Stories of India's Great Monuments · Ajanta
Fire at the Crystal Palace
The Labour of Years
The paintings on the walls of the Ajanta caves had been decaying fast for a long while. To James Burgess, Major Gill was “one of the most faithful of artists”. He copied the paintings full size. Over the years he sent about thirty of his copies home to London, many of them very large. They were “the labour of years”, made in the hope of saving the most interesting parts of the paintings. All but the five he made last went on show in the Indian Court of the Crystal Palace at Sydenham. Those five escaped only because they had stayed in the stores of the India Office. And there, at the Crystal Palace, the copies burned. Burgess puts the fire in the latter part of 1866; Lady Herringham in December 1866. “They all perished there by fire,” she writes.
Fire at the Crystal Palace
No Copy, No Tracing
“Alas for official wisdom and forethought!” Burgess wrote. No copy, no tracing, no photograph had been taken of the paintings before they were sent off to be shown, and burned. Lady Herringham says the same: “No photographs of them had been taken.” In Burgess’s account, all that was left of Gill’s work were some copies in a book, Mrs. Speir’s Ancient India: two of his pictures and eight fragments of others, on a very small scale indeed. Burgess and James Fergusson, writing together, tell it another way. Their chapter says the copies were lent to the Crystal Palace Company, and puts the fire in 1860, though their own preface says 1866. And they say that before the fire “tracings of several of them were made by Mr. Geo. Scharf,” and printed as woodcuts in Mrs. Speir’s book; they give them again.
Fire at the Crystal Palace
What Was Left
Later Burgess came upon two more pictures of the lost work. In the Illustrated London News of 8 September 1849 were two wood engravings, very small, of two of Major Gill’s large copies. Both were from Cave X, the oldest of the paintings, and showed them as they had been more than thirty years before. The one from the left wall showed that “nearly forty years ago” that scene had already become “a mere series of fragments”. The right wall had since become almost black, and had been “scribbled all over by native visitors”. So he printed the two engravings again, to keep what record there was. In the second he knew, almost at the first glance, the famous Chhadanta Jataka. It shows the elephant Chhadanta under his banyan tree, and the hunter carrying its tusks to the queen of Banaras. The five copies that escaped the fire went to South Kensington. In Lady Herringham’s account one, a long ceiling from Cave XVII, is now lost: “it may have been burnt in 1885.” Another, the Great Buddha, is in a sad state. It shows signs of having been stripped in haste from its frame, and its surface is dulled, perhaps by smoke and water.
Fire at the Crystal Palace
Gill Goes Back
In 1868 Major Gill sold his negatives, with two books of plans, sketches and notes, to the Government for £200. His photographs had been taken by the light of a magnesium lamp. Not long after the fire he went back to Ajanta, to report on the state of the caves with a view to making more copies. In a letter of June 1868 he listed several places where the painting had disappeared in the last ten years. And the letter closes somewhat sadly: “Reduced as the paintings now are and in their present condition I should think ordinary tracings of what could be made out and only one or two small pieces finished up, merely to show the style of colouring and the light and shade of the originals, would be all that is needed.” Told from James Burgess, Notes on the Bauddha Rock-Temples of Ajanta (1879), p. 2; James Fergusson and James Burgess, The Cave Temples of India (1880), Preface p. xvi and ch. VIII p. 282; James Burgess and Bhagwanlal Indraji, Inscriptions from the Cave-Temples of Western India (1881), p. 67; and Lady Herringham and her assistants, Ajanta Frescoes (1915), pp. 15-16. The Cave Temples names Mrs. Speir’s book Life in India, and in its chapter has all but three or four sent to the exhibition; Burgess in 1879 calls the book Ancient India. Burgess found four of the surviving copies to be of Cave I. The day of Gill’s letter in June 1868 cannot be read in the old print.