Stories of India's Great Monuments · Nalanda
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
Wet With Blood
Seven miles due north of Rajgir lies the village of Baragaon, ringed by ancient tanks and ruined mounds. Alexander Cunningham, who surveyed it in 1861-62, found finer and more numerous sculptures there than at any other place he had visited. On the mound of Jagdispur, under a magnificent nim tree, several statues had been gathered. One was the finest and largest piece of sculpture he had met with. It showed the Buddha as an ascetic, seated under the Bodhi tree at Buddha-Gaya, surrounded by horrible demons and alluring women, all seeking in different ways to distract him. The slab stood 15 feet high, and a large drawing of it was given by Buchanan. The villagers worshipped it. Every day they smeared its forehead and nose with red lead and poured milk over its mouth. Milk was thought a very powerful offering, but the most acceptable of all was a goat. “At the time of my visit the ground was still wet with the blood of a recently killed goat.”
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
Beyond All Doubt
What were these ruins? The Brahmans had an answer: they were Kundilpur, the city where Rukmini, one of the wives of Krishna, was born. Cunningham doubted it. Rukmini was the daughter of Raja Bhishma of Vidarbha, or Berar, and he thought the Brahmans had mistaken Berar for Bihar, only seven miles away. And he went further: “I can show beyond all doubt that the remains at Baragaon are the ruins of Nalanda, the most famous seat of Buddhist learning in all India.” His proofs came from old books. Faxian, who came to the hamlet of Nalo, and Xuanzang, who described Nalanda minutely, each gave its distance from Rajagriha; so did the Pali annals of Ceylon. Each distance matched Baragaon: Xuanzang’s two when measured by the road, and from the most northerly point of the old ramparts. “Lastly, in two inscriptions, which I discovered on the spot, the place itself is called Nalanda.” In a small temple in the hamlet of Kapatiya he found a very good image of Vagisvari. It bore “an important inscription in two lines, which gives the name of the place Nalanda”. It was dated in the first year of the reign of “the paramount sovereign Sri Gopala Deva”. “This evidence seems conclusive.”
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
The Pilgrim’s Map
To Cunningham the ruins matched Xuanzang’s descriptions “most minutely”, and he followed that account mound by mound. A row of lofty conical mounds were the remains of the monastery’s gigantic temples. Where the great monastery had stood, fields by then lay in square patches among the brick ruins. He took them for the courtyards of the six monasteries Xuanzang describes inside one enclosure. Xuanzang begins with a temple just outside the monastery’s western wall, raised where the Buddha had dwelt three months, explaining the law to the gods. Cunningham took it for one of the great mounds, and dug into it. His excavations “exposed the straight walls of a temple.” When was it all built? Faxian came first, and says only that he reached the hamlet of Nalo, “where Sariputra was born.” Had King Baladitya’s temple, 300 feet high, stood then, it seemed to Cunningham “scarcely possible that he should not have noticed it.” So he gave the temples and monasteries a probable date between the two men’s visits, from AD 425 to 625.
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
Iron-Bound Stones
Cunningham had his own idea of who had wrecked some of these buildings. On the terrace round the great mound he found the remains of several small stupas of dark blue stone. Their carvings were still in good order: rows after rows of Buddhas of all sizes. Each was built of separate stones, numbered to guide the builders and cramped together with iron. “No amount of time, and not even an earthquake, could have destroyed these small buildings. Their solid walls of iron-bound stones could only have yielded to the destructive fury of malignant Brahmans.” He tried to put one stupa together again, but soon found several pieces missing. He believed a complete one might yet be found by a careful search about the village temples and the Jain temple. It would make “a most striking and ornamental addition to the Calcutta Museum.”
