Stories of India's Great Monuments · Sanchi
Captain Fell Sees the Stupas Whole, 1819
A Hill Near Bhilsa
Four and a half miles south-west of the town of Bhilsa, on the flat top of a hill that stands on its own, Captain E. Fell came upon what he called “an ancient fabric, of a hemispherical form”. Statues of the Buddha sat at its gateways; a plan of the place, among sketches signed 1819, calls it “the Jain or Buddhaic Building at Sanchee Kanikhéra”. Fell wrote it up in a letter signed at Hoshangabad on 31 January 1819. It was a great dome of thin layers of stone, set like steps, with no cement between them, and it looked solid all through. The jutting layers made it easy to climb. On the summit lay a cupola that had once crowned it, split, with the pillars that had held it up. At one point the weight and age of the great mass had pushed part of the stone buttress round its base outward until it gave way. Through the gap Fell could see for himself that no cement had been used inside either.
Captain Fell Sees the Stupas Whole, 1819
Rooms Within?
The buildings round it had fallen into decay, yet this one stood entire. In every carving of it on its own gateways, and even on loose stones, Fell saw an opening. And a mass of stone so large, laid so neatly without cement, must need supports within, he was sure: it “must forcibly strike the most superficial observer”. So he came to suspect that it stood on pillars inside. “If so, apartments undoubtedly exist within, highly interesting, and worthy of being further examined.” Finding out would take much time and labour, and the consent of the Nawab of Bhopal, in whose territory it stood. Fell did not think jealousies would stand in the way, for to him no orthodox Hindu would visit such a monument, and the Jains, like everyone else, had grown “totally indifferent” to it. What Fell feared was time. Decay had begun. A few years, most probably, would bring the whole down in a mass of ruin. It would destroy whatever rooms and images lay inside, if there were any, “and thus for ever” deprive the curious of knowing “what so wonderful a monument of human genius contains.”
Captain Fell Sees the Stupas Whole, 1819
A Boat in a Tempest
Gateways forty feet high stood at the east, the west and the north, their uprights carved in panels. Inside each sat a Buddha as large as life, cross-legged on a throne borne by lions. All of them were badly broken, and one had been moved from its place and thrown across the open ground. On the western gateway he found a boat with a lion’s head for its prow and a fish’s tail for its stern. It was “in an open sea, in the midst of a tempest”. Two men rowed. Round it figures swam, clutching at whatever they could to keep from sinking. One, about to drown, was making “an expiring effort” to climb its side. Their faces showed their plight. Above, five pot-bellied dwarfs held up the lintel on their raised hands, as though about to be crushed beneath it. “It is hardly possible to conceive sculpture more expressive of feeling than this.” On the south side Fell found no gateway, only a plain entrance. The Southern gateway had long lain fallen by then.
Captain Fell Sees the Stupas Whole, 1819
Not a Stone Fallen
A quarter of a mile to the north stood a second monument, the same in shape but smaller, its stones closely fitted. “It is in perfect repair, not a stone having fallen.” Almost every stone bore an inscription. Round both monuments lay pieces of columns, broken images of the Buddha and slabs carved with horsemen, elephants and lions. Many inscriptions ran over the pillars round the great monument, most in letters Fell could hardly read. On one pilaster he was “highly gratified” to find a Sanskrit inscription with a date that, by his reading, showed the great monument finished forty years before Christ. F. C. Maisey later found that he had misread it. Fell thought an antiquary skilled in research would find work there for some time; copying the inscriptions alone would take days. He lamented that he could not draw well enough to do the sculpture justice, and that he had had so little time. His account could give only “a very faint idea of the magnificence of such stupendous structures”. But he knew of no earlier description, and so he sent his, with all its faults.
Captain Fell Sees the Stupas Whole, 1819
A Few Years
His letter was printed in the Calcutta Journal of 11 July 1819. Fifteen years later it had still appeared in no lasting work, so in 1834 James Prinsep, editor of the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, reprinted it there. If the building could be pierced without injury, Prinsep mused, coins might be found inside that would tell its age. Fell had known of no earlier description. Yet C. E. Luard says the stupa was “first discovered by General Taylor in 1818”. John Marshall also has Taylor there in 1818: three gateways standing, the southern lying where it had fallen, the great dome intact. Bhilsa near by was sacked three times by Muslim conquerors and its temples destroyed a fourth time under Aurangzeb, yet the monuments on the hill were left unscathed. Fell had feared that a few years would bring the great monument down. By 1850, when Maisey came, only two of its gateways, the Northern and the Eastern, still stood; the Western had fallen a few years before. And the smaller monument, the one Fell had found with not a stone fallen? In Alexander Cunningham’s account it was “in perfect repair” in 1819, but in 1822 half destroyed, by the same amateur antiquaries who had ruined the larger stupa. Told from Captain E. Fell’s account of 1819 and James Prinsep’s notes in the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, vol. III (1834), pp. 411, 489-494; F. C. Maisey, Sanchi and its Remains (1893), pp. 5, 11, 76; Alexander Cunningham, The Bhilsa Topes (1854), pp. 185, 275; John Marshall, A Guide to Sanchi (1918), p. 25; and C. E. Luard, The Bhopal State Gazetteer (1908), p. 118. Fell read the date as the year 18 of the Samvat era; Prinsep would not credit it without a facsimile. The same journal’s proceedings say Fell visited in 1817 or 1818.