Stories of India's Great Monuments · Elephanta
Guns in the Cave
A Shot in the Dark
Inside the great cave of Elephanta, several dark rooms had been hewn out of the rock. Into one of them Alexander Hamilton fired a shot. “I never heard Cannon nor Thunder make such a dreadful Noise.” The noise went on for about half a minute, and the mountain seemed to shake. As soon as it was over, a large serpent appeared. He and those with him took to their heels and got out of the cave at one door. The serpent, “in great Haste”, went out at the other. He tells it in a book printed in 1727; the Bombay Gazetteer dates his visit 1720. The island then belonged to the Portuguese, and it served “only to feed some Cattle”. He believed its name came from an elephant carved out of a great black stone. It was so like a living one that at two hundred yards a sharp eye might be deceived. A little way off stood a horse cut out of stone, but not so well shaped.
Guns in the Cave
No Account
In the middle of the island rose a hill shaped like a blunt pyramid. Halfway up it was the cave, with two wide openings to let in people and light. Its roof rested on pillars hewn out of the solid rock and finely carved. Some bore figures of men about eight feet high, “exceedingly well proportioned and cut”. One showed a giant with four heads joined together, their faces looking away from one another. He sat with his legs under him, and his right hand alone was above twenty inches long. A spring of sweet water ran out of one of the dark rooms, through the cave, and out at an opening. About twenty people lived on the island. He asked them whether they had any account, by history or tradition, of who had made the cave, or the animals carved in stone. “They could give no Account.”
Guns in the Cave
A Great Gun for the Echo
Eight years before Hamilton, in 1712, Pyke found the Portuguese foddering their cattle there in the rainy season, to shelter them from the violence of the monsoon. The echo in the cave was most admirable. And he heard a story. Lately one of the Portuguese had amused himself with that echo. He “had fired a great gun into it with several shot, which had broken some of the pillars”. So the cattle he found there himself; the story of the great gun and the broken pillars he heard. Grose came later; the Gazetteer dates his account 1750. He describes the caves as water-logged. In his account the figures had kept in a fair state, for their age, until the Portuguese made themselves masters of the place. Then, in the blind fury of their bigotry, allowing no idols but their own, they must have taken some pains to maim and deface them, so hard was the stone. “It is said” that they even brought field pieces to the demolition of the images, “which so greatly deserved to be spared”. The Gazetteer gives Grose’s charge, and adds in a note: “Grose is always ready to spread tales against the Portuguese.” James Burgess thought Grose had found Pyke’s story of the great gun: still remembered in his time, but much exaggerated. Told from Alexander Hamilton, A New Account of the East Indies, vol. I (1727), ch. XX, pp. 238-239; the Gazetteer of the Bombay Presidency, vol. XIV, Thana: Places of Interest (1882), Elephanta, pp. 85-87 and note 1; and James Burgess, The Rock-Temples of Elephanta (1871), note 9, p. 55, which quotes Pyke and Grose. Hamilton gives the serpent’s length and girth in feet, but his figures cannot be read in the old print.