Stories of India's Great Monuments · Ajanta
Robert Gill at Ajanta
At Great Risk
There are twenty-nine caves at Ajanta: five chaityas, or temples, and twenty-four viharas, or monasteries. Twenty-seven of them could be reached. Robert Gill entered the remaining two “at great risk”. Because they were so very hard to get into, he hoped to find the paintings inside them better kept than in the others. They were not what he had hoped. The temple was only a beginning: nothing of it had been finished but the top of the great arch of its window. The monastery was not much further on, only a verandah on six rough-hewn pillars and two pilasters. Gill was a captain in the Madras army when he was engaged to make facsimile copies of all the paintings in the caves. To James Burgess he was “an excellent artist”. The work took years.
Robert Gill at Ajanta
No Time to Copy
James Fergusson had stood before the Ajanta paintings and judged them “certainly superior to the style of Europe during the age in which they were executed.” But he made no copies. “I had not time, even if I had had the ability, to copy these interesting paintings, and I fear any one who now visits them will find that much that I saw has since disappeared.” His paper on the rock-cut temples of India, laid before the Royal Asiatic Society in 1843, “first created a lively interest” in the paintings. Early the next year the Society brought the caves to the notice of the East India Company’s Directors. It was “anxious that carefully executed copies” of the paintings be made “before it was too late.” In May 1844 the Directors wrote back that it “would no doubt be little creditable to an enlightened government to suffer them to perish.” Gill was chosen as “the main result” of that answer; by one account he was appointed in 1845.
Robert Gill at Ajanta
A Feat of Endurance
The Madras Government had him copy the paintings in oils, full size. Lady Herringham, who spent several years copying the paintings on the spot herself, judged them exact copies in everything but the oil. How long the work lasted is told differently: Burgess has “several years, till the mutiny”; Fergusson and Burgess together, “eight or ten years”; Lady Herringham, twelve years. To her, Gill “worked with devotion at Ajanta until the Mutiny”. The work went on “under difficulties and disappointments, and it constitutes a remarkable feat of endurance.” In 1852 a large piece of painting was stolen. Repeated requests for a guard were answered in September 1857, when a naik and eight sipahis were sent. The next year fever and dysentery broke out in the camp, and Gill reported that he himself had been far from well for the last fifteen months. About 1862 his stereoscopic photographs of the rock temples of Ajanta and Ellora were published, and in 1863 he was still sending home paintings and drawings.
Robert Gill at Ajanta
Major Gill of Ajanta
From time to time Gill sent his copies to London, about thirty in all, many of them very large. There they were kept in the East India Company’s museum. All but the last five later went on show at the Crystal Palace, and there they were burnt in 1866. No copy, tracing or photograph had been taken of them first. Burgess wrote: “Alas for official wisdom and forethought!” Of the work of “one of the most faithful of artists”, all that was left were copies of two of his pictures and of eight fragments in Mrs. Speir’s Ancient India, “on a very small scale indeed”. Later the Gazetteer of Aurangabad named those whose work had helped it identify the district’s animals. Among them it listed “the illustrations of the Natural History of Western India by Major Gill of Ajanta.” And students of art first came to know the paintings of Ajanta “through the excellent copies made by Major R. Gill in earlier days (1844-63).” Told from Robert Gill, Notes and Illustrations of the Buddhist Caves of Ajanta (1876), p. 2; James Fergusson, Illustrations of the Rock-cut Temples of India (1845), pp. 21-22; James Burgess, Notes on the Bauddha Rock-Temples of Ajanta (1879), pp. 1-2; James Fergusson and James Burgess, The Cave Temples of India (1880), Preface p. xvi and ch. VIII p. 282; Lady Herringham and her assistants, Ajanta Frescoes (1915), p. 15; G. Yazdani, Ajanta, Part I (1930), Preface p. v; and the Gazetteer of Aurangabad (1884), Fauna. Burgess puts the fire in the latter part of 1866, Lady Herringham in December 1866.