Stories of India's Ancient Kingdoms · The Satavahanas
Simuka and the Last of the Kanvas
The Earth Will Pass to the Andhras
The Puranas list the dynasties that came before the Satavahanas. The Mauryas, founded by Chandragupta, ruled northern India for 137 years, until their last king was murdered by his general Pushyamitra. Pushyamitra founded the Shunga dynasty, which held power for 112 years. After the Shungas came the Kanva family, for forty-five years. The Puranas tell what followed in the future tense, as a prophecy. A minister, Vasudeva, will forcibly overthrow the dissolute Shunga king Devabhumi and become king. He and three of his line after him, four Kanva brahmans in all, will enjoy the earth for 45 years, holding the neighbouring kings in subjection. The last of them will be Susharman. Then “the earth will pass to the Andhras”. “The Andhra Simuka with his fellow tribesmen, the servants of Susarman, will assail the Kanvayanas and him (Susarman), and destroy the remains of the Sungas’ power and will obtain this earth.” Simuka will be king 23 years. So, in the Puranas, the man who ended the Kanvas was the first king of the Andhra line. Not everyone who read them believed it.
Simuka and the Last of the Kanvas
Two Centuries Apart
Everything hangs on one question: when did the Satavahanas begin? Vincent Smith dated the end of the Kanvas to about 28 or 27 BC. The last of them was slain by a king of the Andhra or Satavahana dynasty. By then that dynasty’s lands stretched across the Deccan from sea to sea. But the dynasty itself, in Smith’s view, was far older. It had risen under a king named Simuka about 240 or 230 BC, very soon after the death of the great emperor Ashoka, or even before. On these dates, the dynasty began some two hundred years before the last Kanva died. So, in Smith’s judgment, the slayer of Susharman “cannot possibly have been Simuka”. He must have been one of three later kings of the line, though no one can say which. Even Pargiter, who edited the Puranas’ text, suggested that the Andhra who overthrew the Kanvas “was not Simuka as these Puranic accounts say”.
Simuka and the Last of the Kanvas
Like the Peshwas
R. G. Bhandarkar read the Puranas another way, and kept Simuka as the conqueror. The Vayu and the Matsya Puranas say something here that they say of no other dynasty. The founder of the Andhras, they say, uprooted not only the Kanvas but “whatever was left of the power of the Sungas.” And the Kanvas are called pointedly “servants of the Sungas”. So Bhandarkar thought that when the Shunga princes grew weak, the Kanvas took all the power and ruled “like the Peshwas in modern times”. They did not uproot their masters’ line, but left them kings in name only. Like the Peshwas, too, they were brahmans. The two dynasties, then, reigned side by side, and the Shungas’ 112 years included the Kanvas’ 45. On this reckoning the founder, Simuka, did end both the Kanvas and the last of the Shungas, and the Satavahanas came to power in 73 BC.
Simuka and the Last of the Kanvas
Simuka at Nanaghat
The Puranas cannot even agree on the founder’s name: one calls him “Sindhuka”, another “Sisuka”, another “Sipraka”. G. Bühler held that all of these are copyists’ misspellings of one strange, un-Sanskrit name, Simuka. That name had been cut in stone. In the inscriptions of a cave at Nanaghat, the first king is Simuka Satavahana. Kings in the Nashik cave records call themselves “of the race of Satavahana”. The cave records give several of the family the title Satakarni, and it appears again and again among the Puranas’ Andhra kings. Bühler concluded that Simuka Satavahana is “in all probability the first king” of the Puranas’ list. Bhandarkar agreed. The king who had the Nanaghat cave made, with statues of himself and the younger princes, might well have had the founder carved there too, “to give dignity to his race”. From the reign of Krishna, the second king, comes a record over the window of a small cave at Nashik. The cave was the work of an officer there: “Under king Krishna of the Satavahana family this cave has been caused to be made”.
Simuka and the Last of the Kanvas
Brother or Son?
The Puranas make Krishna Simuka’s younger brother, and the third king, Satakarni, Krishna’s son. Yet Krishna’s name is missing from the Nanaghat records, which name Satakarni. Bühler did not feel he could trust the Puranas here. Satakarni may have been Simuka’s own son, who came to rule only after the death of his uncle Krishna. “For it is a very common occurrence in Indian history that an uncle assumes the government instead of a nephew who is a minor at his father’s death.” And “a usurper would, of course, not be noticed.” Still, he preferred “to leave the question open”. E. J. Rapson thought Krishna was probably Simuka’s brother, which in Indian custom would fully explain his absence from Nanaghat. He held that, allowing for the copyists’ corruption of the first name, the Puranas give the first three kings, and their order, correctly: Simuka, Krishna, Sri-Satakarni. Told from F. E. Pargiter, The Purana Text of the Dynasties of the Kali Age (1913), p. xxvi note 3 and p. 71; Vincent A. Smith, The Early History of India, 4th ed. (1924), pp. 216-219; R. G. Bhandarkar, Early History of the Dekkan, 2nd ed. (1895), pp. 23-25, 31; G. Bühler on the Nanaghat inscriptions, in James Burgess, Report on the Elura Cave Temples, Archaeological Survey of Western India, vol. V (1883), pp. 69-72; Senart’s edition of the Nasik cave inscriptions, Epigraphia Indica, vol. VIII (1905-06), No. 22; and E. J. Rapson, Catalogue of the Coins of the Andhra Dynasty, the Western Ksatrapas ... (British Museum, 1908), p. xix. Smith names the slayer as king No. 11, 12 or 13; Pargiter as one of Nos. 12 to 14. Senart’s Nasik record was made by “the officer in charge of the Sramanas”; Bühler, in James Burgess’s Report on the Buddhist Cave Temples and their Inscriptions (Archaeological Survey of Western India, vol. IV, 1883), read an officer named Samana. The Puranas count twenty-nine or thirty kings and 411 to 460 years; Bhandarkar accepted thirty and about 456.