Kautilya's Arthashastra · The King and His Counsel
Seven Views on Ministers
सर्वमुपपन्नमिति कौटिल्यः । कार्यसामर्थ्याद्धि पुरुषसामर्थ्यं कल्प्यते ।
Whom should a king make his ministers? Seven earlier teachers answer, each rejecting the view before his own. Kautilya speaks last. Bharadvaja says: his classmates, for he knows their honesty and ability. Vishalaksha rejects this: old playmates will not respect him. He would choose men who share the king’s secrets and his vices, for they will never harm him, fearing he would tell theirs. Parashara answers that this fear cuts both ways: the king must then go along with whatever they do, and falls into the power of all who know his secrets. He would choose men who stood by the king when his life was in danger. Pishuna objects that this proves devotion, not ability. He would choose men who, set over revenue, brought in all that was fixed or more. Kaunapadanta says such men lack the other qualities. He would choose men whose fathers and grandfathers were ministers, for they will not desert the king even when offended, as cows keep to their own herd. Vatavyadhi replies that such families take hold of the king and play king themselves. He would choose new men, learned in government, who would not dare offend him. The son of Bahudanti answers that theory alone blunders in real work. He would choose men of good family, wise, honest, brave and loyal. “All of this is sound,” says Kautilya, “for a man’s ability is judged by what he has shown in work.” So none of these kinds is ruled out; each man is used where his record fits, as to place, time and task. But such men are to be the king’s officers, the amatyas, not his counsellors. His inner counsellors, who weigh secret plans with him, are chosen with stricter care in the chapters that follow. Book 1, chapter 8.