Stories of India's Great Monuments · Konark
The Raja Who Was Pulling It Down, 1838
In Danger of Destruction
The Sun Temple at Konark, the Black Pagoda, looks down upon the sea from the coast of Orissa. For a long time it had been “the principal landmark on the coast”. On 1 August 1838 the Asiatic Society of Bengal heard a proposal from Mr Maddock. The Society should take steps to get some pieces of the temple’s richly carved sculpture, he said, for they lay “thrown on the ground and in danger of destruction”. The Society’s journal tells why. A Mr Wilkinson had given the Raja of Khurda leave to take stones from the Black Pagoda, meaning, the journal supposed, probably the loose stones lying apart. But the raja had set about pulling the temple down on purpose, and carrying off all its images to ornament his own house. To move one large figure, he had taken down a beautifully carved door. Unless he was stopped, the journal warned, the old landmark would soon be gone. The Society resolved to ask Government to halt the demolition if it could, or at least to secure some of the sculpture for its museum.
The Raja Who Was Pulling It Down, 1838
A Ship Under Sail
That carved door had been pictured by A. Stirling in 1822. In his day a piece of the tower still stood, about a hundred and twenty feet high. From a distance it gave the ruin “a singular appearance, something resembling that of a ship under sail.” Inside the building, the floor was heaped several feet deep with great blocks that seemed to have fallen from above. Among them lay iron beams, “absolutely crushed beneath a superincumbent mass of stone”. He could not guess why anyone had raised such huge blocks so high. On the black polished sides of the porch’s eastern doorway many names were scrawled. The oldest was “G. Hartwell, 1807.” In 1837 James Fergusson came and sketched the temple. A great part of the tower was still standing. He knew nothing of the style then, he admitted. The iron beams puzzled him too. They were not needed for strength, for the porch still stood firm after they fell. To him they were only one more instance of “that profusion of labour which the Hindus loved to lavish on the temples of their gods.”
The Raja Who Was Pulling It Down, 1838
The Boy and the Snakes
Rajendralal Mitra came at the close of 1868. The upper part of the tower had tumbled down. The temple was now “an enormous mass of stones”, with a few pipal trees growing on it and snakes living in it, and few people cared to go near. One carving still stood out: a rampant lion that had jutted from the tower’s southern face, about a hundred feet up. He wanted it measured with a tape, and offered a cowherd boy two rupees to climb up. The boy probably earned no more than a penny a day. But the dread of snakes made him refuse. Mitra guessed it at about fourteen feet in size, and some six tons in weight. Fergusson later made a restored drawing of the temple. To Mitra it was “the only representation that can now be had of this most magnificent sample of Orissan art.”
The Raja Who Was Pulling It Down, 1838
Why the Tower Fell
What brought down the piece of the tower he had drawn, Fergusson could not say. It had since fallen entirely, he wrote in 1876, “but whether from stress of weather or by aid from the Public Works Department is by no means clear.” Mitra weighed an earthquake against a sinking foundation. But a quake strong enough to fell so solid a tower would have been felt far and wide, and remembered, but tradition is entirely silent about one. So he laid the greater blame on the ground. It was sand everywhere, and the builder had very likely never reached solid earth. In the porch he was sure of it: its pillars had sunk where they stood and brought the ceiling down, leaving the walls around them unhurt. Mitra found Fergusson of the same opinion, from the ruins themselves: the failure of “the marshy foundation” was “by far the most probable cause”. L. S. S. O’Malley, in 1908, set out the theories: earthquake or lightning, the marshy or sandy foundation, faulty building. His own guess was different. Trees and plants growing on the tower loosened its top, and the highest slabs came down in one of the strong south-easterly gales that lash the coast. Most of the stones dropped inside the tower or just outside its lower body, which still stood intact.
The Raja Who Was Pulling It Down, 1838
The Stone of the Nine Planets
Over the eastern door the lintel had been a stone carved with the nine planets. Mitra describes an architrave carved with the nine planets, resting on an iron beam. When the side pilasters fell, they brought it down, and he could not tell whether before 1838 or since. W. W. Hunter tells of a slab over the eastern entrance carved with the emblems of the seven days of the week. Its beauty proved “a more fatal enemy than time itself”, for it “tempted English antiquarians” to try to carry it by sea to the Museum at Calcutta. Its builders had brought it eighty miles overland from quarries in the Hill States, across swamps and unbridged rivers. A grant of public money was enough only to drag the block a couple of hundred yards, “as far as ever from the shore”. At the close of 1868 Mitra found his nine-planet architrave on a truck, about two hundred yards from the temple. Twice it was decided to carry the nine-planet stone to the Indian Museum. The first attempt was soon given up for want of money. The second came about ten years before O’Malley wrote. It “was suddenly abandoned on the discovery that the stone had become an object of local worship, a man from Puri having been cured by its miraculous virtues.” Told from the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, vol. VII (1838), Proceedings of 1 August 1838, p. 667; A. Stirling, An Account of Orissa Proper or Cuttack (1822), p. 169; James Fergusson, History of Indian and Eastern Architecture (1876), pp. 426-428; Rajendralal Mitra, The Antiquities of Orissa, vol. II (1880), pp. 150, 152-153; W. W. Hunter, Orissa, vol. I (1872), pp. 290-292; and L. S. S. O’Malley, Puri (Bengal District Gazetteers, 1908), pp. 277, 279-283. Mitra dates Fergusson’s drawing to 1839 and 1838, and Stirling’s visit to 1824 (O’Malley gives Stirling’s time as 1822); O’Malley says the tower had entirely collapsed by Mitra’s visit in 1869.