Stories of India's Great Monuments · Ellora
The Charge Against Aurangzeb
Groans in the Temple of Jugnat
At one of his visits to a cave at Ellora, a group gathered round John B. Seely, groaning, their faces twisted in “strange and piteous contortions”. He would have laughed, if he had not pitied their feelings. They were telling him of a crime, an “impious act” they laid at the door of the emperor Aurangzeb. His court, they said, had been held only a short way off, at Aurangabad. The cave stands at the northern end of the long row of excavations. To Seely its name was “of the highest order”: it is dedicated to Jugnat, “the Lord of the Creation”. Parts of its halls were coated with chunam, and where Seely scraped a little of it away, the furrows of the chisel showed plainly. Figures were painted on the ceiling. But the painting and the chunam had been badly injured and defaced.
The Charge Against Aurangzeb
Gunpowder and a Cow
And “a heavy charge was brought against Aurungzebe”. He had wilfully tried, the charge ran, to destroy this cave by blowing it up with gunpowder. When that “monstrous purpose” failed, he had a cow, “the most sacred of animals”, slaughtered within the walls of the temple. Not all the Brahmans accepted it. Some went into the temple cheerfully. Others, “with loathing and horror”, would not enter “the defiled place”. When Seely had his turn to speak, and read to them part of a letter annexed to his chapter, his hearers gave their answer. If Aurangzeb did not commit the act himself, they said, he allowed his court to. With the court so close at Aurangabad, the temples were constantly visited and insulted by his “minions”.
The Charge Against Aurangzeb
Straw and Fire in the Kailasa
The cave of Jugnat was not the only place where the people of Ellora told of Aurangzeb. They told of him at the Kailasa too, a temple whose rooms had pyramidal roofs, once stuccoed and painted. C. W. Malet, who described the caves in 1794, found the painting inside black with smoke. “The people here attribute the smoky blackness of the painting within,” he wrote, to Aurangzeb, who had the rooms filled with straw and set on fire. Seely found the same story in the papers of the Asiatic Society in Calcutta. In his own opinion, the blackness might be “otherwise accounted for”. Malet set down another story. In a gallery on the right of the Kailasa court, three pillars were broken. They were broken, it was said, to make trial of the power of the god of the place. When the rock above did not sink, “the tempter, said to be Aurungzebe”, gave up the trial.
The Charge Against Aurangzeb
An Obelisk and Forty Pilgrims
In front of another temple, Seely saw a single obelisk, more carved than the two before the Kailasa. There had once been two, the Brahman told him, but Aurangzeb had destroyed the one on the right. “Of this I have my doubts,” Seely writes. He could find no trace of its base, and no fallen pieces. In Seely’s day few pilgrims came to Ellora. He gives the reasons, on a page the old print has partly lost. The once powerful Holkar family had suffered reverses, and no longer supported the pilgrims. The country was in a distracted state. He names centuries of warfare by foreign invaders, and the “tyranny” the Hindus had known at the hands of their “Mahomedan masters”. And there was “the received opinion” that Aurangzeb had “profaned and violated” these shrines by sacrificing oxen and cows in a few of the temples. In all his stay, he thought, not more than forty came from a distance to pray at Ellora. They bitterly lamented the fallen grandeur of the place.
The Charge Against Aurangzeb
The Tirtha Leaves the Caves
Later James Burgess found the village of Ellora still the site of the shrine of Ghrishnesvara. It was one of the twelve sacred tirthas or jyotirlingas of the Hindus. To him the tirtha was doubtless at the caves at first. But after their desecration by Aurangzeb it lost its repute and was moved to the village, where Ahalya Bai of Indor built a temple that holds the image of Ghrishnesvara. Seely had doubted parts of the story: the smoke might be “otherwise accounted for”, and of the obelisk, “I have my doubts.” And not all the Brahmans had admitted the charge. James Fergusson and Burgess held that the caves “doubtless suffered severely” when Devagiri was taken, about 1294. They were “sure also to suffer” at the hands of Muhammad Tughlik, when he tried to make Daulatabad his capital (1325-1351). “But tradition,” they wrote, “ascribes their final desecration and most of the destruction of the sculpture to Aurangzeb, cir. 1684.” Told from John B. Seely, The Wonders of Elora (1824), pp. 151, 213-214, 219-221, 241 and 324-325; C. W. Malet’s letter to Sir John Shore of 22 December 1794, with a Description of the Caves on the Mountain to the Eastward of Ellora (Asiatic Researches VI, 1799), pp. 408 and 412-413; James Fergusson and James Burgess, The Cave Temples of India (1880), p. 455; and James Burgess, Report on the Elura Cave Temples (Archaeological Survey of Western India V, 1883), p. 3. Malet could explain the burning only as a way to efface any obscenities, “if any there were”, as there are many in the sculpture.