Folk-Tales of Kashmir
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
The Fish That Laughed
A fisherwoman was going past a palace, calling out her fish. The queen came to a window and beckoned her over to see what she had. Just then a very big fish began to jump about in the bottom of the basket. “Is it a male or a female?” asked the queen. “I want to buy a female fish.” At this the fish laughed out loud. “It’s a male,” said the fisherwoman, and went on her way. The queen went back to her room in a great rage. When the king came to see her that evening, he saw that something had upset her. “Are you unwell?” he asked. “No,” she said. “But I am very angry with a fish. A woman brought me one today. I asked whether it was a male or a female, and the fish laughed at me, most rudely.” “A fish laughed? Impossible! You must have dreamt it.” “I am not a fool. I am telling you what I saw with my own eyes and heard with my own ears.” “Very strange! Well, so be it. I will look into it.” The next day the king told his wazir, his chief minister, what the queen had said. He ordered him to find out why the fish had laughed, and to bring a proper answer within six months. If he failed, he would die. The wazir promised to do his best, though he felt almost sure he would fail. For five months he worked without rest. He searched everywhere and asked everyone. He asked the wise and the learned. He asked people skilled in magic and in every kind of trick. Nobody could explain it.
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
The Wazir’s Son
So he went home with a broken heart and began to set his affairs in order, ready to die. He knew the king well enough to know he would not take back his threat. Among other things, he told his son to go away and travel for a while, until the king’s anger had cooled a little. The son was a clever and handsome young man. He set off wherever fate might lead him. After some days on the road he fell in with an old farmer, who was also travelling to a certain village. The young man liked the old man. He asked if he might go along with him, and said that he too was going to that village. The farmer agreed, and they walked on together. The day was hot, and the road was long and tiring. “Wouldn’t it be pleasanter,” said the young man, “if you and I took turns to carry each other?” “What a fool the man is!” thought the farmer. Soon they passed a field of corn, ripe for cutting, waving like a sea of gold in the breeze. “Is this eaten or not?” asked the young man. The old man did not understand him. “I don’t know,” he said. A little later they came to a big village. There the young man handed his companion a clasp-knife. “Take this, friend, and get two horses with it,” he said. “But be sure to bring it back. It is very precious.” The old man pushed the knife back at him, half amused and half angry. He muttered that his friend was either out of his mind or making fun of him. The young man acted as if he had not heard, and said almost nothing more until they reached the city. The farmer’s house was a short way outside it.
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
City and Cemetery
The two of them walked about the bazaar and went to the mosque. But nobody greeted them, and nobody asked them in to rest. “What a large cemetery!” said the young man. “What does he mean,” thought the farmer, “calling this crowded city a cemetery?” Their road out of the city led through a cemetery. A few people there were praying beside a grave. In memory of the one they had lost, they were handing out chapatis and kulchas, two kinds of bread, to passers-by. They beckoned to the two travellers and gave them as much as they wanted. “What a splendid city this is!” said the young man. “The man must be mad,” thought the farmer. “What will he do next? He’ll call the land water and the water land. He’ll speak of light when it is dark, and of dark when it is light.” But he kept his thoughts to himself. Next they had to wade a stream that ran along the edge of the cemetery. The water was rather deep. So the old farmer took off his shoes and his loose trousers and crossed. But the young man waded through with his shoes and trousers on. “Well! I never saw such a perfect fool, in word and in deed,” the old man said to himself. All the same, he liked the young man. He thought he would amuse his wife and daughter. So he invited him to stay at his house for as long as he had business in the village. “Thank you very much,” said the young man. “But first, may I ask whether the beam of your house is strong?”
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
Is Your Beam Strong?
The farmer gave him up in despair and went into his house laughing. He greeted his wife and daughter. “There is a man out in that field,” he said. “He has come most of the way with me. I wanted him to stay here while he is in the village. But he is such a fool, I can make nothing of him. He wants to know if the beam of this house is all right! The man must be mad!” And he burst out laughing. “Father,” said his daughter, who was a very sharp and wise girl, “whoever this man is, he is no fool. He only wants to know if you can afford to have him as a guest.” In a Kashmiri house, one long strong beam runs along the upper storey, and the whole roof rests on it. So “Is your beam strong?” is a Kashmiri saying. It means, “Can you look after me well?” “Oh! Of course,” said the farmer. “I see. Well, perhaps you can solve some of his other puzzles. As we walked along, he asked whether he should carry me or I should carry him. He thought that would be pleasanter.” “Certainly,” said the girl. “He meant that one of you should tell a story, to make the time pass.” “Ah, yes. Then we passed a cornfield, and he asked whether it was eaten or not.” “Didn’t you see what he meant, father? He wanted to know whether the owner was in debt. If he was, the crop was as good as eaten already. It would all go to the people he owed.”
