Stories of India's Great Monuments · Elephanta
The Horse That Seemed Alive
A Horse of Stone
On a small island three leagues from Bombay stood a horse carved in stone, the size of a real horse. It was “so lively, with such a Colour and Carriage”, and its shape so exactly finished, that many who saw it from a distance took it for a living animal. J. Ovington, who made a voyage to Surat in 1689, tells of it in a book printed in 1696. The island was Elephanta. It took its name from an elephant cut in stone, as large as a full-grown living one. The elephant stood in the middle of a field, in plain sight of anyone who came into that part of the island. He thought such figures were made not only to show the sculptor’s skill. Their fine workmanship was more likely meant to win admiration, and with it a kind of religious respect, from “such Heathens as came near them”. But what most marked the island was “the fam’d Pagode at the top of it”, much spoken of by the Portuguese. The present Queen Dowager admired it so much that to her no one had seen this part of India who came home without some account of it.
The Horse That Seemed Alive
Defaced by the Portuguese
Dr. John Fryer had seen the horse years before; his account was printed in 1698. Coming back by boat from a week’s business at Bassein, a Portuguese city, they steered on purpose to touch at Elephanta. There was the elephant, cut out of the rock, “bearing a Young one on its Back”. Not far from it, in the valley, the horse stood “stuck up to the Belly in the Earth”. From there he and his party clambered up the highest hill on the island. On its summit was “a miraculous Piece hewed out of solid Stone”, held up on pillars he called Corinthian. A statue with three heads was “crowned with strange Hieroglyphicks”. All along the walls were huge giants, “some with eight hands”, making their vanquished knights stoop for mercy. It seemed to him of later date than the one at a place he calls “Canorein”, “though defaced by the Portugals, who have this Island also”. The Portuguese had no defence on it, and the island was inhabited by the poor.
The Horse That Seemed Alive
A Race of Giants
Ovington saw the giants too, in a very large temple cut out of the very heart of a hard rock up a high hill. Forty or fifty figures of men stood out of its sides, each twelve or fifteen feet high, some with six arms or three heads. Some were so huge that their fingers were larger than an ordinary man’s leg. Here some took “an Amiable Charming Lady by the Chin”; there was “the horrid Prospect” of others hewing little children in pieces. The island was then held by the Portuguese, but these giant figures had once been revered as heroes or demigods. And he gives what he says was the account of them in the chronicles of those who revered them. The figures, by that account, showed the first race of mortals, who were all giants. Men dwindled by degrees, until the decay of manners shrank them to the size men are now: our small stature came from too much vice and too little virtue. And because cutting a temple out of such hard rock needed “Incredible endless Pains”, they would have it that only such giants could have done the work.
The Horse That Seemed Alive
No Trace
The horse that seemed alive seems not to have lasted. It stood somewhere near the top of a ravine where the hills draw close together. Like the elephant, it was carved out of a block of trap. The Bombay Gazetteer judged that Ovington described it more fully than Fryer, “though probably less accurately”. In 1712 Captain Pyke called it Alexander’s Horse, and drew it: a stiff, zebra-like animal, its belly and legs not cut free of the rock. Captain Hamilton, in 1720, thought it “not so proportionable and well shaped as the Elephant”. It seems to have disappeared between 1712, when Pyke saw it, and 1764, when Niebuhr visited the island. Neither Anquetil-Duperron, who came in 1760, nor Niebuhr notices it. In 1818 Mr. Erskine searched for the horse. He found no trace. Told from J. Ovington, A Voyage to Suratt in the Year 1689 (1696), pp. 158-162; John Fryer, A New Account of East-India and Persia (1698), Letter II, ch. III, pp. 75-76; James Burgess, The Rock-Temples of Elephanta (1871), p. 2 and note 9, p. 55; and the Gazetteer of the Bombay Presidency, vol. XIV, Thana: Places of Interest (1882), Elephanta, pp. 84-85, 93. Burgess dates Fryer’s visit 1673, the Gazetteer 1673 and 1675; Burgess has Ovington writing in 1689, the Gazetteer 1690. Fryer counts forty-two pillars, Ovington sixteen.