Tales of the Sun and Other Stories
It Is for the Best
The Lost Finger
In a certain country there lived a king who had an unusual minister. Whatever the king asked him about, the minister always gave the same answer: “It is for the best.” One day the king lost one of his fingers while handling a sharp tool. He sent for the minister and showed him his hand. “See what a disaster has happened to me,” he said sadly. “I have lost one of my fingers.” The minister only answered calmly, “It is for the best.” The king was furious. “You wretch! How dare you say the loss of a finger is for the best? You shall see where your stupid motto gets you. You shall live in prison for twenty years!” But again the minister only said, “It is for the best.” At that the king sent him off to jail, crying, “What insolence!” So the minister was locked up. The next day the king went hunting in the forest. He always took his minister along, but now the minister was in prison, so he had to go all alone. After a long, tiring hunt, he lay down under a tree for a short sleep. Now, Hindus believe that a lion will not eat a man whose body is not whole. Soon the king heard a lion roar. The lord of the beasts had seen the lord of men and picked him out for his prey. The king thought he was as good as dead, and he fainted.
It Is for the Best
The Lion Goes Away
The lion came up and looked the fainting king over. When it saw the hand with a finger missing, it turned away and left him. A maimed king was no prey for a lion. When the king came to, he thought, “My good minister was right. But I thought only of myself, took his words the wrong way and put him in prison. If I had not lost that finger, the lion would have eaten me. So my loss has done me good. But what good can come of his being in prison? I shall hear from his own mouth what he meant.” So the king went back and at once ordered the minister to be set free and brought before him. He told him all about the lion, and how his words had come true so far. “But how can sending you to jail be for the best?” he asked. “My noble lord,” said the minister, “if I had not been in jail, I would have gone with you to the forest. The lion would have refused you because you were maimed, and then taken me for his feast instead. I would have died. So even my day in jail was for the best.” The king was very pleased with this answer, and he trusted his minister more than ever. Retold from Pandit S. M. Natesa Sastri’s Folklore in Southern India, It Is for the Best, printed in The Indian Antiquary (December 1888).