Stories of India's Great Monuments · Sanchi
The Treasure-Hunters of 1822
Cut Open
In December 1822 Dr. Spilsbury went to see the great stupa of Sanchi, near Bhilsa, and found it cut open. Mr. Maddock, the Political Agent at Bhopal, had got leave from the Bhopal government to dig into it. His assistant, Captain Johnson, had done the digging. He had “completely opened it from the top”, down about thirty feet, Spilsbury thought, to what Johnson took for the bottom of the foundations. What had Johnson found inside? Only “the whole solid brick-work, without any appearance of recess or open space of any kind.” His note was printed in the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal in 1835. On rooms hidden inside the stupa he was plain: “With regard to apartments within, none exist.”
The Treasure-Hunters of 1822
A Search for Treasure
Spilsbury, who saw the cutting, writes of rooms. F. C. Maisey calls the dig “an unsuccessful and carelessly conducted search for buried treasure”. To John Marshall, each new account of the stupas had stirred up interest in them, and the interest proved “lamentably disastrous”. The hill became “a hunting-ground for treasure seekers and amateur archaeologists”, some trying to probe its secrets, some hoping to enrich themselves from the spoils they supposed were hidden there. Between them they half demolished most of the buildings and did them “irreparable harm”. In 1822 Johnson opened the Great Stupa “from top to bottom on one side” and left a vast breach in it. Marshall thought “the same blundering excavator” was probably to blame for the partial destruction of the Second and Third Stupas, “which until then had been in perfect repair.” In Maisey’s account, the search did “immense damage” to the upper part of “the three more important” stupas, and hastened, if it did not begin, the ruin of their enclosures. An old man of Sanchi told Maisey of an outer way up to the summit. Maisey thought it most probably a scaffolding of the visitors who “ascended, and destroyed” the stupa in 1822. The Ti and its square enclosure, though, were already down in 1819, as Fell’s description shows.
The Treasure-Hunters of 1822
The Fallen Gateways
Johnson’s breach went on doing harm. Marshall blames it for much later damage to the body of the stupa, and for the collapse of the Western Gateway and parts of the railing. Water did harm too. Rubbish had piled up several feet deep round the stupa over the centuries, so that every monsoon it stood in a sheet of water. It was “small wonder” to him that the South and West Gateways, with long sections of the railing, sank and collapsed. In James Fergusson’s account of 1868, the Western Gateway had fallen only a few years before. The cause, apparently, was the clumsy digging of “some nameless amateurs”, who buried it under the rubbish they threw down from the stupa itself. When Spilsbury came in 1822, three gateways still stood. The fourth, he believed, had been “thrown down by an earthquake”, and lay strewn on the ground; before long, he warned, another would follow. In Marshall’s account, many of the carved reliefs still looked almost as fresh as when they left the sculptor’s chisel. Such harm as the others had suffered was done chiefly in modern days by “Moslem iconoclasts”, “too many of whom, alas,” still took delight in his own day in defacing them.
The Treasure-Hunters of 1822
Within a Single Foot
Alexander Cunningham found that at the Great Stupa the diggers had cut their breach on the south-west side and carried it down to the foundation. But they never reached the centre. “The Tope was thus partly ruined without any discovery having been made to repay its destruction.” Another stupa had fared no better: one that Captain Fell had seen perfect in 1819. Cunningham and Maisey came to it after the diggers of 1822 had half ruined it. Cunningham wrote: “I must confess that I felt a secret satisfaction that the labours of the bungling amateurs, who had half ruined it in 1822, had ended in nothing.” Yet the breach was so large that he had misgivings. Had their workmen reached the centre after all? After several careful measurements, he and Maisey were both satisfied that the true centre had not quite been reached, “although the excavators must have been within a single foot of it.” Told from Dr. Spilsbury’s note in the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, vol. IV (1835), p. 712; F. C. Maisey, Sanchi and its Remains (1893), pp. 5, 13; John Marshall, A Guide to Sanchi (1918), pp. 26-27, 79; Alexander Cunningham, The Bhilsa Topes (1854), pp. 269, 285; James Fergusson, Tree and Serpent Worship (1868), p. 109; and C. E. Luard, The Bhopal State Gazetteer (1908), p. 118. The Gazetteer puts the dig in 1828 and names the Political Agent Haddock; Spilsbury, who was there, gives December 1822 and Maddock.