Stories of India's Great Monuments · Konark
The Loadstone That Drew Ships
A Strange Fable
Among the sand hills of the sea shore, eighteen miles north of Puri in Orissa, stand the remains of the temple of the sun at Konark. When A. Stirling described it in 1822, its great tower had been shattered and thrown down, and the temple had long been completely deserted. Why had it been left? The people of the villages nearby had “a strange fable” to account for it. Once, they said, a Kumbha Pathar, a loadstone of immense size, lay on the summit of the great tower. It drew ashore every vessel that passed near the coast. This was felt so much that, about two centuries before Stirling wrote, “in the Mogul time”, the crew of one ship landed some way off. They stole down the coast, attacked the temple, scaled the tower and carried off the loadstone. The priests were alarmed that their holy place had been violated. They took the image of the god, with all its trappings, away to Puri, where they have stayed ever since. And from that day, the villagers said, the temple was deserted, and went rapidly to ruin.
The Loadstone That Drew Ships
The Black Pagoda
The temple’s tower and porch could be seen far out at sea. Old logs and sailing directories call it the Black Pagoda, apparently to tell it from the next landmark, the Jagannath temple at Puri, which was sometimes called the White Pagoda. The earliest mention of the names appears to be in the diary of Sir Streynsham Master, Governor of Fort St. George at Madras. Sailing from Balasore in December 1675, he wrote: “We sailed in sight of the Black Pagoda and the White Pagoda.” An old sailing directory of 1780 says that at a distance the Black Pagoda “resembles a large ship under sail”. But “on a nearer view it loses somewhat of its magnitude.” Stirling saw the same. A small section of the shattered tower, about 120 feet high, still stood, and from afar it gave the ruin something of the look “of a ship under sail.” Local tradition says that when the Black Pagoda was first built it stood on the sea shore. In L. S. S. O’Malley’s day it was 2 miles inland, and its place on the inner row of sand hills bore the tradition out.
The Loadstone That Drew Ships
Like Sinbad’s Rock
W. W. Hunter saw where the fable came from. Ships on their way up the Bay still sighted the temple; and those that took wrong bearings, or neglected their soundings, were “constantly wrecked” on the shore. A “perfect jungle of legends” sprang up to explain why so costly and beautiful a shrine was deserted. The villagers explained the wrecks by the loadstone on the tower, which “like Sinbad the Sailor’s rock, drew the unhappy ships on the sands”. In Hunter’s telling, the crew who scaled the temple and carried off “the fatal magnet” were Muslims; Stirling says only the crew of a ship. Rajendralal Mitra called the loadstone “obviously fictitious”, though he thought the story worthy of note. In his view the tower, from its great height, had served as a beacon, warning sailors of the shallow shore. From that, “it was an easy transit” to the romantic loadstone and the story of Sinbad.
The Loadstone That Drew Ships
What Brought It Down
Stirling himself thought the tower had been thrown down by “some extraordinary force”, an earthquake or lightning. In its fall it seems to have damaged the side of the neighbouring building that looks towards it. Once the ruin had begun, the weather and the plants that root in a deserted building hastened it. The people of the neighbourhood did much harm, forcing out the iron clamps that held the stones together, for the sake of the metal. And he added that “it is well known” that the officers of the Maratha government “actually beat down a part of the walls”. They wanted materials to build “some insignificant temples” at Puri. Mitra was certain that no enemy had brought the temple down. No artillery of two or three hundred years ago could have knocked down walls so thick. Gunpowder enough to do it would have done serious harm to the four walls of the porch as well. And undermining would have been dangerous and slow, and would have left a huge mound of earth and sand nearby.
The Loadstone That Drew Ships
The Image Goes to Puri
The legend ends with the image of the god carried to Puri, and the records tell of that move too. The Temple Annals say that the images of Surya and Chandra, the presiding gods of Konark, were brought away to Puri by a king Narasimha Deva. Mitra puts his reign at 1628 to 1652. O’Malley gives a Raja of Khurda, Narasinhadeva, who was troubled by the Muslim governors. He had once carried the images of Jagannath away to Khurda in fear of an invasion. In 1626-27 this Raja visited the Konark temple, had it measured, and moved the sun-image to the temple of Indra inside the Jagannath enclosure at Puri. Elsewhere O’Malley writes that in 1627 the tower was so dilapidated, and the shrine so deserted, “owing partly to the bigotry of the Muhammadan rulers”, that the image was moved. In 1646 the Raja was killed at Puri by Fateh Khan, an officer of the Nawab, who looted both the palace and the temple.
The Loadstone That Drew Ships
A Lamp at Midday
In O’Malley’s account the image that presided at Konark was the figure he calls Maitraditya. He held a lotus in each hand, with ornaments on his body and a crown on his head. He sat on a chariot drawn by seven horses and guided by Aruna. In 1908 it could still be seen in the temple of Indra. Mitra tells of a small image of the sun, seated on a car drawn by seven horses, in the Surya Mandir, a sun temple at Puri. It is said to have been the presiding god of the great Pagoda at Konark, brought there when that temple was destroyed. But this was not generally acknowledged. Right in front of it stood images of Radha and Krishna, which hid it from the faithful. Mitra saw it only by going into the sanctuary and standing close beside the throne, “with the aid of a lamp at midday.” Why it was hidden away, he wrote, “none would, or could, tell me.” Told from A. Stirling, An Account of Orissa Proper or Cuttack (1822), pp. 164-165; W. W. Hunter, Orissa, vol. I (1872), pp. 289-290; Rajendralal Mitra, The Antiquities of Orissa, vol. II (1880), pp. 149, 151 and the Puri chapter (temple No. 88); and L. S. S. O’Malley, Puri (Bengal District Gazetteers, 1908), pp. 15-16, 39-40, 277, 279, 282-284. O’Malley tells the fable as Stirling does, “in the time of the Mughal rule”. A log of 1746, Croisey’s French map of 1764 (“Pagoda Noire”) and Dunn’s directory of 1780 also name the Black Pagoda; Hunter notes that Captain Horsburgh, by his own Sailing Directions, nearly met with the same mishap. Mitra puts Narasimha Deva’s reign at 1628-1652; O’Malley has Narasinhadeva move the image in 1626-27 and 1627, and die in 1646. Mitra says the old town once stood by the beach and is now more than a mile from it; O’Malley that the Black Pagoda is now 2 miles inland.