Stories of India's Great Monuments · The Taj Mahal
Curzon and the Story of the Sale
Hammer and Chisel
Lord Curzon told of revellers who came to the garden of the Taj with hammer and chisel. In the days when picnic parties were held there, it was not an uncommon thing. The guests would pass the afternoon chipping fragments of agate and carnelian out of the tombs of the emperor and “his lamented Queen”. He said it on 7 February 1900, at the annual meeting of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, of which he was the Patron. He told the Society that at Agra “the other day” he had gone to the marble tomb of Shah Jahan in the lower vault, “beneath which his body actually lies”. It was still stripped of much of its inlay. He ordered it restored. To him the old governments had been busy laying the foundations of a new empire, and thought little of the relics of old ones. Now and then a Governor-General spared a little money, and one appointed a committee to repair the Taj. But such efforts brought little more than a few drawings and “a few local and perfunctory repairs”. He added that incidents of the past could show how little the officials of those days cared for beauty.
Curzon and the Story of the Sale
“Offered for Sale!”
Curzon said: “In the days of Lord William Bentinck the Taj was on the point of being destroyed for the value of its marbles.” On 26 July 1831 a Calcutta newspaper, the John Bull, had printed a report. Fanny Parkes copied it into her book. “The Governor-general has sold the beautiful piece of architecture, called the Mootee Musjid, at Agra, for 125,000 rupees,” it ran, “and it is now being pulled down! The taj has also been offered for sale!” The paper added that the price asked had not been obtained, though two lakhs of rupees had been offered for it. If the Taj were pulled down, it was rumoured, there might be disturbances among the people. Parkes wrote: “If this be true, is it not shameful?” The present king might as well sell the chapel of Henry the Seventh in Westminster Abbey. “By what authority does the Governor-general offer the taj for sale? Has he any right to molest the dead? To sell the tomb raised over an empress, which from its extraordinary beauty is the wonder of the world?” And she added what “they say”: that a Hindu wished to buy the Taj, to carry away its marble and build a temple at Bindrabund.
Curzon and the Story of the Sale
A Careless Remark
W. H. Sleeman tells of the palace at Agra. An earlier Governor-General broke up one of its most beautiful marble baths, to send home to George IV of England. Later, by order of Lord William Bentinck, the rest of the marble of those rooms was sold by auction for the government. Sleeman wrote: “Had these things fetched the price expected, it is probable that the whole of the palace, and even the Taj itself, would have been pulled down, and sold in the same manner.” In Parkes’s account the auction brought so small a sum that “it put a stop to further depredations.” Sleeman, “feeling as an Englishman”, could hardly help wishing that the bath-room had fetched a better price, and that “palace, Taj, and all at Agra, had gone to the hammer”. His reason was that the buildings raised the past above the present in the people’s minds. When Curzon’s speeches were printed in 1906, a note was put to his sentence on Bentinck. “This statement was made on official authority. But there is reason to think that it is an exaggeration, based on a careless remark by Sir W. Sleeman.”
Curzon and the Story of the Sale
Lime-Light and Lanterns
The Taj has a mosque on one side, and on the other a building that balances it, the false mosque. Travellers and pleasure parties had used it, and so arose the “oft-reported story of ‘wassail and riot’”. H. G. Keene saw little harm in a few Englishmen enjoying themselves there, “within the limits of becoming mirth”. But he also quoted “a recent Indian journalist”: “To my mind the Taj is utterly unsuited for illumination. To crowd the silent gardens with gaping chattering crowds, to deck the great doorway and the mosque with rows of light till they resemble gin-palaces, to fling lime-light upon the delicate masonry of the mausoleum, seems to me an act of vandalism.” Garden parties, bazaars and even dances had once been held in the grounds, and the tomb lit up with lime-light and Chinese lanterns. In 1905 the gazetteer of Agra said: “Happily these practices have long ceased.” The false mosque was a rest-house no more. The only gatherings allowed were for festivals, Muslim and Hindu, and a flower-show each March.
Curzon and the Story of the Sale
A Pearl of Great Price
On 18 March 1904 the Bill for the Preservation of Ancient Monuments came before the Legislative Council at Calcutta, and the Viceroy, Lord Curzon, spoke. He said: “The Taj itself and all its surroundings are now all but free from the workmen’s hands. It is no longer approached through dusty wastes and a squalid bazaar. A beautiful park takes their place.” Every building in the garden had been repaired. Old plans had been found, and the water-channels and flower-beds were laid out again more nearly as they first were. The other old buildings of Agra had been taken in hand too, and their inlaid agate, jasper and cornelian were being replaced. “The skilled workmen of Agra have lent themselves to the enterprise with as much zeal and taste as their forerunners 300 years ago.” The tomb of Shah Jahan in the vault, which he had found stripped of much of its inlay, was restored too. Since he came to India, between £40,000 and £50,000 had been spent on repairs at Agra alone. “Every rupee has been an offering of reverence to the past and a gift of recovered beauty to the future.” In three or four years more, “Agra will be given back to the world, a pearl of great price.” Told from Sir Thomas Raleigh (ed.), Lord Curzon in India: Being a Selection from his Speeches (1906), pp. 185, 188-190, 194, 198-199; Fanny Parkes, Wanderings of a Pilgrim in Search of the Picturesque, vol. I (1850), pp. 220, 368; W. H. Sleeman, Rambles and Recollections of an Indian Official, vol. II (1844), pp. 36-37, 41; H. G. Keene, A Handbook for Visitors to Agra and its Neighbourhood, 6th ed. (1899), pp. 33-34; H. R. Nevill, Agra: A Gazetteer (1905), pp. 209, 216-217; Reginald Heber, Narrative of a Journey through the Upper Provinces of India, vol. I (1828), p. 587. The earlier Governor-General is Lord Hastings in Sleeman. Parkes and Nevill have the bath sent to the Prince Regent; Heber and Curzon say it never left Agra. Curzon names Lord Minto’s repair committee; Nevill dates one to 1809.