir, “the great centre of India”, submitted to a king called the Balhara, and the name passed to his successors, who reign there “until the present time”. In Mas’udi’s account, many kings of India turn their faces towards the Balhara in their prayers, and make supplications to his envoys when they come. His troops and elephants are past counting, but his troops are mostly foot soldiers, because his seat is among the mountains. And of all the kings of Sind and India, none pays greater respect to the Muslims. In his kingdom Islam is honoured and protected. Two geographers, Istakhri, writing about 951, and Ibn Haukal after him, say the same. From Kambaya to Saimur, in their account, is the land of the Balhara. It is a land of unbelievers, “but there are Musalmans in its cities, and none but Musalmans rule over them on the part of the Balhara.” There are mosques where they gather to pray. And the Balhara lives at Mankir, a city with a wide territory.
The Balhara, One of the Four Great Kings of the World
Who Was the Balhara?
The Arab writers all spell the title alike, and Abu Zaid and Ibn Khurdadba make it “king of kings”. On the man behind it, the historians who read them did not agree. Elliot and Dowson, who gathered these Arab writers in one book, took the Balhara to be the kings of Ballabhi-pura, the Ballabh Rais, as Colonel Tod had proposed. Mankir is missing from Istakhri’s and Ibn Haukal’s lists of the cities of India, and to them it must have fallen to decay and been known only by tradition. R. G. Bhandarkar read it otherwise: Mankir must be Manyakheta, the Rashtrakuta capital. The Rashtrakutas took the title Vallabha from the Chalukyas before them, and their grants call them Vallabha-narendra, “king Vallabha”. Vallabha-raja, as common speech says it, becomes Ballaha-ray or Balha-ray: “the same as the Balhara of the Arabs.” One writer keeps a detail of the king himself. Ibn Khurdadba held high office under the Khalifs and died in 912. He wrote that the Balhara wears a ring with a sentence cut in it: “What is begun with resolution ends with success.” Told from Elliot and Dowson, The History of India as Told by Its Own Historians, vol. I (1867): Sulaiman, pp. 1-5; Abu Zaid, pp. 7-8; Ibn Khurdadba, pp. 12-13; Al Mas’udi, pp. 18-25; Istakhri, pp. 26-27; Ibn Haukal, pp. 33-34; note A, “Balhara”, pp. 354-358; R. G. Bhandarkar, Early History of the Dekkan, 2nd ed. (1895), p. 77; C. V. Vaidya, History of Mediaeval Hindu India, vol. II (1924), pp. 162-163; and Vincent A. Smith, The Early History of India, 4th ed. (1924), pp. 445-446. Vaidya agrees with Bhandarkar, dates Sulaiman 857, and guesses that Rashtrakuta coins, which Sulaiman says were dated by reigns, had only regnal years. Reinaud read Balhara as Malwa Rai. Ibn Khurdadba and Mas’udi name a king of Juzr, which the translators bracket as Gujarat. Elliot and Dowson call Mas’udi’s eighty parasangs from Mankir to the sea “a palpable exaggeration”.