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
The Brick Quarry of Bihar
By 1872 A. M. Broadley could write that the place had been identified “beyond the possibility of a doubt” with the great Nalanda monastery. On 15 October 1871 he came to its central mound, sixty feet high, the largest of all. He found it “literally a small hill”, covered in thicket and brushwood, with a hollow on top and the remains of an earlier dig on its eastern slope. The wall that had surrounded the monastery was gone without a trace, and the most diligent search could not find the great gate. “Burgaon has been the brick quarry of Bihar for centuries.” The landlord of the village had built two large houses with its bricks, one three storeys high, and the principal “ryots” of the village had brick houses. He traced the great bricks in the modern Jain temple of Baragaon and its garden wall, and in the mosque and merchants’ houses of Silhao. Nor was it only bricks. Exquisitely carved lintels and pillars had gone to ornament Muslim tombs and shrines. One door “of extraordinary beauty” by then formed the entrance to the shrine of Shah Ahmed Charamposh at Bihar.
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
A Thousand Labourers
That same day, 15 October, Broadley began to dig the great central mound, with 1,000 labourers. They cleared the jungle and worked without a break until the 25th. They laid bare a paved court with halls and buildings round it. In its centre rose an enormous temple in four or five terraces, its bricks laid so close that the cement between them barely showed. To Broadley the first two terraces were almost as perfect as when Xuanzang saw them, fourteen hundred years before. On the west side of the court stood the great entrance door. He uncovered it perfect. It “was thrown down in my absence by the workmen, who imagined I wished to remove the whole edifice to Bihar.” In an inner chamber he found a headless Buddha four feet high, on a handsome throne of black basalt. Between the mounds he traced eight halls, with gateways and pillars but no images, and took them for the “halls of disputation” that Xuanzang describes.
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
Found or Invented
Not everyone trusted what Broadley reported. James Fergusson and James Burgess studied his plan and his drawing of the building. They found it possible from neither “to make out what he found, or what he invented.” A photograph they received later was enough to show “how utterly worthless Mr. Broadley’s drawings are.” Another man had dug there too. The great mound was later excavated by order of Government under Captain Marshall. That was in 1871, and Fergusson and Burgess could not tell whether he and Broadley had dug the same ground. Marshall found a temple with an inner room, and the remains of a pedestal, but no trace of any statue; pieces of broken statues lay in the entrance hall. To him the false doorway, “the abstraction of the idols” and the missing plaster told one story. The building had been used after “the glories of the temple had passed away”, and then fell to pieces through neglect and decay.
Cunningham Finds Nalanda
Worshipped as Rukmini
Where Cunningham blamed “malignant Brahmans”, Broadley read the ruins otherwise. Hindu and Buddhist images lay side by side at Baragaon. To him its sculptures “lend no aid to the theory which represents the violent overthrow of Budhism by the partisans of Hinduism”. Hindus and Buddhists, he believed, had once both worshipped at its shrines. Then the Buddhists’ “languid faith” died out before the stronger belief, “and perhaps occasional attacks and persecutions” of the Hindus. At last the Hindu establishment itself fell “to religious indifference and Mahomedan persecution”. He asked the Brahmans of the village, twenty-four families, about the old tradition. Nearly all told him that the ruined mound of Jagdispur, half a mile south-west of Baragaon, was the site of Rukmini’s father’s palace. He agreed with Cunningham that the tradition came from a confusion of Bihar and Berar: “I have no doubt he is right.” Broadley went to the spot. There he found the large Buddha that Montgomery Martin had described and pictured in his book. He thought the figure “very rudely carved”, and Martin’s picture “very flattering”. “I was gravely assured this was a statue of Rukmini, and it is still certainly worshipped as such.” Told from Alexander Cunningham, Four Reports Made during the Years 1862-63-64-65 (Archaeological Survey of India I, 1871), pp. 28-36, with the note on p. 33; A. M. Broadley, The Ruins of the Nalanda Monasteries at Burgaon (1872), pp. 1, 5-11; and James Fergusson and James Burgess, The Cave Temples of India (1880), pp. 130-131. Broadley puts Baragaon seven miles north-east of Rajgir. Cunningham also dates Baladitya’s temple to AD 450-550, by its likeness to the Buddha-Gaya temple. Broadley judged the temple at least 200 feet high; Fergusson and Burgess thought about 70 or 100.