Kautilya's Arthashastra · The King and His Counsel
Three or Four Advisers
न इति कौटिल्यः । अनवस्था ह्येषा । मन्त्रिभिस्त्रिभिश्चतुर्भिर्वा सह मन्त्रयेत ।
“No,” says Kautilya, “that has no end. He should take counsel with three or four ministers.” The answer closes a debate on how a king should take advice. Bharadvaja says the king should weigh secret matters alone. Ministers have their own advisers, and those have theirs, and so secrets leak. Vishalaksha disagrees: one mind alone cannot see what is hidden, settle what is doubtful, or judge the whole from a part. The king should sit with men of wide understanding. He should despise no one and hear everyone’s view; a wise man uses even a child’s sensible words. Parashara objects that this gathers opinions but gives the secret away. The king should ask his ministers about a case like his own, as if it were only supposed, and do as they decide. Pishuna objects in turn: asked about something remote, ministers answer half-heartedly. The king should consult only those who know the matter in hand. Kautilya finds all this endless. With one minister alone, a hard question may never be settled, and that one man acts as he likes, unchecked. With two, the king may be overpowered when they join hands, or put in danger when they quarrel. With three or four he will come to no great harm and reach good results. With more, decisions come slowly and secrets are hard to keep. Still, as place, time and the work require, he may consult one or two, or decide alone. Book 1, chapter 15.