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
The Daughter Explains
“Yes, yes, of course! Then, in a village, he told me to take his clasp-knife and get two horses with it, and to bring the knife back to him.” “Aren’t two stout sticks as good as two horses, to help one along the road? He only asked you to cut two sticks, and to take care not to lose his knife.” “I see,” said the farmer. “Then we walked all over the city. We saw no one we knew, and not a soul gave us a scrap to eat. But as we passed the cemetery, some people called us over and gave us chapatis and kulchas. So he called the city a cemetery and the cemetery a city.” “That makes sense too, father. A city is the place where everything can be had, and people who give nothing to strangers are worse than the dead. The city was full of people, but for you it was as good as dead. The cemetery was full of the dead, but there kind people greeted you and gave you bread.” “True, true!” said the farmer, amazed. “And just now, crossing the stream, he waded through without taking off his shoes and trousers.” “I admire him for that,” said the girl. “I have often thought how foolish people are to go barefoot into that fast stream, over those sharp stones. One slip, and they fall and are soaked from head to foot. This friend of yours is a very wise man. I would like to see him and talk with him.”
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
Full Moon, Twelve Months
“Very well,” said the farmer. “I will go and find him and bring him in.” “Tell him, father, that our beams are strong enough, and then he will come. And I will send a present ahead to him, to show him that we can afford to have him as our guest.” So she called a servant and sent him to the young man with a present: a basin of ghee, twelve chapatis and a jar of milk. With it went a message: “Friend, the moon is full, twelve months make a year, and the sea is overflowing.” Halfway there, the servant met his little son. The boy saw what was in the basket and begged for some of the food. His father foolishly gave him some. Then he found the young man and handed over the rest, with the message. “Give your mistress my greetings,” said the young man. “Tell her that the moon is new, and I can find only eleven months in the year. And the sea is not full at all.” The servant did not understand these words. He repeated them to his mistress just as he had heard them. In her message the full moon stood for the basin of ghee, the twelve months for the twelve chapatis, and the overflowing sea for the jar of milk. So his theft came to light, and he was severely punished.
The Farmer’s Clever Daughter
The Pit
Soon afterwards the young man came in with the old farmer. They paid him great attention and treated him in every way like the son of a great man, though his humble hosts knew nothing of who he was. At last he told them everything: the fish that laughed, the death that hung over his father, and how he himself had been sent away. He asked them what he should do. “The laughing of the fish has caused all this trouble,” said the girl. “It means that there is a man in the palace whom the king knows nothing about.” “Joy, joy!” cried the wazir’s son. “There is still time for me to go back and save my father from a shameful and unjust death.” The next day he hurried home, and he took the farmer’s daughter with him. As soon as he arrived, he ran to the palace and told his father what he had heard. The poor wazir, by now half dead from waiting for death, was carried straight to the king. He told him the news his son had brought. “Never!” said the king. “But it must be so, Your Majesty,” said the wazir. “To prove it, I beg you to call together all the women who serve in your palace. Have a pit dug, and order them to jump over it. The man will give himself away at once.” The king had the pit dug, and ordered all the palace women servants to try to jump it. They all tried, but only one cleared it. And that one turned out to be a man! So the queen was satisfied, and the faithful old wazir was saved. Afterwards, as soon as it could be arranged, the wazir’s son married the old farmer’s daughter, and a very happy marriage it was. Told in Kashmiri to J. Hinton Knowles in Srinagar in the 1880s, and printed in his Folk-Tales of Kashmir (1888). The teller was Lassu, a landholder of Sonwar, near Srinagar. The Kashmiri saying is “Viram kari chheyih dar?”, “Is your beam strong?” The fish’s laugh and its meaning are also told on this site, differently, in the Kathasaritsagara tale The Fish That Laughed.